Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Survivor Season 28 - 1/6 Werewolf Mish Mash GAME THREAD Survivor Season 28 - 1/6 Werewolf Mish Mash GAME THREAD

01-07-2014 , 03:46 PM
batmn you can be complete aidz and waste your peek on me if you desire

but its pretty dumb
Survivor Season 28 - 1/6 Werewolf Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-07-2014 , 03:47 PM
BATM doing work ITG

Not sure what kind of work though, lol. Seems villagery
Survivor Season 28 - 1/6 Werewolf Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-07-2014 , 03:47 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by UncleDynamite
wang, cdl is just a huge idiot who can't tell left from right. He's good on mech stuff I s'pose, but I just think he's a villager. I said this yesterday and you didn't like it.

mets, I forgot about TH10, thanks for bringing him up. I agree that he's a wolf.
prolly didn't like it cause i dont know CDL's game. but this + swiitch vouching here convinces me.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Swiitch
They are very, very likely v/v

CDL often calls some people wolfy, who most of the other players think are villagers. It's actually more villagery of CDL to make some wild reads like his thinking UD is a wolf.
alright. i can buy both of these.
Survivor Season 28 - 1/6 Werewolf Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-07-2014 , 03:48 PM
Tanner, I'm on phone right now so I can't search well. Have you ever addressed my point on your rawrs vote?
Survivor Season 28 - 1/6 Werewolf Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-07-2014 , 03:48 PM
Someone explain to me why joining in the community challenge makes me a wolf?

UD decided he didn't want to play. Then after the challenge he decides his tribe was full of wolves. Yet he has built no cases on why his tribe is full of wolves other than that four of us participated in the challenge.

Can no-one see how flawed that logic is!
Survivor Season 28 - 1/6 Werewolf Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-07-2014 , 03:49 PM
the pro play would be for BATM to peek himself. Think of the rustlage
Survivor Season 28 - 1/6 Werewolf Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-07-2014 , 03:50 PM
Broken, I don't think we've been in the thread at the same time together except for like 9am Monday morning
Survivor Season 28 - 1/6 Werewolf Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-07-2014 , 03:50 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by UncleDynamite
Tanner, I'm on phone right now so I can't search well. Have you ever addressed my point on your rawrs vote?
Which point? I responded to you earlier but the only thing I recall you saying is that it was a thin vote or that I wasn't voting "for pressure". The former is right but not terribly important and the latter is wrong. Any vote is a vote for pressure, and I even explained why I thought it was a particularly bad post from him right around that time (which, again, you failed to quote).

If I missed any other point, just repost it and I'll try and answer.
Survivor Season 28 - 1/6 Werewolf Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-07-2014 , 03:50 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by wangpirate
prolly didn't like it cause i dont know CDL's game. but this + swiitch vouching here convinces me.


alright. i can buy both of these.
this is so forced, i wish i could vote for you but i can't
Survivor Season 28 - 1/6 Werewolf Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-07-2014 , 03:51 PM
SIR in pure commentary mode too
Survivor Season 28 - 1/6 Werewolf Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-07-2014 , 03:51 PM
i wish for a vig
Survivor Season 28 - 1/6 Werewolf Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-07-2014 , 03:52 PM
What's with the DWetz wagon? I have seen much from him... or is that it?
Survivor Season 28 - 1/6 Werewolf Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-07-2014 , 03:52 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Deco354
Someone explain to me why joining in the community challenge makes me a wolf?

UD decided he didn't want to play. Then after the challenge he decides his tribe was full of wolves. Yet he has built no cases on why his tribe is full of wolves other than that four of us participated in the challenge.

Can no-one see how flawed that logic is!
Don't worry, I see it.

People tend to give wolves too much credit for acting as a group when they rarely ever do.

I'd prefer we all try and win immunity (if you're in my tribe) and go from their. The tribes are random so we're almost assured to be saving more villas than wolves.
Survivor Season 28 - 1/6 Werewolf Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-07-2014 , 03:53 PM
i feel frozen right now

like until these slankers from my tribe come in the thread i don't really have anything to say

i hate my tribe with the passion of a thousand suns

teh good news is well named is the newest member of my tribe circle of trust
Survivor Season 28 - 1/6 Werewolf Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-07-2014 , 03:53 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by SirRawrsALot
What's with the DWetz wagon? I have seen much from him... or is that it?
EVERY DAY IM SHROOPILIN
Survivor Season 28 - 1/6 Werewolf Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-07-2014 , 03:54 PM
im back in n out til 6pm
Survivor Season 28 - 1/6 Werewolf Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-07-2014 , 03:54 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by cjkalt
this is so forced, i wish i could vote for you but i can't
Thankfully, I can. wangpirate

You're welcome
Survivor Season 28 - 1/6 Werewolf Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-07-2014 , 03:54 PM
mut do u hate me?
Survivor Season 28 - 1/6 Werewolf Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-07-2014 , 03:54 PM
Can we lynch the players who joined the challenge for tribe 1 and 3 as well?
Heck why not lynch anyone who takes part in any challenge.

Now I'd understand this if we had decided that tribe X should win (which is what we should be doing) but we didn't. I got bored coming up with neutral reads all afternoon so jumped at the chance to play a challenge. (As did dozens of other people who aren't having fingers pointed at them).

You all need to take a hard look at the reasoning behind this stupid claim and look for wolves within this ridiculously read-less way to smear villagers.
Survivor Season 28 - 1/6 Werewolf Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-07-2014 , 03:54 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Deco354
Someone explain to me why joining in the community challenge makes me a wolf?

UD decided he didn't want to play. Then after the challenge he decides his tribe was full of wolves. Yet he has built no cases on why his tribe is full of wolves other than that four of us participated in the challenge.

Can no-one see how flawed that logic is!
I don't think you're a wolf in particular, but the idea behind it would be:

1) getting immunity for the tribe benefits wolves more than villas (in part because wolves lose more equity when one is lynched)

2) this is especially true if the tribe has multiple wolves that are likely wagons

3) there were more lower-volume posters on the winning tribe than on the other two tribes

4) at least some of the lower-volume posters helped behind-the-scenes to try to win the challenge

5) in a vacuum, wolves could have more of an incentive to do this (be more active in the challenge than in the thread) than villagers

thus, it's reasonable to conclude that the winning tribe had at least one wolf who put significant effort into winning the challenge in order to gain immunity for wolves who were at risk of being wagoned

alternatively, it could also be the case that most of the low-posters from the winning tribe were just carried to victory by a handful of diligent villagers putting in effort on the challenge

and this would all be moot if I'd been able to figure out the challenge and get immunity for my own tribe, which sort of illustrates how easy it would have been for one or two people to win the challenge on behalf of the tribe as a whole
Survivor Season 28 - 1/6 Werewolf Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-07-2014 , 03:54 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by well named
the pro play would be for BATM to peek himself. Think of the rustlage
not a productive post
Survivor Season 28 - 1/6 Werewolf Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-07-2014 , 03:54 PM
also mets


swiitch/wn/mets/me get to decide teh lynch


everyone else just don't vote1
Survivor Season 28 - 1/6 Werewolf Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-07-2014 , 03:55 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by SirRawrsALot
BATM doing work ITG

Not sure what kind of work though, lol. Seems villagery
the "lol" and the "seems" are both wolfy
Survivor Season 28 - 1/6 Werewolf Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-07-2014 , 03:55 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by metsandfinsfan
mut do u hate me?
no i literally didn't see this post

xpost


Survivor Season 28 - 1/6 Werewolf Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-07-2014 , 03:55 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Deco354
Can we lynch the players who joined the challenge for tribe 1 and 3 as well?
Heck why not lynch anyone who takes part in any challenge.

Now I'd understand this if we had decided that tribe X should win (which is what we should be doing) but we didn't. I got bored coming up with neutral reads all afternoon so jumped at the chance to play a challenge. (As did dozens of other people who aren't having fingers pointed at them).

You all need to take a hard look at the reasoning behind this stupid claim and look for wolves within this ridiculously read-less way to smear villagers.
deco

shut up about it

who do you want to lynch

dont defend yourself for being in a challenge. people will believe what they want about it

move on and play

make some good cases
Survivor Season 28 - 1/6 Werewolf Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote

      
m