Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
A Tale of Horror - WW mishmash 04/04 A Tale of Horror - WW mishmash 04/04

04-05-2011 , 05:18 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by derwipok
Is Tom on here because you think he wouldn't choose that posting style as a wolf?
yeah absolutely
A Tale of Horror - WW mishmash 04/04 Quote
04-05-2011 , 05:20 PM
I think telco's case looks good for him being a villager, but it says almost nothing for ssoted's role.

#1326:

Quote:
Originally Posted by TheDean1
Also I cannot reiterate enough that esse is not a villager. He is not wolf hunting, only hunting for lost wol signals in a game with presumably no lost wolves. I am his other wolf lean when i should be rather clearly a villager, and his read as well as his others seems entirely absent of any thought process.

Akson, the case on jd is that hes prolly a wolf. Nice to see that youre villa.
#1329:

Quote:
Originally Posted by TheDean1
On the phone now, i made a case on him last page that boils down to him being around a bit but not villagery at all.

I still think esse is more likely to be a wolf but jd is a good lynch.
#1338:

Quote:
Originally Posted by XXsooted
I pm'd the mods and explained why I didn't post.
Very easy for sooted to catch that dean was pushing esse.
A Tale of Horror - WW mishmash 04/04 Quote
04-05-2011 , 05:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by essedarius
explain then

how did you have the knowledge to vote me when you had only read one page?

do you think I'm so bad of a player that you don't even have to read me yourself if someone who you have a villa read on who has played prob 5 games at max is voting me? so that is enough for you to vote someone?
yes, even if I am 100% you are a villager it is pro-villa to build a wagon on you to see how people react. It is much better for me to vote you there and build a wagon then to leave my vote on no one. It has nothing to do with you being a "bad player" or w/e.
A Tale of Horror - WW mishmash 04/04 Quote
04-05-2011 , 05:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by XXsooted
telco I am a villager, I am now on post 101 (the one I just quoted of vaya's). I am a villager and I am not sure which posts you think I read out of order which would make me a wolf. I read a random dean post during night last night that made me think he's villa. I also saw that the lynchee, ibavly, had his vote on a non-wagon in esse, which made me think he had a strongish wolf lean on esse.
he spitevoted me because I was pushing his wagon, because he signaled

he played a horrible game and people who are gonna put that little effort simply shouldn't play
A Tale of Horror - WW mishmash 04/04 Quote
04-05-2011 , 05:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andynan
Tom can I have an autograph?

you did basically what I wanted to do but only managed to mantain for 1 post xDDD
"Dear Andy,

Keep your chin up! You'll get there someday too!

Yours,

TV"
A Tale of Horror - WW mishmash 04/04 Quote
04-05-2011 , 05:21 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by essedarius
yeah absolutely
Can you explain why exactly? It seems like a great posting style for a wolf to use because he basically can't be read on his posts.
A Tale of Horror - WW mishmash 04/04 Quote
04-05-2011 , 05:21 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by gder402
that was awsome guys
Quote:
Originally Posted by gder402
i would love an esse wagon

esse
Quote:
Originally Posted by gder402
I have a good amount of meta recently with akson esse and rebonk. its a tone thing(esse seems fake and forced, rebonk seems off also from villageryness and akson coming in and voting me cuz im here just screamed GDER IM A VILLAGER! MASONS?)

Derwipok is also super wolfy on tone
Quote:
Originally Posted by gder402
villagers

the dean 1
aaronk56
fcbl
duckberg

wolves
rebonk
esse

I like his villa list fwiw

Quote:
Originally Posted by gder402
based on pag 4/5 thedeanwon is a villager

no obvious wolves
This turns out to be a good read imo

Quote:
Originally Posted by gder402
On phone atm, haven't read anything hope I haven't been vigged or anything

We should lynch someone who has a prime number of posts an hour before eod
this is a post that a wolf would try not to make, it's like saying "hi guize I havent read the thread! lets lynch an UTR!"

It would be wolfy at face value but wolves dont have the kind of balls to make such a wolfy post in isolation and peace out, in my limited experience.

I dont dig the gder wagon, but he needs to step the **** up
A Tale of Horror - WW mishmash 04/04 Quote
04-05-2011 , 05:23 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by XXsooted
yes, even if I am 100% you are a villager it is pro-villa to build a wagon on you to see how people react. It is much better for me to vote you there and build a wagon then to leave my vote on no one. It has nothing to do with you being a "bad player" or w/e.
I'll give a villa lean to sooted for this
A Tale of Horror - WW mishmash 04/04 Quote
04-05-2011 , 05:23 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by essedarius
he spitevoted me because I was pushing his wagon, because he signaled

he played a horrible game and people who are gonna put that little effort simply shouldn't play
To be fair if he had peeked you n1 and had read very little of the thread voting you is at least logical, even if it's not actually useful.
A Tale of Horror - WW mishmash 04/04 Quote
04-05-2011 , 05:23 PM
Tom could you arrange a meeting on the tavern?

I could use that drink.
A Tale of Horror - WW mishmash 04/04 Quote
04-05-2011 , 05:25 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by derwipok
Can you explain why exactly? It seems like a great posting style for a wolf to use because he basically can't be read on his posts.
After giving Andy his autograph, I heard derwipok whispering in the shadows about me. I knew his attempts to subvert the village were destined to fail, but thought I should intervene regardless.

"Excuse me good sir," I say, offering my hand. "I believe that you'll find all the information I have I have provided in a clear and concise way, so that anybody who wishes may find out exactly what they need to know." I point at my notebook.

"It's all in there. Go ahead and read it. And if you've got any questions, I'll be right here." I sit at the bar and order a drink while he considers my offer.
A Tale of Horror - WW mishmash 04/04 Quote
04-05-2011 , 05:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andynan
I like his villa list fwiw
I don't see how aaron and fcbl are in anyone's top 4 villagers. I have a villa lean on aaron and a wolf lean on fcbl fwiw.
A Tale of Horror - WW mishmash 04/04 Quote
04-05-2011 , 05:27 PM
Fwiw I have TV as one of my strongest village leans currently. His posting style does make it pretty much impossible to read him for tone but his content has been pretty good. A wolf doing what he's doing is likely to ignore including actual content but TV has actually made a decent effort at conveying his actual thoughts and reads through the stuff he's writing. I'd still prefer it if he posted normally as far as reading him goes but it's fairly entertaining at least.
A Tale of Horror - WW mishmash 04/04 Quote
04-05-2011 , 05:28 PM
ok I had 2 secret things I wanted to keep to myself, but **** it

dean has never been as agressive as he was d1, in skype he's generally really nice, he was also nice in wolf chat, what I thought would explain it, was to be randed a wolf twice in a row and especially since I jumped early on Vaya, I thought he was pissed off because of that because he thought I probably caught something

there was lost wolves, and he was very stubborn about not trying to lynch lost wolves, CDL was other one who did this and jonnyd who now seems to have disappeared and is probably a wolf was making fun of signals

since we don't really know how the wolf scattering works.. I think it makes sense they know each other, I've been putting that on hold for a while.

vaya has been villagery, especially when compared to the previous wolf games he posted.. but then again it would be easier for him to be villagery if he hadn't got a wolfchat to waste his time in, if he didn't know who the other wolves are..

I don't want to lynch him today, again because of the wolves knowing each other, but not having a chat makes sense based on their pm

other thing that I've noticed is considering Telcontar: where are his smileys? has he stopped using them recently, I haven't still had time to reread him, and I'm not sure if I'm going to so I'm asking if anyone has noticed.. usually his posts have had like each at least 5 smileys, is he trying to be more serious for a reason?
A Tale of Horror - WW mishmash 04/04 Quote
04-05-2011 , 05:28 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Willd
Fwiw I have TV as one of my strongest village leans currently. His posting style does make it pretty much impossible to read him for tone but his content has been pretty good. A wolf doing what he's doing is likely to ignore including actual content but TV has actually made a decent effort at conveying his actual thoughts and reads through the stuff he's writing. I'd still prefer it if he posted normally as far as reading him goes but it's fairly entertaining at least.
Good post, this is much better than the people saying "tom is villa" without articulating why
A Tale of Horror - WW mishmash 04/04 Quote
04-05-2011 , 05:30 PM
village

hoya
jd
cadaz
aicirt
jfdan
tomveil
andy
willd


A Tale of Horror - WW mishmash 04/04 Quote
04-05-2011 , 05:30 PM
Post analysis of utr + on my wolf leans list = JD

Quote:
Originally Posted by J.D.
Hmm, just a thought. Maybe we should all leave lost wolf "signals".

We never seem to actually be able to lynch anyone for leaving signals. So lets just make it harder for them.
His logic doesn't make sense to me here.


Quote:
Originally Posted by J.D.
no, trust me you arent that good.



and no. Although here we go.

Why, as a lost wolf would I signal in the first 20 posts when its likely 3/4 of the game wont read them?

I got to head to work, will try and keep up by phone but probably wont be posting.

/in before wolfy.
This post mildly contradicts his idea in the previous post.

Quote:
Originally Posted by J.D.
so skim caught up, skipped pages 2 and 3, but glad there arent 10 to catch up on.

If Esse was a wolf looking for lost wolf signals, WHY oh WHY would he bring it up IN THREAD? It makes no sense, he would let it slide and peek you.

FWIW, FOL IS W (skip the HAT part) mixed up = IS WOLF.



But THIS is absolutely the perfect post.

rebonk
Reasons for not posting/reading followed by rebonk vote.

Quote:
Originally Posted by J.D.
ummm, you quoted posts from people commenting about it. There was a LOTof talk about it right on Page 1. Wat?
Quote:
Originally Posted by J.D.
actually I didnt skip them entirely, I read some from my phone. Most of it centered around signals.

I got back in my office, saw the top of page 4 was the same so just started reading from there.

Plus I wanted to post. So less reading, more posting.
Less reading more posting.

Quote:
Originally Posted by J.D.
I suggested that in order to defeat signaling that everyone should do it.

Multiple people disagreed so I let go of the idea. BBB was the first I think, and made an argument that made sense.

it was basically an all or nothing, I actually still think the idea has some merit.
Talks about signaling some more.

Quote:
Originally Posted by J.D.
BTW, are you new?

Has anyone else asked if you are a gimmick?
Asks gotgame about his gimmick. Mostly fluff posts so far.

Quote:
Originally Posted by J.D.
if you are going to call people stupid you should probably look in the mirror.

You post white text with a potential signal and then expect to NOT catch heat for it?

if you are a villager, think man, think.

or die as a wolf, I dont care.
idk if a wolf would be this abrasive.

Quote:
Originally Posted by J.D.
What? You intentionally act Wolfy but yet wolves are all over your wagon?

More likely wolfhunting villagers because you did something dumb.
More abrasiveness.

Quote:
Originally Posted by J.D.
my argument to this: Why would you call outright village fail, for calling you wolfy, when you admit, that you are EXACTLY trying to act wolfy to see if people jump on you.

All he has done is say fail fail fail, lol village, logic fail, when his argument for being wolfy is "well I am acting wolfy on purpose"

I also felt a trend while catching up that people are actively trying to save him.



THANK YOU, I am 99% sure he hasnt, it's interesting to say the least.

I am probably staying on rebonk but dont hate the Ibavly votes at all.
His agitation seems forced to me. Still voting rebonk.

Quote:
Originally Posted by J.D.
because my browser always fails when I try to search by a persons posts, and loading IE just about crashes my laptop.
More fluff.

Quote:
Originally Posted by J.D.
if rebonk is a wolf, all the redirecting was done a couple hours back.

could also be w/w? <fingers crossed>

and yes, I use Chrome, will try the refresh thing next time. thanks.
This reasoning seems rediculous to me.

Quote:
Originally Posted by J.D.
hey yo., mid pagee 12 on my reading, but felt like posting.

RW is my new #1 villager for today, a couple of his posts are just solid. GotGame seems a bit shady to me, seems to reflect the same style of posting that he did in the Fringe game where we wolfed together, but its more a tone thing that I cant put a finger on.

I think its really important to figure out if the wolves are lost or not, for some pretty obvious reasons. For instance, if they are truly lost, Esse is a lock villa, if not, then he probably is a wolf. There is obviously more.

vayacondios for now, but I want to do some homework, and that is subject to change.
changes vote to vaya and really neutrally says gotgame is wolfy

Quote:
Originally Posted by J.D.
to add my mechaincs two sense, just based on the kills I think at least some wolves are lost.

Signaling dominated yesterday. Both Rebonk and Vaya are still alive.

CDL seemed villagery, and Carrie def seems like a role that would be a wolf. I just htink CDL would be a really odd kill for a villager to make.

I would expect village vigs to cap one of the signalers as a default action last night.

Rambly, but its my thoughts.
Conjecture.

Quote:
Originally Posted by J.D.
no. I was phone reading but the lack of keypad on my new phone makes it nearly impossible unless I am stopped somewhere, I am back in my office now.

and just about to go read the rest, obviously I missed somehting.
More about how he hasn't read.

Quote:
Originally Posted by J.D.
Dont have a reason why they are there, might just be because I usually type
pretty quickly. Didnt cut and paste anything at all.

Caught up now, and was hoping for a mod explanation about the lost/scattered discussion but nothing to be found.

I love CPHoya's long post, very villagery. Thedean does look good in the whole monikrazy thing, provided wolves do know each other which seems to be the general consensus.
I like this post. But I think it's the first time he has committed to reading someone as villagery.

Quote:
Originally Posted by J.D.
Dean, the problem with your case is you are working backwards, you assume I am a wolf and already know everything. You take my D1 posts, when we all know nothing, and throwing the added D2 information in my face to make your case. Its flawed, and you are wrong.
Telling off Dean. I have agreed with Dean on most things itt.

Quote:
Originally Posted by J.D.
dean, what kind of phone do you have?
Fluffity fluff.

Quote:
Originally Posted by J.D.
Test post from my droid
More fluff.


Quote:
Originally Posted by J.D.
ok, this is slim, and probably 100% non-important but:

You will probably have to click the actual posts to see it, but when I post from my droid, I lose the title header (a tale of horror, blah blah). I first noticed it when mets was phone posting a while back.

Deans posts have the header, and its why I asked what phone he had. Lynch all liars?
Even more fluff.

Quote:
Originally Posted by J.D.
FWIW this is 100% right. I post when I can.

For instance, I had 3 conf calls back to back from when I made my dean post and now.

and now I am heading out for beers with my friends. Will do some reading by phone but no chance I keep up. Will vote to save myself LDO.

dean, other than "busted" you didnt address my case, were you phone posting or no?
Why he hasn't been contributing.

Any posts of his I haven't quoted were omitted because I didn't see anything in them.
A Tale of Horror - WW mishmash 04/04 Quote
04-05-2011 , 05:31 PM
I'll vote whoever thedean says that esse digs and hopefully globe (villa) doesnt like. If duckburg likes it that's a bonus

Esse is not going anywhere guys, lets make sure there is cancer in that arm before chopping it off. We'd be esse-less for the rest of the game
A Tale of Horror - WW mishmash 04/04 Quote
04-05-2011 , 05:32 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by essedarius
ok I had 2 secret things I wanted to keep to myself, but **** it

dean has never been as agressive as he was d1, in skype he's generally really nice, he was also nice in wolf chat, what I thought would explain it, was to be randed a wolf twice in a row and especially since I jumped early on Vaya, I thought he was pissed off because of that because he thought I probably caught something

there was lost wolves, and he was very stubborn about not trying to lynch lost wolves, CDL was other one who did this and jonnyd who now seems to have disappeared and is probably a wolf was making fun of signals

since we don't really know how the wolf scattering works.. I think it makes sense they know each other, I've been putting that on hold for a while.

vaya has been villagery, especially when compared to the previous wolf games he posted.. but then again it would be easier for him to be villagery if he hadn't got a wolfchat to waste his time in, if he didn't know who the other wolves are..

I don't want to lynch him today, again because of the wolves knowing each other, but not having a chat makes sense based on their pm

other thing that I've noticed is considering Telcontar: where are his smileys? has he stopped using them recently, I haven't still had time to reread him, and I'm not sure if I'm going to so I'm asking if anyone has noticed.. usually his posts have had like each at least 5 smileys, is he trying to be more serious for a reason?
Your first point argues that wolves know each other and therefore dean is likely wolf.

Your second argues that wolves don't know one another and therefor I'm a wolf.

Not to mention the fact that I'm not a wolf and dean probably isn't either.
A Tale of Horror - WW mishmash 04/04 Quote
04-05-2011 , 05:32 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Willd
Fwiw I have TV as one of my strongest village leans currently. His posting style does make it pretty much impossible to read him for tone but his content has been pretty good. A wolf doing what he's doing is likely to ignore including actual content but TV has actually made a decent effort at conveying his actual thoughts and reads through the stuff he's writing. I'd still prefer it if he posted normally as far as reading him goes but it's fairly entertaining at least.
yay!!!

I knew you'd come around

Quote:
Originally Posted by VayaConDios
Good post, this is much better than the people saying "tom is villa" without articulating why
I dig this too
A Tale of Horror - WW mishmash 04/04 Quote
04-05-2011 , 05:34 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by VayaConDios
Your first point argues that wolves know each other and therefore dean is likely wolf.

Your second argues that wolves don't know one another and therefor I'm a wolf.

Not to mention the fact that I'm not a wolf and dean probably isn't either.
I explained how my thoughts have advanced in chronological order, first part was d1, 2nd was around middle d2

right now I don't think you're a wolf, but there's def something weird about dean
A Tale of Horror - WW mishmash 04/04 Quote
04-05-2011 , 05:35 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by essedarius
village

hoya
jd
cadaz
aicirt
jfdan
tomveil
andy
willd


how are JD and Cadaz your 2nd and 3rd villagers?
A Tale of Horror - WW mishmash 04/04 Quote
04-05-2011 , 05:35 PM
sorry for not being more active, I really am hard pressed to keep up with everything work-wise + gf + reading game of thrones at every break I can find
A Tale of Horror - WW mishmash 04/04 Quote
04-05-2011 , 05:35 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by DonkDonkDonkDonk
how are JD and Cadaz your 2nd and 3rd villagers?
same reason you are probably a wolf
A Tale of Horror - WW mishmash 04/04 Quote
04-05-2011 , 05:36 PM
partially caught up

seems like most are in agreement scattered wolves know who they are to some extent, which i agree with too. cdl is very anti-bus but a lot of that from the pern game (i think it was the pern game at least) came from the team they were on, it was a team effort to avoid bussing and in this game where many wolves are without wolf chat i don't think you can make the same assumption that cdl will stick with that strategy (at least as determined as he was). never the less, i definitely think cdl spewed rebonk villa; bobman, on the other hand, could be anything.

for moni, obvious one is dean is a villager. moni had esse/hoya as his top villagers...i doubt he'd have the balls to put two wolves as his top villagers so i think there's gotta be at least one villa between the two of them. if one of them comes back wolf it should be soft clearing to the other. villa points for both of them anyway. outside of that moni didn't post any reads.

so from spew, villagery to least villagery

dean
rebonk
esse
cphoya
bobman
A Tale of Horror - WW mishmash 04/04 Quote

      
m