Quote:
Originally Posted by GoCubsGo
But religion greatly assists large unified empires, with lots of people within those empires not killing each other.
Drunk, going to argue. I trust you look at this post after looking at my prior disagreement over whether religion is the worst thing ever.
You can't argue the quoted point without separating religion from empire. You do not do that. I do not think it is possible to do that. But by anecdote - the largest empire in human history was the British empire. It was founded on arms, trade, capitalism and if you were lucky, democracy.
Quote:
Originally Posted by GoCubsGo
This also allowed for much more rapid spread of information, technology, trade, etc.
Dark ages.
Quote:
Originally Posted by GoCubsGo
Didn't all the African kingdoms and Native American tribes war with each other, well before big religion found them?
Only because that's how we define big religion. They were religious, it's just that their religions lost. Survivor bias is not an argument.
Quote:
Originally Posted by GoCubsGo
Also, the man responsible for more deaths than any other, Josef Stalin, represented a movement that outlawed religion. So your claim looks pretty silly now, doesn't it?
Disagree. Hitler was a Catholic, conventional wisdom aside. Also disagree that because someone did something terrible for an unrelated reason, does not mean that religion is valid. Also disagree about the man with the most deaths on his hands. How many men did God directly/indirectly kill in the old testament? As a proportion of the humans on the planet at the time?
Quote:
Originally Posted by GoCubsGo
Religious people are apparently happier than non-religious.
Am going to get in trouble for this bit, but - so? Stupid people are happier than smart people. Accepting easy answers makes you happy. That doesn't give those answers validity. And if we avoid that point - happiness is not necessary to lead a valid life.
Quote:
Originally Posted by GoCubsGo
Gives them a purpose in life, creates greater cooperation between people (as long as they're of the same faith)
Have to /close the quote there.
Quote:
Originally Posted by GoCubsGo
I believe that there is some genetic component (i.e. personality) and obviously an environmental component to believing
To have the PROPENSITY to believe, yes. But clearly no genetic component to believing in a specific thing. Doesn't that tell you something?