Gus, you're the one that said "Just don't buy an expensive citizen or other Japanese watch when you can just buy a cheaper Swiss watch "
You can't come back with
"Your standard Seiko or Citizen is like $200. If you can get a Swiss watch for that cheap, it's obviously going to be garbage, and you are definitely better off getting a Japanese watch. We are talking about watches close to $1000."
If we're going to talk about $1000 to $2000 range. There are very few Seikos or Citizens in this range anyways. And I would argue that the Seikos in this range are actually more watch for the buck, such as the MarineMaster 300 which uses Grand Seiko movements.
You have no knowledge of Swiss watchmaking history if you are going to discount Grand Seiko. Grand Seikos are timed to higher tolerances in more positions than COSC and they offer you in house highly decorated movements with immaculate case and dial work for 80% of Rolex prices. Seiko actually won numerous Swiss timing competitions until the Swiss got embarrased and decided to stop the competitions.
a good article from purist pro on Grand Seikos
http://general.watchprosite.com/show...ost/ti-400171/
Swiss watches are expensive because they spend a crapload of money on advertising and its obvious that it is working. Are they worth the money? well thats watch specific and up to the user to decide. I happen to own several but I don't discount non Swiss makers. Also, to disregard quartz watches as 'crap' is quite the fallacy as well as it runs more accurately with fewer need for mechanical maintenance. By definition quartz watches aren't crap. They may lack romanticism or soul but they perform as intended with more functions much more so than mechanical.
But since you believe quartz is crap then for those shopping in the sub $400 mechanical watch category, their options when going Swiss is going to be very limited. On the other hand, Seiko and watches powered by Miyota provides an excellent option in this price range.
The majority of $1000 to $4000 swiss mechanical watches will be generic ETA sourced calibers that makes very little difference whether you buy a TAG or a Breitling or an IWC or 'lesser' brands such as Tissot or Hamilton. You can't get in to in house manufacture at this price range. But you can if you step abroad in to Seiko or boutique German brands like Nomos.
There is no best. Watches, like any other goods, has endless levels of upsmanship. One day, you will have your ALS or PP or VC and then see that the guy next to you is wearing a Voutilainen or Dufour and its going to again turn around everything you thought you knew about what you wanted in a watch.