Also I did play TT1 but I suspect this game is very different so I doubt that’s much of or any real advantage.

It was a fun game and wolf win, tho. Sun (lost) and bankles were part of that team as well.

I mean its only slightly meta in the sense that I am saying that doing it is wolfy which is directly relevant to this game.

Further I will say that I do not mind people who are useless, I mind it when people are useless but disguise it as if they are doing something useful.

My first village read is on Birdman. This is great.

guess I'm not as nice as you since I dislike people being useless in a broader sense

Re voting:
Have we considered having some people vote completely off wagon? If the final count is 23/15/1/1/1/1/1/1 that could be beneficial to ensuring that the 1 voters don't switch.

Do we know if the actual end vote totals will be revealed?

Knowing/believing the useless play is a ploy is a good thing though.

yeah s1 was easily the best and i was losing interest at the end, but i still think it was worth it

Yeah, I got your point. Your post still made me laugh.

It's an interesting observation... maybe the wolfy pop-in isn't nearly as wolfy as calling the pop-in wolfy

Take of unknown temperature: Doctor Zeus is a villager.

Doctor Zeus

This will inevitably happen. Half the posters havent even arrived

I mean its easy to skip people's banter when I am reading the thread. It's annoying when I read a post and think "oh this is about the game, cool" and all it is is you giving us timing tells on confirmedtroll

This is beautiful

I'm not afraid of the Court Intrigue mechanic one bit.

I guess we disagree viggo

I thought the part about CTs posts being nothing was decent as I have not felt much oomph from CT yet

Anyway, I'm intrigued by the way pry responded to birdman... justifying his vote, then quietly trying to change it to someone tangentially involved in the conversation

pry

Noted. Thanks.

Gotcha

It's mostly a gut read. I can see what you are saying though which is why I'm hesitating. He posts seem kinda fake but I also thought he had a lack of self awareness/abruptness when interacting with me earlier and also I feel like I've seen Pry wolf and it felt different? Don't quote me on this

Creature is just vibes. It's kinda hard to tell what post restricted Creature would be like, but from what I saw (his thoughts on apoc+how he approached my readslist specifically) were ~fine and nothing wolfy so far

Filthy saying he townread literally everyone so far seems like a very towny move+natural. Granted I do tend to townread filthy every game, but I've also never played with him when he's a wolf, so.

That's good. Are you going to be posting/making reads more today? I can't really read you based on what you've posted so far



It's interesting because Birdman and Fanmail came to completely opposite conclusions, with Birdman saying that Pry's comment is weak and Fanmail saying it was a "villagery" observation

seems like zeus making a mountain out of a molehill

fwiw I don't actually have a read on DZ

How?

birdman's comment was just weird with no substance, does not seem like something you would agree with

not all of us

when I leave to do other things, it's not because of "real life"

it's because I have other not real life things in addition to ww

It's the typical sort of thing that Birdman would have issue with-- so for him it's villagery. But I don't think Zeus would know that. Not sure there.

You know that we often disagree, so I don't think this post is necessarily wolfy for you, but really, these slips just never really happen by wolves. In a decade and a half of werewolf play, I think I've seen three misstatements that were actual slips. Every other time they have been villagers who poorly expressed themselves.

Add to that the level of player in question here, an Apoc, and I'm not saying it make him a villager, but it DEFINITELY doesn't make him a wolf.

The ONLY exception is if the wolfpack has info that there is a lost wolf trying to join them or if Apoc is himself lost. But in that case, it's not a slip. it's a signal.