Quote:
Originally Posted by WorkEthic
The ectomorph, endomorph, mesomorph stuff is overrated too. If you eat enough and at the right times and lift with a solid plan based on progressing, you'll grow. Different genetic make-ups will have certain people growing faster than others, but if you're consistent, you'll grow.
Absolutely wrong. This is way much too much of a lazy and sloppy blanket statement.
First of all, it assumes a sort of lock-step among types. In real life, people do different things, no matter what type they are. Diet, exercise, stress, sleep, etc., are all individual. And ectomorphs either exist or they don't. If they do, then we can fairly discuss variance among types. If they don't, or if you are arguing they don't, then we are on a whole different plane of argument.
If they do, then their results vs. those of others are distinct. And according to existing science (screw my opinion) they are indeed distinct.
Time for anecdotes? Seem so, and why not.
In my own case (f*ck me!), as a very active ectomorph from 8 years old on, there isn't a single friend I saw not advance in weightlifting further than myself. Yes, this is the age at which I started resistance training.
In fact I introduced ALL OF my friends pre-20-ish years old to weightlifting. And not a single one didn't progress further in terms of either strength or mass than I did, and in short order. This despite the fact that I ate like crazy. My parents even told me I needed to cool down, because from about ten years old on, I ate twice as much as my dad if not more, and was hungry again about two hours later(if not one hour later!). And then later again that same evening. I was not proud. I was not finicky. And I was eating them out of house and home.
Luckily, I had indulgent parents in this respect for the most part, and my mother went out to local chicken/egg farms and got me big slabs of eggs, in either 6 x 6 flats if I recall correctly, four stacks at a time. I ate like a fiend and gobbled raw eggs like Rocky (I'm old) every single day, sometimes multiple times per day, before Sylvester Stallone was Rocky.
The result? Pretty much nothing. I watched as my friends within weeks or a couple of months achieved great results on the programs I had designed for them and did myself.
It was a lifelong slap in the face until I started deadlifting.
Last edited by Blarg; 12-07-2008 at 02:45 AM.