Quote:
Originally Posted by vhawk01
Yeah, the ranking of those four goes:
Long Walk>Rage>Running Man>Roadwork, dont think any of them are particularly arguable. Long Walk is really good, my favorite of his short stories I think.
Just finished Long Walk and I totally disagree with it being the best story in the collection. To me the story was just as boring as a really long walk would be, drawn out and with no real climax. I mean, a few parts were cool about, like the conflicts and story telling between some of the walkers, the warnings and executions by the soldiers on the jeep, and the effects of the built up fatigue, but after these same things happened a dozen times, I became really bored of the book. Not to mention that it doesn't even explain the end of the race, and who was the winner*.
I would much rather read about the antics of the crazy guy in Road Work, the suspense of Running Man, and the psychology of Rage, so for me the ranking is:
Road Work, Running Man, Rage > Long Walk (the first three are interchangeable, imo.)
*I'm actually confused about that part. It said that he was the last surviving competitor, but then again it also never described the executions of like 4 other walkers who were supposedly still competing. This coupled with the fact that the narration became kinda of incoherent, since it was told from the main character's POV, really had me unsure of who ended up winning.