Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
EDF MMA November Thread EDF MMA November Thread

11-20-2009 , 06:23 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by boozy
The cardio of top MMA guys is far and above any other athlete in any other sport and its not even remotely close. Its not even debaatable
contrary to popular belief, motocross (yes dirtbike racing) is WAY up on the list, very close to soccer.


220lb bike, 30 min +2 lap moto (twice), it's a SUPER demanding sport cardio wise- dudes have amazing gastanks.
11-20-2009 , 06:36 AM
The problem with MMA judging right now is it rewards stalling. If you just clinch your opponent up against the fence you get the edge, bare hug him inside his guard you get the edge, pin him in side mount, merely defend a takedown.

I think fights should be based on 3 criteria.

Damage inflicted. If I was in a fight, at the end if I inflicted more damage to my opponent than he put on me, I'd feel like I won the fight. I think this is the most important criteria to judge and we should only look at the others when this is close. So quantity and quality of strikes landed.

2nd and 3rd would be attempts to finish the fight and aggression. Attempt to finish is close submission attempts and coming close to finishing it through strikes. So if fighters were equal in damage I'd look at who had their opponent defending more submissions. Aggression to me means pursuing the other two, strikes and submissions. Not spending 2 minutes attempting a takedown. Or caging your opponent. It means pursuing him with strikes standing or on the ground, and attacking him with submissions.

I think positions shouldn't be scored on their merit alone. If the mount is so good, you'll score off it by your effective striking and submission attempts. If you aren't able to do anything from mount but pin your opponent, then why should that score significant points? You also don't score points from defending takedown attempts. All that does is leave you even with your opponent. Gotta damage your opponent or put him at risk of tap'ing.

These rules would make for more exciting fights, and more accurate judging where the guy who beat his opponent up or really put the pressure on him would win the decision.
11-20-2009 , 08:00 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by willie
contrary to popular belief, motocross (yes dirtbike racing) is WAY up on the list, very close to soccer.


220lb bike, 30 min +2 lap moto (twice), it's a SUPER demanding sport cardio wise- dudes have amazing gastanks.

+1 on this, had several friends who were serious about motorcross when they were a bit younger, crazy demanding
11-20-2009 , 11:01 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by boozy
The cardio of top MMA guys is far and above any other athlete in any other sport and its not even remotely close. Its not even debaatable
I think that you are looking at this wrong. Most professional athletes are going to be in amazing condition for the kind of activity that there sport requires. MMA fighters are required to be able to go for multiple five minute rounds. An NFL player would never want to set up there workout to be able to do that. They want to be as explosive as possible for a very short period.
11-20-2009 , 12:34 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by DannyOcean_
I agree. If you look at 170 and under, nearly every fighter is

ripped
strong as hell
quick as hell
cardio machine
crazy hand/eye
crazy reflexes
crazy flexible
etc

Think guys like Aldo, Brown, Torres, Bowles, Sherk, Faber, Penn, GSP, (prime) Hughes, Koscheck, Rumble, Alves, etc.

These guys are all crazy good athletes. They couldn't play in the NFL or NBA because of height/weight, but they are still incredible and world class athletes.
yeah, those guys are. but the 500th best player in the NFL is still an insane, NFL caliber athlete. the 6th best welterweight (ok not really) is paulo thiago
11-20-2009 , 12:42 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by DannyOcean_
I think it's fairly safe to say Lesnar could be an NFL starter at minimum if he had played through college. He still has one of the best combine performances of the last decade.
Some people already now this, but the guy who narrowly beat Brock for the college HW championship in Brock's junior year was Stephen Neal, who is currently a starting O-lineman for the Patriots despite not playing football in college.
11-20-2009 , 01:56 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by willie
i agree with this. i'm a huge faber fanboy and didn't know if i'd ever see him lose at 145 then he got caught by brown the 1st time, then had to fight the entire second fight with 1 hand....

i think faber wouldn't even be close to a walkthrough for aldo.

i think he's back in action in early 2010.
Faber wouldn't be a walk over for any fighter. I think Aldo would take a comfortable decision though. But would have to be an exciting fight and I would love to see Faber get a shot soon.
11-20-2009 , 02:45 PM
What a triangle that would make if Faber gets a title shot and takes Aldos strap.
11-20-2009 , 02:56 PM
I was also thinking about how messed up it could make the wec if Aldo decided to go down to 135. He could probably take the belt there too but then they'll almost never be airing title defenses. And if he loses then the 135 champ is better than the 145 champ? weird stuff when it comes to moving down.
11-20-2009 , 03:05 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by willie
1st off, bench press has NOTHING to do with grip. if he was deadlifting you might have an argument

2nd- mike tyson was punching old women in the teeth at 14.
Agreed on point 2...
But your way wrong about grip and bench... There is a huge and obvious correlation between someones bench press and their grip strength. You would have to be ******ed not too see that correlation. I challenge you to find someone with a 400 lb bench press with a weak grip....You WONT find him.

This is even more pronounced with individuals with little strength training yet have sick natural bench press strength...They are gonna be stong every where else and grip strength is no exception.

I dont wanna turn this into a strength and conditioning thread but saying grip has nothing to do with bench is really naive. I dunno how much weight training experience you have but do some research on how grip strength helps a bench press.You will learn that saying "bench press has NOTHING to do with grip" is absurd.
11-20-2009 , 04:32 PM
wow i hate karo. He backs out of every goddamn fight. I was really excited to see hazelett. ..his armar on josh burkman is one of my favorite submissions ever
11-20-2009 , 04:52 PM
I'm really excited for this card. Amir and NYBA is LOL and I love it! Kos and Rumble is going to be fun too. The consensus is that Josh will hold Rumble down and pound him to a decision or what? Rumble's tank expires early after take downs and not being able to KO him? I need to watch the Clementi fight.
11-20-2009 , 04:52 PM
koscheck has taken down something like one fighter in 4 years
11-20-2009 , 04:55 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Phresh
I'm really excited for this card. Amir and NYBA is LOL and I love it! Kos and Rumble is going to be fun too. The consensus is that Josh will hold Rumble down and pound him to a decision or what? Rumble's tank expires early after take downs and not being able to KO him? I need to watch the Clementi fight.
yeah im putting money onto a sportsbook just to bet it on baroni. Amir has 0 chance imo.
11-20-2009 , 04:58 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Phresh
I'm really excited for this card. Amir and NYBA is LOL and I love it! Kos and Rumble is going to be fun too. The consensus is that Josh will hold Rumble down and pound him to a decision or what? Rumble's tank expires early after take downs and not being able to KO him? I need to watch the Clementi fight.
kind of my opinion on it except i think rumble gets finished. Koscheck doesn't have brutal gnp but rumble has no ground game so I can see him going full chimpanzee on him. I'm sure that after the paulo thiago loss, kos isn't going to play around with the standup too much.
11-20-2009 , 05:00 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by gimmetheloot
yeah im putting money onto a sportsbook just to bet it on baroni. Amir has 0 chance imo.
you really think so? this isn't a fight that I'm interested in like everyone else. People are just excited to see Baroni back in the ufc. But I really think Baroni will gas and Amir will sub him late or take a decision.

but you're the guy with the baroni avatar so maybe i'm not completely alone
11-20-2009 , 05:43 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Count Chocula
i think lesnar has a lot more than just nfl "potential" imo. but that's just imo yeah...
I agree 100%. If the guy would have started playing football in Pop Warner, it is scary what he would be able to do on a football field on any level.

But that is just it.... 1 amazing athlete in the UFC with very little MMA experience is dominating. You don't think the same would apply at other weight limits?
11-20-2009 , 05:45 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by agdci981
I have heard that Lesnar would have made the Vikings if he wasn't Brock Lesnar.....
He didn't make it because of his age. The fact that he made the final cut shows exactly how good of an athlete he is.

Basically Brock had no clue what he was doing on a football field, but his sheer size+power+athletic ability+motor almost got him on the team. He would have been a project and he was simply too old to develop. If he would have tried out after college, he would have made the team. It had absolutely nothing to do with his name.
11-20-2009 , 05:59 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Count Chocula
you really think so? this isn't a fight that I'm interested in like everyone else. People are just excited to see Baroni back in the ufc. But I really think Baroni will gas and Amir will sub him late or take a decision.

but you're the guy with the baroni avatar so maybe i'm not completely alone
I think baroni has a solid 1.5 rounds and will KO him within that time, and if not can gut out another 1.5 and hopefully get semi-lucky and KO him. Its also definitely not crazy to have baroni solidly win R1, edge out R2 and lose R3 to win a decision

How good are Amirs takedowns?
11-20-2009 , 06:49 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by gehrig
koscheck has taken down something like one fighter in 4 years
Yeah but he got KO'd by Paulo and he knows what a beast Rumble is on the feet. You still think he'll try and stand?
11-20-2009 , 06:56 PM
i moreso think that kos might not be a great wrestler anymore
11-20-2009 , 07:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jlp_2908
Agreed on point 2...
But your way wrong about grip and bench... There is a huge and obvious correlation between someones bench press and their grip strength. You would have to be ******ed not too see that correlation. I challenge you to find someone with a 400 lb bench press with a weak grip....You WONT find him.

This is even more pronounced with individuals with little strength training yet have sick natural bench press strength...They are gonna be stong every where else and grip strength is no exception.

I dont wanna turn this into a strength and conditioning thread but saying grip has nothing to do with bench is really naive. I dunno how much weight training experience you have but do some research on how grip strength helps a bench press.You will learn that saying "bench press has NOTHING to do with grip" is absurd.

ok, you caught me i have no idea what i'm takling about.

pressing infinitely stresses the grip muscles, you're correct sir. despite the bar being basically straightlined to the forearm causing no need to grip the bar like gravity is pulling it down out of your hand

you're definitely right..

a 400lb bench press guy wouldn't have a weak grip cause his BP is just SO massive, it probably has nothing to do that he also does a lot of work on other excercises that actually strain his hand strength.


what are you blabbering about dude. bp stresses tri shoulders and pecs primarily. this is not something you're going to make me reevaluate no matter how many times you say naive or insinuate that i'm clueless.

look at the design of the body and path of movement of the excercise, and then just stop talking.
11-20-2009 , 07:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by gehrig
i moreso think that kos might not be a great wrestler anymore
rofl
11-20-2009 , 07:25 PM
Can anybody legit here make a $500 trade with me.. 500 on 5d for cash on ftp?

Last edited by gimmetheloot; 11-20-2009 at 07:37 PM.
11-20-2009 , 08:10 PM
These caved-in stomachs during weigh in are so disgusting.

      
m