PM me everyone on this list (and anyone who has played >5 games in the past year) whom you think deserves to being in a top villa, top wolf and top all rounder list.

Next to their name, put a number between 1-20 with which you're objectively ranking their skill next to one another.

i.e,
Amber Heard 19
ScarJo 15
Emma Stone 20

it doesn't have to be in order, but I will love you if it is

You can include as many or as few people on the list as you want, but I will ask that you don't submit a load of people with very low numbers just for my benefit.

You send me three separate PMs.

One each for:
Best Villager
Best Wolf
Best All-Rounder (vanillager to godfather, vigilante to serial killer, lost wolf to bodyguard)

You aren't ranking people 1-20. You are giving an arbitrary number of people a "skill value" from between 1-20 (with 20 being the highest) for each category.


The players for your consumption (if I've missed anyone, post itt and I'll pester a mod to edit them in the OP. I've tried to include everyones gimmicks which they've played significantly on but will have forgotten some)

425kid
aaronk56
aaronk56's son
aksdal
alexjd
alrighty roo
anarchist
andynan
atakdog/about a thousand gimmicks
axel_nld
biggerboat
bluffingdonkeyz
bremen
bsball8806
cadaz
calleddownlight
captain binkles
Chips Ahoy/oreos
chrja
CieloAzor
CPHoya
crackedquads
Crossnerd/Jennfox
derwipok
Diggerthedog
dkgojackets
donkdonkdonkdonk
drontier
dryice420
duckburg
dyenimator
EADGBE
enty
evene
FCBLComsih
filthyvermin
flytrap
fnord_too
gabethebabe
gadarene
gder402
Henrik Sedin
hifi/hugh jass
hotwings18
ibavly
iversonain
J.D.
jim halpert/applejack
jjhender
jonnyd
kowboys4
Kruze
Larry Legend
Loretta8
luckayluck/fluttershy
magic_gazz
master3004
mcavoy
metsandfinsfan
monikrazy
Monkey Banana
Montecore
necro
NLSOlider
Noah
nofear/scootaloo
officedog
perdition
Plzbealevel
pocketas227
pwnsall
rebonkulous
Rollwave
sangaman
schu_22
Senor Cardgage
Silman
steven yrtzman fan
sun tzu/rarity
supine
Swiitch
tao1
tehtoes
tehvader
telcontar
the moocher
thenothing
TimeLady
timistere
tweedybird
Variance Minefield
VayaConDios
vixticator
vyk07
wahoopride
well named
wheatrich
willd
Willi
xxaceshigh77xx
xxsooted
younguns87
zdye724

I don't think its fair giving credit to atakdog for all the elite gimmicks.

also missing monikrazy

Is this a ranking from highest to lowest (where 1 is the highest), or a point system (where 20 points is the most)?

that is the face i picture TL making all the time

points system, 20 is the most

lemme clarify

lulz @ objectively

sanga though

ANNOUNCEMENT

To be as objective as possible, I will be using this program:
http://xomnom.com/preference.html

Inputting the list and then thunderdoming players' skill one vs the other until I get a full list of players in an ordered list.

I will give the top person on my list a score of 20 and the bottom person on my list a score of 1, and distribute (roughly normally and evenly) the other scores between all other players.

For the most complete and objective way of coming up with "arbitrary" points for players I recommend this method if you have enough time.

weeeeeeeee

Whos steve yztrman fan tho?

I will definitely be doing this.

I think I'm going to try the luckay method

oh man it keeps giving the most hilarious choices

this seems like a lot of work

cool program will be checking it out

the first one i got was

well named vs cphoya

I couldn't decide

wn wolf
hoya villa
hoya overall

next

i agree with that

the program WILL necessarily give you the tough choices because near the end you'll basically be deciding who is #10 and who is #11, who is #20 and who is #21, etc

that means it's doing it right

(and by random chance you could get a tough choice on the first one but no worries because if one of those players gets voted out on thunderdome they will probably win a lot of thunderdomes on the way back up)

the fact that I'm not on the player list makes me realize how little werewolf I've played over the last year

I just plan on running it once and then individually altering the results for the villager/wolf category

Why is soah in none of my thunderdomes?

One thing that is tough with these is that I think there are many players who are better in vanillas than in MMs, and vice versa

Updated power rankings... how exciting.

Holy ****, I was like this is easy to do and then **** got really hard once it understood my preferences

My villas are in but I may use the Luckay method for the other two lists.