if it makes you feel better you consider most of the purple list as "people I'm concerned I'm not competent enough to read correctly"

it's not you, it's me

It doesn't mean much because I can give you valid explanations from both alignments.

I'd likely bus him (or be bussed) hard. It's not outside the realms of possibility. But it's a silly thing to say without knowing my meta, or his.
Did you research either of us prior to saying this?

How do you figure? A wolfy response is a wolfy response is a wolfy response is a wolfy response. Doesn't matter who said it.

Cory, you remember on VS when I rustled Chris and he outed himself as non-town in his tail-between-legs deer in headlights response to me?

Carcino (who was some old POGgers gimmick - lucky?) did the same thing in GoT.

Traz did the same thing here.

So we lynch him.

I'm voting traz Tommy

Or as far as I can remember I am

This is like #1 on the Top 50 Mafia Mistakes list. Too scummy to be scum can most definitely be a scum strategy. Don't write it off because you think it's suicidal; that might be exactly what he wants you to do.

To the bolded, you're telling me the TWELVE people in your villa list have all given a 'real reason' to be there? You have tappo as villa, the guy has 23 posts and is known as maybe the best vanilla wolf out there, presumably you have played with him plenty of times and been owned by him, on the other hand you are saying on the one hand that you don't read me particularly well but on the other you don't know what my village game looks like. You were wrong about me once, try not to worry about it, everyone I've wolfed against has been wrong at least once.

TomTom what do you think of my latest list at 1506

who would you move up?

who would you move down?

My mind is absolutely BLOWN having Murska as a top 3 villager. Absolutely insane to me.

I'm voting traz and will continue to vote traz. The case is the exact same as it was when I put the vote down, and he's done absolutely nothing to help us find scum since I made that vote. He still is avoiding my reasonable question.

Im exclusively posting by phone in this game. I can't really research. I'm giving my real time responses to thread events. I had a twinge of w/w there; you'll see me explain why later.

I'm thinking Moocher is probably a villager at this point. But you were right in your rambling that I sometime say things for reactions -- that post was one of those times that I half believed what I said and half wanted to see what other people would say about it. Only Moocher bit so it wasn't too helpful.

I didn't really see the merit in your rambling post about my mysterious nature, though. You're gonna have to take a stance on me at some point. Shirking that responsibility is bizarre, but it's even weirder to me that you're acting like someone with tons of meta on me -- declaring I'm unreadable -- despite me being pretty sure we've never played before. Almost like you were told about me in wolf chat!?

Votes from post 13 to post 1535
Night in 10:11:28
---

Votes	Lynch	Voters
5	Phelanpt	Athexx (33), marvellosity (101), dbmurph22 (110), The Moocher (131), Thingyman (61)
4	TommyDanger	saberwolf13 (24), Murska (33), Luckbox Inc (37), traz (83)
3	traz	merk_sa (65), Top Tier Tom (216), corycurren (120)
2	The Moocher	Phelanpt (50), Arcbell (31)
2	lenC	well named (14), DWetzel (93)
1	Crunkus	monstrman (47)
1	monstrman	jcohen (38)
1	Luckbox Inc	TommyDanger (69)
1	merk_sa	tappokone (23)
1	well named	lenC (28)
3	not voting	AngryPidgeon (0), Crunkus (63), yamato77 (29)

I am aware of this and it is part of the reason why I have him as SLIGHT villa lean (I could very well be wrong on those reads, in which case he doesn't really get any villa pts from me for thinking the same as me - especially given that we massively disagree on other reads, namely Phelanpt). As you will note, he's only actually made 2 posts that I've found villagery (to where I'm caught up to) and he's made one that I found wolfy.

First time Phelan even addresses me and he's not talking to me. Do you guys see this?

He's trying to convince everyone else, he knows he can't convince me.

I know I have a lot of villagers! But most of them are very thin, consider them all people I think are > rand but not super confidently at this point. I take pride in having strong townreads so I'll have more confident ones when I feel comfortable

Tappo is of course a good wolf but he owned me once MOSTLY because he bussed in a wolfbro convincingly in the Seinfeld game Tommy ran; I have been able to recognize him as a villager in games since and so far I feel pretty okay about him

Seriously link me to a villager game you've had recently - or more than one - because I tend to look at players based on how they think and I just don't know HOW you think as a villager. Tappo is a "good wolf" but I have decent footing (in my head) at least about how he approaches the game and also how he portrays himself subconsciously as a villager and I would guess gun to head he's a villager here

I'm allowed to give thin town reads when I want to give thin town reads

Right now I'm probably more focused on the ~handful of people who have been independently wolfy

I appreciate you being ~somewhat perturbed that you aren't on my green list and if you are a villager I hope our minds click and we get there, but I'm just not comfortable at this point

Maybe some light reading on your villagery self will help me

have fun!

I'm here to blow, baby.

I had a null read of yamato up to this point. He was non-existant. This sounds good, though.

Let's just hope if you're town you don't have a gun

You have provided me with no evidence that you'd be aware of this and I'm starting to think you're just making it all up as you go along. I think your effort level has been a joke so far, especially given that you spent more time talking me into playing this ****ing game than you've spent actually playing it and just about every post of yours has some excuse about how you aren't caught up or some detail about what you're doing irl. Not good enough.

Tell me EXACTLY what sounds good about that post, Phelanpt.

[QUOTE=Thingyman;45270440]
corycurren/Arcbell[/q]

Are you saying they're the same person? Or indicating some sort of tie between them?

And given your previous case on me, how do you feel about murph?

I'm iffy on saberwolf but I haven't played with him in ages and probably have the least read on him of all the BGG players. Tommy I wouldn't have much of a read on except the fact that I think the current votes on him are extremely sketchy so I'm inclined to feel better about him as a result.

This is why I'm suspicious about Saber. He reads tommy as good, without making a comment on Tommy's intro post that he requested.
Tommy's intro post was a rehashing of a prior intro, and not a very good one. It felt half-assed.
So Saber not commenting on it until called out on it later:
It's weak. This is unusual for saber.

What do you like about that post?

TOO SLOW TTT