Quote:
Originally Posted by PartyGirlUK
Listening to 2018 Booker winner Milkman. Multiple reviews suggested it was a 'hard book', perhaps easier to listen to than read but I'm not so sure. It's tough going. A first person quasi stream of consciousness style - the narrator has a tendency to duplicate, stating essentially the same thing consecutively in multiple different ways - I find this annoying and suspect it would be less so had I the option to quickly skip over the repetitions. A particularly jarring example is when she lists all the name Catholics (during The Troubles) were 'banned' from giving their babies. They took a couple of (tedious) minutes to list but if reading I'd power through them all in ~10 seconds. Not sure if I'll finish this, haven't listened for a couple of days and not feeling the urge to dip back in. We'll see.
After a few months took this back up , got 2/3 through and switched to the paper version which was much better. Look, it's an interesting book written by a clearly talented writer. It's creative & taught me, I think, what it was like growing up in a ten child Belfast family during the Troubles. But the narrator's voice is annoying. Take, for example, this paragraph highlighted in the NYT's
review (which is too harsh)
Quote:
“No matter the reservations held then — as to methods and morals and about the various groupings that came into operation or which from the outset already had been in operation; no matter too, that for us, in our community, on ‘our side of the road,’ the government here was the enemy, and the police here was the enemy, and the government ‘over there’ was the enemy, and the soldiers from ‘over there’ were the enemy, and the defender-paramilitaries from ‘over the road’ were the enemy and, by extension — thanks to suspicion and history and paranoia — the hospital, the electricity board, the gas board, the water board, the school board, telephone people and anybody wearing a uniform or garments easily to be mistaken for a uniform also were the enemy, and where we were viewed in our turn by our enemies as the enemy — in those dark days, which were the extreme of days, if we hadn’t had the renouncers as our underground buffer between us and this overwhelming and combined enemy, who else, in all the world, would we have had?”
That needs editing. A number of reviews say
Milkman is a short story spun out over 368 pages (some of those mean it as a compliment). There is truth to this. e.g IMO if you gave a talented editor a week they could produce a 200 page version by removing entire chapters and cutting out a bunch of repetition and it wouldn't read like an abridged book and would possibly be superior. Milkman is not a bad book, perhaps it's a good book - but it's not a Booker winner.