Thingy outted me.

JD and tarheels

somehow my inner nichp27 is also a stoned hippy. I can't explain it

ya, wasn't blaming you, just saying that outing each other is pretty bad

those 2 aren't bad i guess - i don't really remember anything from them which probably means they're good choices

i posted part of my reasoning on thinking oti is a wolf and he responded that it was a good line of thinking and called me a villager rather than defending himself

i dont like when people do that

he also had that ridiculous interaction with derwi that was more villagery than not

I could swear that you at some point used the "I can't remember anything from that person" as a reason for why a person WASN'T a good wolf suspect.

wn officially joins my villa lean club

thingy,

Can you give me a list of your reads plz.

HMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM?

wagon != nk

post thingy omitted regarding unmemorable peeps

note this was prior to derwi's lynch and i was obv advocating both derwi/digger lynches

Chris - u gave the shank to mcavoy? why are you so confident he is a villager?

hmmm... off the top of my head:

villa leans (alphabetized):
biggerboat
chrisrjdk
coordi
Forsythio
Maruchan
McAvoy
RollWave
Thread Cat, imo
XXsooted

Then there are people who I have noticed SOME villagery stuff from, but who I don't really want to place on my villa list yet, but who I at least wouldn't want to wagon at this very moment: darthrob, housenuts, J.D., tarheeljks

Consider the rest wolf leans.

But I haven't done a reread yet and I've been slacking on my note-taking, so they're probably not the greatest reads in the world.

in finding that post i just quoted, i remembered that really long JD post had that was villagery. but he didn't really do well after that.

I'm curious thingy, why do you have a villa lean on coordi when he has like 9 posts.?

OK, I spent a lot of time trying to decide who to shank last night.

Tarheels jumped out at me because he's basically done nothing. Read him plz. He's just asked some weird questions and hasn't voted once (that I can find). I had to go pretty far back to find a game he was in, but I found one (can't remember now - do a search in this forum and you'll find it). But, he was extremely conscious in that game about who he put a vote on and why. He has done nothing like that this game.

JD has been giving me wolf vibes from d1. His entrance here is similar to a previous wolf game (LOTR I think - can't remember because I read several of his games). The reason I didn't pick him is because of his late day activity. Since the wagons have all been non-wolf I would think he wouldn't be as vocal about things.

DMK has not, until today, tried to do anything except just say XXX is a wolf. He is usually pretty involved in the game itself (commenting on theory or mechanics or play). He's starting to today. Also, he is still alive - he's usually an early wolf target. Picking him was tough because if he's a villager I don't want to kill him. I'm not thoroughly convinced on his role atm. Waffling itt.

In hindsight, I probably should have tried to take out tarheels, but I like that dmk has started talking.

because making up reads is easy

I feel i can read him okay and i got a really villagery vibe from him yesterday(although why is he playing so serious, this being a mish mash?)

Also i was a little tilted and i thought IF he is a wolf maybe he is playing kind to me in the hopes that i would pass him the shank, and then he would kill me with it.

The fact he did'nt makes me even more confident of him being a villager

Let me emulate Dustin: tone

But, no really, I quickly compared his posts to the Lost game and his whole way of behaving is quite different, and he had a specific reply to bigger which I found quite villagery.

additional possibility to consider re wahoo's fake intent to peek bsball last night: bsball is a wolf and was afraid wahoo would peek him as such

not having me on a villa list is a crime

Well, we are in prison.

WP.

all of us may be standing in the gutter, but some of us are looking at the stars, imo

I had a villa lean on tarheel from his naive oti comments yesterday, so i'm glad you chose not to go after him. also today - he didn't articulate it well, but I think he is spot on about the cphoya kill. Cphoya was killed by abruzzi, who i suspect is a neutral sk just like tbag. Neutrals need to survive as long as possible, regardless of who is left. However, they would prefer to kill wolves since wolves know who each other are, so no way for the sk to blend in. If the neutral killed a semi-cleared villager - it has to be because cphoya's reads were good. that's the only good reason for sk to go after a villager, because he thinks that villager will blow his cover/suspect him of being wolf. So, I think its likely that somebody cphoya suspected as a wolf is actually abruzzi.

JD would have been best i think. I personally wouldn't have gone after DMK but i'm on the fence about him so can't fault you and actually think its a pretty reasonable move.