Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
WW: The Departed game thread WW: The Departed game thread

07-30-2008 , 08:24 AM
zeturd needs to be pressured from the start today so his wagon has a better shot at moving (had square wheels yesterday)
WW: The Departed game thread Quote
07-30-2008 , 08:31 AM
wolves:
zeturd
roundtower
river
dustin

wolfy:
clown
luckay

not-vanillager:
dan

villagers:
monk
bobman
well named
villagery:
boiler
dmk
swiitch
wl

unknown:
aard
ack
sun (either vanillager or wolf)


this game is already over
WW: The Departed game thread Quote
07-30-2008 , 08:38 AM
if aard and I are unknown, maybe we deserve some attention at night from some pro-village forces, if ya know what i mean.
WW: The Departed game thread Quote
07-30-2008 , 08:40 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ZeTurd
Heh, pretty sure I'd be giving a reason as a wolf actually.

The damned thing is that I'm having a hard time finding a vote I really like right now. I think all of the people providing a lot of content in the thread so far have villagery things going for them, leaving me with the more UTR people.

I kinda like your latest posts in the thread as they somewhat mirror my own thoughts, but I think you're very capable of making good posts as a wolf, and I currently plain dislike the m1ke wagon, and the last Hitch post made me lukewarm about him as well. So sigh.
love the 'so sigh' part at the end after saying he is only voting me because he dislikes m1ke and hitch wagons, even tho he wants to go more after UTR people and he kinda likes my latest posts

the 'so sigh' part is because he's saying that he has no other options but to go with one of those 3 wagons


Quote:
Originally Posted by ZeTurd
Well, he's claimed power village hasn't he? I'm not entirely sure it's a good idea forcing him to claim. If he isn't NK'ed within a reasonable time frame, he's probably a good lynch though. Also, I'm starting to get this sneaking feeling that you're on the block with a fellow wolf and want to restructure the wagons entirely.
this is after i asked him to go onto dustin wagon...zeturd knows dustin almost always claims power role, so yet again another lame excuse for his vote...and he knows that i am simply trying to get him to commit to vote for someone because he thinks that person is a wolf, not because he 'dislikes the current wagons', yet he throws out the disingenous 'sneaking feeling that you're on the block with a fellow wolf and want to restructure the wagons entirely'

(btw, now that m1ke/hitch came up villa, i guess that 'theory' (which u never actually believed in anyway) was false)


Quote:
Originally Posted by ZeTurd
Yeah, OK, you're being pretty damned bloody-minded here. The thing is.. I don't think you have any problem inflicting posting diarrhea upon the thread as a wolf, and I have a feeling that your wolf game is being underestimated by a lot of posters here. But there's other things.

1) You seem to believe that you're so obviously a transparent villager in this game that my vote on you is somehow preposterous. Personally, I find that kind of ridiculous, but I'm not sure if you're playing it that way as a wolf.

2) I'm not sure you're pressuring me this hard as a wolf since the fallout would land mostly at your feet. Unless at least two or three wolves (you included) were up for lynch and you needed to find a lynchable 3rd or 4th alternative.

But OK. I'm dropping my vote even though I'm feeling an inclination for stubbornness since I believe you're being pretty darn unreasonable.

Late WL wagon? I'll also be rereading m1ke to see if my villager read is as good as I thought.
translation: "you caught me, don't tell anyone"



zeturd/dustin wagons today would be lovely
WW: The Departed game thread Quote
07-30-2008 , 08:42 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ackbleh
if aard and I are unknown, maybe we deserve some attention at night from some pro-village forces, if ya know what i mean.
ok, u have moved to the wolfy list

all ur posts have been about the movie, or how u are unlynchable as wolf, or to 'berate villager for lynching noob d1' and now this

thanks for clearing that up
WW: The Departed game thread Quote
07-30-2008 , 08:45 AM
btw, zeturd...how exactly am i being unreasonable?

u showed that u obv didn't like the current wagons so picked 'the lesser of three bad choices' so i actively worked to get another wagon that u could agree on going...u resisted that completely and so i moved u further and further up the wolf list...there was nothing unreasonable about what i did...i simply tested your claim that you didn't like the wagons and pressured u about it...the results of the test showed that u were faking the 'so sigh' and that u weren't really interested in any other wagons

if u go ahead and resign now, we can do a 2-in-1 day today and u will also avoid spewing any partners
WW: The Departed game thread Quote
07-30-2008 , 08:56 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nicholasp27
ok, u have moved to the wolfy list

all ur posts have been about the movie, or how u are unlynchable as wolf, or to 'berate villager for lynching noob d1' and now this

thanks for clearing that up
Glad to be of service. Please drive through.
WW: The Departed game thread Quote
07-30-2008 , 09:02 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bulletproof Monk
Anyway, whatever.

I AM A SEER

n0 - Vaya: Vanillager
n1 - Sun Tzu: Vanillager
Warning: The following is a Level 4 post. It is EXACTLY level 4. I counted the number of levels I was going above level 1. Tip to help people: Level 1 and Level 2 are complete opposites of thinking. Levels 3 and Level 4 are complete opposites of thinking.

---


This is such a shady view list. You're pretty much just viewing the people who look clear due to Vaya's modkill! Why wouldn't you view people who are more clear? For example, why not view HBE and White Lightning as villagers instead?

Are you a wolf for trying to fake a Sun Tzu view when we all know you wouldn't view the obvious vanillager? Surely you're not a seer because that is a terrible view, and surely you're not a villager trying to cover for the seer because it is obvious you would never view that person.
WW: The Departed game thread Quote
07-30-2008 , 09:03 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by clowntable
So I finished reading up. What a ****ing trainwreck of a game one.
And congratulations on lynching a new player day1, let's keep all the fun games to ourselves.
I hope the people who said "he's too good to be new" turn up wolves, this arrogance is mindboggling.

I'll post deeper thoughts on who's a wolf and who's not later for now:
boiler
This is clown's wolf game imo. I'm leaving my vote on him.

I will not likely wake up before night. good luck finding Jack Nicholson. If all else fails, lynch clown.
WW: The Departed game thread Quote
07-30-2008 , 09:04 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by White Lightning
I just realized that the mod kill could have serious reprocussions.

The following players went after/mentioned Vaya's claim was weird:

Sun Tzu
Antidan
Well named
Dustin

Do we assume they are all none vanillagers?
We have to assume Antidan, Well named, and Dustin aren't vanillagers.

That sort of means we'll start lynching them...hmmm...tomorrow.
WW: The Departed game thread Quote
07-30-2008 , 09:04 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ackbleh
This is clown's wolf game imo. I'm leaving my vote on him.

I will not likely wake up before night. good luck finding Jack Nicholson. If all else fails, lynch clown.
* vote clowntable *
WW: The Departed game thread Quote
07-30-2008 , 09:16 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ackbleh
This is clown's wolf game imo. I'm leaving my vote on him.

I will not likely wake up before night. good luck finding Jack Nicholson. If all else fails, lynch clown.
i completely agree with u here...that post IS clown's wolf game and a decent % of why he is on the wolfy list
WW: The Departed game thread Quote
07-30-2008 , 10:14 AM
im here for a short minute

ROLECLAIM:

I am *NOT* a vanillager.

I am also *NOT* allowed to roleclaim my role. I am however allowed to roleclaim not being allowed to roleclaim. You can take of this what you will as im sure you'll do.

Just from the brief skimming I've done i don't like the Clown votes, but as I said earlier killing clown is usually fun and correct so w/e

when i wake up (which will be before night) i'll have more
WW: The Departed game thread Quote
07-30-2008 , 10:15 AM
The way yesterday went, I'm not sure I want to put a vote on someone early when I know I won't be around, but if I do it's going to be ZeTurd or clowntable I think.

I can't really put my finger on it, but I'm not entirely convinced ZT is evil here. I think ZT/nich could be v/v. Still, I don't have any better lynch candidates other than maybe clown.

I read some other boiler games and I no longer want to lynch him, his game looks like his standard. BPM is not a seer, unless he's like double-pump-fake fake-seering-as-real-seer. But he's probably still villa either way.

The only thing that worries me about nich is that his list seems a little [i]too[i] correct to me, although I guess I think, at the least, Sun was a villager yesterday.

Luckay: for the record, I started the game as a vanillager, and I still am.

Dan is pretty clearly some kind of power role, but I think pro-village almost certainly.

Ackbleh is some kind of power role with some weird night related win condition and a backup pro-village win condition?

River and dustin are also probably not vanillager but not sure yet as to alignment.

Have a good day village, sorry for being a jerk to m1ke
WW: The Departed game thread Quote
07-30-2008 , 10:24 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by LuckayLuck
We have to assume Antidan, Well named, and Dustin aren't vanillagers.

That sort of means we'll start lynching them...hmmm...tomorrow.
for you this is wolfy i think btw but im not sure why
WW: The Departed game thread Quote
07-30-2008 , 10:32 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nicholasp27
btw, zeturd...how exactly am i being unreasonable?
This really isn't that hard to figure out. What it all boils down, is that your balls are sore because I picked you as my #1 wolf candidate after a very specific Hitch post made me turn around on him:

Quote:
Originally Posted by The_Hitch
anyone voting me should be aware that the posts I have made today were all before the dramabomb, and they were all clearing the vanillagers that had seen the angleshoot, and suspicious of the people that hadn't seen it.

I would like to hear how players are reconsiling that vote with the fact they are clearing all the other players (at least before bucky's post about it) that did the same.
I simply don't think it's in Hitch's repertoire to make a "reverse angleshooty" post earlier (referencing Vaya's first post as a wolf, indicating knowledge of PM contents) and then proceed to defend himself in that way.

This was obviously before he claimed seer.

I was pretty clear on why I didn't like the m1ke wagon, so I picked one of the UTR's, namely you. Admittedly there wasn't that much to go on, since at the time I voted you I'd only seen 3-4 posts or something like that from you. The funny thing is that your over-the-top aggression about being voted made me like the vote even better. Your ENTIRE CASE is that you're upset that I wouldn't switch my vote off of you, and that you'd vote that person with me. Now, why the hell would I do that if I think my vote is in a good place?

Quote:
u showed that u obv didn't like the current wagons so picked 'the lesser of three bad choices' so i actively worked to get another wagon that u could agree on going...u resisted that completely and so i moved u further and further up the wolf list...there was nothing unreasonable about what i did...i simply tested your claim that you didn't like the wagons and pressured u about it...the results of the test showed that u were faking the 'so sigh' and that u weren't really interested in any other wagons
No! What I was resisting was moving my vote off of you, and the sigh was in reference to Hitch/m1ke wagons. It's ridiculous to expect that I'll switch to a wagon with you if I think you're a wolf at the time. I still really don't get the defensiveness you're exhibiting, but I also really don't think a wolf would be so gung-ho about going after a villager, and the deaths of Hitch and m1ke discredits the longshot chance that you were going after me because it was at the very least w/w/v wagons. So I'm actually pretty good with you being a villager now. Unfortunately I might add.
WW: The Departed game thread Quote
07-30-2008 , 10:35 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by well named
I can't really put my finger on it, but I'm not entirely convinced ZT is evil here. I think ZT/nich could be v/v. Still, I don't have any better lynch candidates other than maybe clown.
OK, just for reference here, please read the last game (Spanish Inquisition) and notice the way nich goes after Hitch. It was villager/villager then too. Or well, at least until nich got converted, but then he started backing off.
WW: The Departed game thread Quote
07-30-2008 , 10:41 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by RoundTower
ok

lets get the obvious out of the way: hitch was probably killed by the wolves and HBE was probably killed by some kind of serial killer, or maybe a village vig (less likely imo, I haven't seen the film though).
Quote:
Originally Posted by bobman0330
I'm not sure I agree with this. I can't think of anyone from the film who might be a SK, and I have a really hard time believing that a village vig would kill HBE. So, I'm thinking that hitch was a village kill and hbe was the wolf-kill. it's also possible that your second paragraph is true, but hitch's claim was so fake that i don't think the wolves killed him for it.
There's weirdness both ways, it seems to me. Why do wolves choose HBE for the first night kill, when he's almost certainly vanillager? This early, they should be seer hunting, not trying to get rid of cleared players. It seems like there were a lot of better candidates as far as likelihood of having some pro-village power role. I don't know how to explain this. It's possible there is some role that deflects NKs, I guess, as one explanation, but that's a pretty hard conclusion to reach on so little info.
WW: The Departed game thread Quote
07-30-2008 , 10:42 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by White Lightning
Wow! Where did this come from? ZeTurd, my best POG friend, this dosen't look good for you. You didn't have a very transparent, clear and concise day did you?
Oh, this old dance again!

I don't know about your description about my day, but I think it's when I get too clear and concise you need to start worrying, heh. I always hop around to a certain degree as a villager. In fact, I think it's pretty damned good work on my part to get away from Hitch, and then later away from nich. Whether I landed in a good place (you) remains to be seen. I really don't think me voting you should elicit that amount of surprise since you didn't really do much at all on D1.
WW: The Departed game thread Quote
07-30-2008 , 10:45 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ZeTurd
This really isn't that hard to figure out. What it all boils down, is that your balls are sore because I picked you as my #1 wolf candidate after a very specific Hitch post made me turn around on him
this is not true

u even ASKED me SPECIFICALLY why i didn't like ur vote for me: if it was because it was on ME or because of the ARGUMENT

i answered that it was because of the ARGUMENT yet you go on...why even ask then?

and my ACTIONS show that it was because of that, as I spent most of the rest of the day trying to see if you would move to a candidate u thought was a wolf instead of the 'oh well, golly gee, guess if i have to pick from these 2 people, then i'll pick him' attitude that you displayed
WW: The Departed game thread Quote
07-30-2008 , 10:45 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by well named
Dan is pretty clearly some kind of power role, but I think pro-village almost certainly.

Ackbleh is some kind of power role with some weird night related win condition and a backup pro-village win condition?

River and dustin are also probably not vanillager but not sure yet as to alignment.
OK, just for the record, speculating about which villagers are power villagers and what their eventual powers might be isn't really a good idea. Let the wolves figure it out themselves.
WW: The Departed game thread Quote
07-30-2008 , 10:46 AM
how was i defensive? i was aggressive and offensive in going after you, not defensive
WW: The Departed game thread Quote
07-30-2008 , 10:48 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ZeTurd
OK, just for the record, speculating about which villagers are power villagers and what their eventual powers might be isn't really a good idea. Let the wolves figure it out themselves.
anyone that people are posting as 'power roles' or 'non-vanillagers' are clearly that to everyone, so wolves also know this read, so discussing it doesn't help the wolves (as they know whether the person is a wolf or not), but it could help village in determining if the person is power villager or wolf
WW: The Departed game thread Quote
07-30-2008 , 10:55 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nicholasp27
this is not true

u even ASKED me SPECIFICALLY why i didn't like ur vote for me: if it was because it was on ME or because of the ARGUMENT

i answered that it was because of the ARGUMENT yet you go on...why even ask then?

and my ACTIONS show that it was because of that, as I spent most of the rest of the day trying to see if you would move to a candidate u thought was a wolf instead of the 'oh well, golly gee, guess if i have to pick from these 2 people, then i'll pick him' attitude that you displayed
But see, there's an inherent flaw in your argument here. I did move my vote away from one of the two aforementioned candidates (Hitch/m1ke). And yeah, I didn't have that much to go on, but the incredible amount of defensiveness shown by you actually made me like where my vote was. So why would I change, and especially at your say-so?
WW: The Departed game thread Quote
07-30-2008 , 10:58 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nicholasp27
anyone that people are posting as 'power roles' or 'non-vanillagers' are clearly that to everyone, so wolves also know this read, so discussing it doesn't help the wolves (as they know whether the person is a wolf or not), but it could help village in determining if the person is power villager or wolf
There are borderline cases, and I think WN mentioned one of them. But mostly it's speculating about what their powers are.

Eg. "I think X is the seer. What do you say guys?"
WW: The Departed game thread Quote

      
m