Open Side Menu Go to the Top

08-14-2012 , 03:46 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NajdorfDefense
My pov is that DFW had strong, negative views about the *overuse* of irony in today's fiction. He clearly tweaks the reader who knows this with a few ironic touches.

YMMV, but 'playful,' nor 'self-referential' are not synonyms to me for 'ironic.'

Also we need to separate the traditional 1990s view of irony, with the Shakespearean, Hamlet use of dramatic 'irony.' Clearly DFW uses the latter version throughout the book, but I think we both agree that's not what you meant.
you're right, there are enough competing ideas of exactly what constitutes irony that i should a) try to avoid conflating postmodern and ironic, and b) try to work out exactly what DFW means by it.
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread Quote
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread
$25m Guaranteed WPM on CoinPoker
Join the action now
Daily Rewards • Splash Pots • CoinRaces
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread
08-14-2012 , 04:58 AM
Can I tackle this book with a dictionary or do I need some kind of super brain?
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread Quote
08-14-2012 , 12:03 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by lonely_but_rich
Can I tackle this book with a dictionary or do I need some kind of super brain?
You just need two tools I lack right now. Time, and a rudimentary amount of focus.
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread Quote
08-15-2012 , 03:07 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shark Sandwich
SPOILER DON'T CLICK IF YOU HAVEN'T READ THE BOOK

Spoiler:
FAIR WARNING
Spoiler:
This is never really answered is it? There's the mold theory, which seems most plausible, the DMZ-dosed toothbrush theory (i.e. ghostly JOI stole Pemulis's stash and used it on Hal), and the he-watched-Infinite-Jest theory, but it's not clear which one is responsible for Hal going nuts. Not that it matters I guess, since it all ultimately leads to the same result
Spoiler:
Yeah, "a manifestation of something other than social awkwardness" is how I'd put what I was referring to.
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread Quote
08-15-2012 , 05:47 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ineedaride2
You just need two tools I lack right now. Time, and a rudimentary amount of focus.
I would listen to it at work while driving but they didn't record the endnotes for the audiobook.
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread Quote
08-15-2012 , 06:35 PM
god forbid you do the audiobook of IJ. Plz no.
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread Quote
08-15-2012 , 09:20 PM
they HAVE an audiobook for IJ how frickin long is that thing? also, like it's been said before itt, the endnotes are absolutely crucial.

i'm finishing this tonight imo.
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread Quote
08-15-2012 , 10:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NajdorfDefense
god forbid you do the audiobook of IJ. Plz no.
Plz explain ?
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread Quote
08-15-2012 , 10:20 PM
infinite jizz would make a good adult film. still no sign of the amazon delivery. arab crooks.
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread Quote
08-19-2012 , 06:09 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NajdorfDefense
Also, the Eschaton part is the bomb.
Le Culte du Prochain Train > Eschaton, imo
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread Quote
08-19-2012 , 06:48 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by lonely_but_rich
Can I tackle this book with a dictionary or do I need some kind of super brain?
Lonely, I've read a lot of books in my day, and I honestly don't think this book is worth the trouble. I don't think it's worth even 10% of the trouble.

I would recommend that you try reading 2 novels by Jonathan Franzen instead: The Corrections and Freedom. Wallace and Franzen were friends and contemporaries. Franzen's novels are readable. And no ****ing footnotes.
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread Quote
08-19-2012 , 09:31 AM
Thanks for the heads up, kioshk. Maybe Infinite Jest was written as a joke on people who read it.
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread Quote
08-19-2012 , 02:05 PM
I LOVED Freedom. Corrections is on my short list. This is good short reading too.
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread Quote
08-19-2012 , 02:23 PM
Anyone who doesn't think DFW is 'readable' is flat out trolling.

Just read 'Girl with Curious Hair' collection, and if it's not your thing, then nvm IJ.
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread Quote
08-19-2012 , 02:51 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NajdorfDefense
Anyone who doesn't think DFW is 'readable' is flat out trolling.

Just read 'Girl with Curious Hair' collection, and if it's not your thing, then nvm IJ.
I think he meant compared to IJ, not Wallace.
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread Quote
08-19-2012 , 09:41 PM
Sometimes people can have different opinions about things without any "trolling" being involved, as shocking as they may seem to some.
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread Quote
08-20-2012 , 06:25 AM
I do like most of Wallace's essays.
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread Quote
08-20-2012 , 10:03 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kioshk
Sometimes people can have different opinions about things without any "trolling" being involved, as shocking as they may seem to some.
Wait, are you trolling me right now?
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread Quote
08-20-2012 , 08:58 PM
This must be an uber-level troll. Nice work!
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread Quote
08-22-2012 , 06:55 AM
Gotta say, I'm mostly reading it for the sake of finishing it, now. I'm at, like, 70% on the kindle (the main text ends in the 80%s, I'm at 98% when reading footnotes), and I've largely fallen out of love with it. It's odd, because I really like two of the three major threads of the book - the tennis and the drugs - but the pacing seems all wrong. Whilst it's entertaining enough, nothing of any note has happened for like 300 pages. That's a book, right there.
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread Quote
08-22-2012 , 05:41 PM
I gotta be honest, I have *no idea* what people mean when they say things like 'Nothing happened for x00 pages' in any book.

You could say the same thing about the entire last half of Lolita [save one quick scene.] People I consider smart, well-educated say this about various Great Novels that I've enjoyed and I just....it's like they are speaking Gaelic, it doesn't register at all with me. A Fan's Notes, same thing.

It's not Stephen King. It's not Hardy boys. It's not Robert Howard. It's not Agatha Christie. Many things happened on those pages. It's not a plot-driven novel, as you obviously have noticed by now.

I mean, you could say he's too verbose, too difficult for today's reader, too post-modern, trying to hard to be clever, any number of criticisms, but...that one I do not grok.

Last edited by NajdorfDefense; 08-22-2012 at 05:46 PM.
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread Quote
08-23-2012 , 02:36 PM
I dunno, it seems to me that the book as a whole has much more of an overall narrative direction than other really big books that i've read recently - 2666, Against the Day, Life and Fate being the three that spring to mind. Perversely, having a sense of where the book is going but not having it going there seems to make me feel the weight of the 1000 pages much more than in these other books where stuff just happens with no obvious direction to it.

To be a bit more specific:
Spoiler:
At some point midway through the book there is a section in which Hal and the other tennis players decide to try out the mega drug (WMD was it?) that they've got their hands on. That pretty much seems to set up the likely resolution to the question that the book opens with - wtf is it that's going on with Hal in the interview. Thereafter, all the tennis scenes are frustrating because they just aren't advancing that plot arc at all. If the arc wasn't there, no problem - I was enjoying reading about the tennis before that point - but to have it sketched out and then not followed up on has given me a major case of the blueballs.
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread Quote
08-24-2012 , 08:47 PM
Okay, I hear you there. Noted and a logical complaint.

But like you said, if we decide to go with it is/part of the callback to the opening...where else would it go?

I did feel there was plenty of drug discussion at the Academy so maybe he felt even more would be too much? Maybe it was in the 200 or so pages that got cut...

I really loved ETA and the Halfway House. I even loved the pun/injoke about calling the tennis academy ETA.
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread Quote
08-28-2012 , 02:51 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kokiri
Gotta say, I'm mostly reading it for the sake of finishing it, now. I'm at, like, 70% on the kindle (the main text ends in the 80%s, I'm at 98% when reading footnotes), and I've largely fallen out of love with it. It's odd, because I really like two of the three major threads of the book - the tennis and the drugs - but the pacing seems all wrong. Whilst it's entertaining enough, nothing of any note has happened for like 300 pages. That's a book, right there.
I finished it now, and I fell back in love with it as it came to an end. I'm not about to flip the book over and start again from page 1 (hello self reference!), which I guess I'd really need to do to really get under the skin, but I'm definitely glad I did read it.
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread Quote
08-28-2012 , 11:50 PM
I re-read it like ~14 years later [the whole thing I mean, not just bits and pieces.]

Prob re-read it in another 5-6 years this time.
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread Quote
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread
$25m Guaranteed WPM on CoinPoker
Join the action now
Daily Rewards • Splash Pots • CoinRaces
The Infinite Jest reading, discussion and support group thread

      
m