too bad for the modkill. didnt get the yolomato. but it made the lolyomato stronger

what does not kill the lolyamato only makes the lolyamato get lynched the next day

gg people

not that there is nothing really wrong with other new players, but marvellosity you seemed like a really cool guy and i hope you will play more games in POG

agree. also true for many others. this is why we need a champions turbo series!

but they are also not being subbed day 1.

There was a moment I thought modkilling was not needed because of Gamer Dude role, but it was just too obvious of a modkill.

The Gamer Dude role was not properly designed though - I forgot it were two day gamedays, which makes the 10 post limit pretty useless. In any standard POG game he would have enough NK choices for the first 2 nights, but this was not a normal POG game.

Funny was that wolves did not have a real seer, but when they NK-ed AND monitored Murska they got a free peek of Thingyman. At that time wolves were clear favorities with the angel/doc being lynched day 1.

But then there was the lolyamato and the lolbad claim of TTT and Luckbox refused to get caught and generally wilves started being outplayed by the village.

waking up and immed realising that i no longer have to play this game is an unreal good feeling

and it means i get to save several hours this morning where i thought i'd be typing out a post beginning:

'dear thingyman/dwetzel,

about yesterday...'

sounds like you got plenty of time to play some blitz

lets do it

I wouldn't mind representing MTGS this time around, if you guys will have me. I've completed 115 forum Mafia games across 7 or 8 different sites, have played a bit of EpicMafia, and am one of the Mafia mods over at MTGS.

As far as the setup goes, when Mountainous is concerned, I feel that a 1:5 ratio is balanced-ish in slight favor of the scum. The Cop being balanced here is really a question of how good the scum are at PR-hunting and how good the Cop is at playing it low-key and investigating scum. So while it's a little swingy, I think that it's balanced.

Thingy
I'm the least qualified person to comment in this thread so feel free to ignore.

I think the element missing is the bragging rights at the end sort of thing. Like, POGGERS vs. EpicMafia etc. That would create more more rooting interest for spectators for sure.

More and smaller/quicker games might be a solution? Because having only 1 from each group, especially the larger groups, seems meh.

Ideas:
1. Have preliminary games set up featuring players from only 2-3 forums. Have some sort of ranking/points/subjective element to have the best players from each game advance. So as season goes along, players will get used to each other and the end of the season won't feature tons of posts explaining cultural differences.

At the end, the best players from the preliminaries play regardless of forum.

2. Have the forums host games, with say, 5 of 15 from that forum, and a community member serving as mod to give it the flavor suitable to the home turf. Creating crossover is good for each community IMO.

Well, that was a game.

Good work, town.

As for the vanilla ruleset, I enjoy it, though I do like a Baner(/Doctor/whatever you call it), probably one that can't protect himself, in the mix. But that does strengthen the town a lot and requires additional balancing - I just enjoy the added complexity without making it too much a PR-fest.

I can't believe you guys didn't lynch Merk. He started howling on early d1 and never stopped. How can you let a guy like that live? So bad.

LOL TRAFFICONE

<3

gg all, wp town

reasonably content with my play overall. my only regret is not following through Arcbell on d1 when I totally saw through everything he did.

i blame trafficone

gg marv

Village outplayed scum like 3:1, interesting game.

tappokone
merk_sa\'Tunnel

How long did you spend in that Skype log?

To be fair to me - and I'm all about fairness to me - a large part of the issue was that I was reading every other villager correctly. When on top of that Crunkus's performance art exploited my tendency to assume that people who go out of their way to behave like they have a death wish are villagers, the wolfy as **** guy had to be the wolf.

Using Control-F to see how many comments Arc had made took a few seconds. Scrolling through to find a section or two where both of you were chatting took several minutes.

fyp