You're trolling me.

You're like actually trolling me.

the blahblah was just cus you just kinda repeated yourself in the bottom half of the post

not trolling

*shrug* Fair enough.

You think I am wolfy.

You think Gad is wolfy.

The natural conclusion is that we are w/w.

Unless

You think one or both of us is wolfy but a villager.

Otherwise the pairing is automatically w/w.

So of course you would have to think it.

You already said you think Gad is an outed wolf.

You restated earlier when I specifically asked you that that read hasn't changed.

So for that to be terrible, you are saying that you find me wolfy but ultimately think I'm a villager.

In which case, if you are a villager, why why why why would you be doing this.

There is just no reason.

And you refuse to state if you think I'm a wolf.

If you do, Gad and are auto w/w for you.

I mean, wtf.

Ooooooooooooh.

no this is wrong

Alright, let's try something different EADGBE.

Your reads are fluid beautiful changing things la la la.

In this moment, aorn,

Do you think I'm MORE LIKELY to be a villager or a wolf?

pretty sure now that both EADGBE and Noah are villa

Are you claiming neutral?

no, im saying that just because you think A is wolfy and B is wolfy does not mean you think A and B are w/w

Gadarene's blah blah blah

Village lean
Anarchist
EADGBE
Necro
Noah
TimeLady

No particular lean
TheNothing

Skeptical face
captain binkles

Wolf lean
Applejack
Evene
Supine

Lynch from the bottom up and we win almost always imo

I addressed that very thing in the post.

if you thought A was 40% to be a wolf and B was 40% to be a wolf, they'd both be "wolfy", but the chance they're w/w is only 16%

Anarchist is right here

conditional probabilities ftw

EADGBE refuses to state whether he thinks I'm a wolf or not.

AORN, today, whatever.

This is my point.

Are you deliberately trying to miss it?

......

This is not a discussion about probabilities.

I simply asked EADGBE whether he thinks I'm a wolf or not, given that he finds me wolfy.

But it's all about probabilities. He can't think you're a wolf; he can only think you're wolfy.

kinda torn

as a wolf ive seen you kinda lay down and die under pressure

and you fight as a villager

so metawise youre villagy

but youre not really getting heat right now, and your game has improved alot judging by the mystery mash game

and youve had alot of bad posts

id bet wolf right now

You can't know if someone is a wolf or not, unless you are one.

Of course you can think it.

wat

Was gonna quote TL's assessment and I agree with the sentiment as well. Thought Noah was funky earlier but the way they are going at each other feels like v/v to me too.

Finally.

itt, EADGBE thinks I'm a wolf.

Thank you.

Whatevs, then "think you're a wolf" and "think you're wolfy" are effectively the same thing. We're all dealing with incomplete information (wolves aren't, obv).

TheNothing, what do you think of my reads list?

And what do you think of the fact that you're the only person on it that isn't assigned a lean?

Then why would he not just say that?

I find you wolfy, of course I think you're a wolf, they are about the same thing anyway.

I'm not him. But I don't understand the distinction you're trying to draw.

If he thinks I'm wolfy and he thinks you're wolfy, he doesn't necessarily have to think we're w/w.

If he thinks I'm a wolf and he thinks you're a wolf, he doesn't necessarily have to think we're w/w IF "thinks you're a wolf" and "thinks you're wolfy" are effectively the same thing. And "thinks you're a wolf" and "thinks you're wolfy" HAVE TO BE effectively the same thing (albeit maybe at differing confidence levels), because villagers are dealing with incomplete information.