Quote:
Originally Posted by ianlippert
Is the second book also good? I loved the first one but I have heard some really mixed reviews of the second. Basically that it doesnt progress any of the mysteries that were set up in the first one and that it rambles and could use a series edit. I am holding off on reading the second until the third one comes out, if the third is as great as the first then I will probably continue with that series.
I agree with what you have heard in that the 2nd volume of the Kingkiller Chronicles isn't the equal of the first. The Name of the Wind is wonderful. The Wise Man's Fear is slightly less wonderful.
It suffers from the same problem that so many middle volumes of trilogies or even longer series suffer from in that there is neither a true beginning nor a true end e.g., the Two Towers is great but taken on its own merits is inferior to The Fellowship of the Ring and is considerably less compelling than the Return of the King. Put the three together and you have a masterpiece.
When dealing with series like this I think it's important to remember just because you are reading a different physical book doesn't mean you are reading a different story. Too much is made of not "advancing the plot" or "leaving loose ends." It's the writer's story and he will wrap things up or answer the overarching questions of the plot/mythology/world when he decides to, if at all. Just enjoy the ride and realize that all of the big questions will likely be answered and hopefully most of the small ones as well.
If you loved The Name of the Wind then you owe it to yourself to read the next book.