I did this too. When I saw Phel's flip, that was really the first thing I thought about especially given's Phel's insistence that the village lynch me next after him.

thingyman, how does the above post read to you?

does it sound like wolf-merk complaining that it's more difficult for him to convinve you to do what he wants in this game?

that's next lvl

most ppl should be thinking tappo. Its quite sad ppl are not.

sad because it shows poor village thinking imo

murph

I'm asking because you said that you would be driving home before EOD. So why were you at stoplights after EOD.

Because traz makes sense here. He was after me before, he's still after me now. I disagreed with him on Tommy; he was wrong, I disagreed with him on Phelan, I was wrong. He still seems villagery to me and wrong about me.

this is an incredible post

Not knowing anything about Tappo, it doesn't really factor in at all. But yes, I was aware. Why did you vote Phel at the 8:01 slot?

Okay, this is getting ridicolous, because he's obviously just gonna make up an excuse if he's lying anyway.

I choose to trust this.

It's just that I wanted to give you village points for including a detail that made me believe your story about checking the role list (being at stoplights).

I actually don't trust Len that much. Having some trouble there. Will have to put that into some detail.

So normally I would've just noted this post down as villagery and move on without anyone knowing how this impacted my reads, but since at least two people (traz and The Moocher) have expressed a dislike for me asking questions, I'd like to make it clear that at least I actually do get something out of them a lot of the time - and I believe that any tone reader should as well

so take this post

The underlined. If we believe this to be the truth (he would otherwise have to be a wolf lying and including such a detail just for the heck of it), then he's also telling the truth about checking the roles and thus he is a villager.

I choose to believe it.

this reminds me of "why do you need air conditioning, it's 59 degrees in Ireland" catch

that worked poorly for me

I would absolutely like to know more about tappo in order to be able to figure out what happened yesterday but I have seen nothing to indicate it wasn't two villagers up for lynch and I would rather not just lynch him to figure that out because that's wasting lynches. We need to hit a wolf.

traz, if and when tappo flips wolf the people who are alive can go back and look through that EOD and it's all gravy

however i'm trying to think about what it means if tappo is villa, specifically the people who were spazzing all over the thread during a v/v lynch

also i would feel that i had wasted an entire week were i to mislynch tappo on sunday so i'm really trying to put more into it than just 'good villagers should be voting for tappo' because it doesn't really mean anything and is in no way helping to work out the roles of other players in the game

when i village i try to play each gameday as if it could be my last, because it usually is, i'd like to see more urgency from you in this regard

Just having fun with you. Saw the reveal after I exited freeway. First light. Then I checked the role list after. I get off work 30 min to lynch, but I left slow so stayed for EOD in my car

to the bolded, you're making a case on me being a wolf because i encouraged you to mislynch your boy phelanpt, however i was leading the counterwagon, how the **** do you think this doesn't factor into your read?

How common are such mechanics on BGG?

lol

the thought did occur to me, but well... Hmm. Actually, if he did feel that way as a wolf, would he want to address it? merk is very arrogant, very confident in himself and likes to be superior (I say nothing of this as an insult - I would be shocked if merk would disagree with this characterization of himself), so I feel like that would be not in tune with him to sort of be admitting defeat.

But I treat it as null.

until tonight, bitches

Not common in "standard"/newbie friendly games but increasingly common in more complex games. I feel like especially in the past few years.

Alternately it's also somewhat common in basic games to have zero reveal on death. It used to be more so in fact but that's diminished in recent years.

Well obviously it depends on what tappo is. If tappo is a wolf then it pretty much clears you IMO. If tappo was just another villager then it emphasizes the possibility that you are doing exactly what I was saying (but certainly isn't conclusive evidence).

Timewarping. I probably will use this day to be privately constructive and work on my notes after I'm caught up.

This is my opinion on all of them as well. I find it intriguing that you got a bunch of yamato voters as part of your wolf list for one. I'm aware bussing is a thing, but I don't think it was a team effort.

bah I forgot theres no multiquotes here. Above post was to traz's wolflist and well named rating each likelihood and I agreed with every rating he gave.

Oh.....saber

If athexx is a failasaurus rex for mislynching one villager, then I can only imagine what that says of the people that mislynched the doctor, just saying.

Saber you're my favorite player from BGG

**** you murph