Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
SE MegaElite Werewolf Crossover GAME THREAD SE MegaElite Werewolf Crossover GAME THREAD

11-28-2011 , 02:35 AM
actually lloyd was the only person to vote tuma d1 and lynch eadgeb

that could be adorable
SE MegaElite Werewolf Crossover GAME THREAD Quote
11-28-2011 , 02:36 AM
How come I'm the only one that thinks Geddy is a wolf?
SE MegaElite Werewolf Crossover GAME THREAD Quote
11-28-2011 , 02:41 AM
exhibit a - piling on a vanilla wofl, saving a roleblocker

_D1D2D3*D4D5D6D7
Debo9LLOYDUT2010CVIGNO VOTENO VOTEEADGBEDUKESUCKS
72offMCBEEFVICTORCVIGVYKMASTER/KKCEADGBEJUMANJI
DaerLLOYDUT2010CVIGSMIEEADGBEEADGBEJUMANJI
DukeSucksIRMVICTORRIVERMANVYKCHILLYEADGBEJUMANJI
riverboatkingNO VOTETUMAPALOVYKCHILLYEADGBEJUMANJI
showerman9BASAINTUT2010KARAKSMIEEADGBEEADGBEJUMANJI
tweedy/chipsahoyNO VOTETUMANO VOTESMIEEADGBEEADGBENO VOTE
DCIAceIRMTUMARIVERMANVYKLINEGUYEADGBEPVN
HungryH/mcavoyIRMTUMARIVERMANSMIEEADGBEEADGBEPVN
KarakIRMUT2010CVIGVYKLINEGUYEADGBEPVN
LuckyLloydTUMATUMACVIGVYKNATHEADGBEPVN
nutshot2NEEDLETUMACVIGVYKLINEGUYEADGBEPVN
PaloIRMUT2010RIVERMANSMIECHILLYEADGBEPVN
mjw0586TUMAUT2010VARIANCEVYKNO VOTEEADGBEXXXXXX

dci, karak, nutshot, palo all dead villagers, leaving lloyd, mcavoy and chips (kinda sorta, i think that was the day tweedy disappeared)

you want to see some bad pvn votes? there you go imo
SE MegaElite Werewolf Crossover GAME THREAD Quote
11-28-2011 , 02:42 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by McAvoy
How come I'm the only one that thinks Geddy is a wolf?
i think your both wolves
SE MegaElite Werewolf Crossover GAME THREAD Quote
11-28-2011 , 02:47 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kkcountry
i might be wrong about vix
I voted for the lynch every night except one where I was gone the whole time and picked at night. Looks right.
SE MegaElite Werewolf Crossover GAME THREAD Quote
11-28-2011 , 02:52 AM
I think of my strong villa leans throughout the game the one I've been least confident in has been Lloyd. We shouldn't lynch him though. Not today. We need to get Debo to post more itt. He's just laying low.
SE MegaElite Werewolf Crossover GAME THREAD Quote
11-28-2011 , 03:34 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by McAvoy
How come I'm the only one that thinks Geddy is a wolf?
Oh, I dunno...might have something to do with our only real interaction since you've joined:

Quote:
Originally Posted by Geddy Lee
Moving over to Karak, going to continue trying to dissuade people from jumping onto nutshot.
Quote:
Originally Posted by nutshot2
mine is the wolfiest looking wagon i've ever seen seriously
Quote:
Originally Posted by g-bebe
outside of aej yeah that is actually pretty wolfy
Quote:
Originally Posted by McAvoy
nut

Time for a CFD imo

Seriously guys, karak is one of my biggest villa leans
Quote:
Originally Posted by McAvoy
Seriously karak isa villa like 98% ofthetme here

his posts are too bad and too out there at times to be a wolf

The fact that pvn wants him dead should be a good enough reason not to lynch him

Look at who he'svoted out the past week
Quote:
Originally Posted by Geddy Lee
Killing nutshot in any capacity is a mistake. We cannot afford losing any more villas needlessly. Believe me, if I had the ability to contribute a better wagon, I would. I'm working on it.

We're gonna have 4 days after tonight to figure things out before it gets out of hand. We all need to take a step back and stop posting with our egos.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Geddy Lee
Goddammit, get off nutshot you idiots
Quote:
Originally Posted by McAvoy
nutshot

Geddy next imo
Quote:
Originally Posted by Geddy Lee
Yeah, you'd like that, wouldn't you? ****ing Habs fans always deliver the lulz.

McAvoy
Karak was all over the place itt but that's the guy you decided to vouch for, with a 98% tag of approval. He confused the **** out of everyone with some really bizarre posting, made himself a prime candidate for a lynching and yet he was still "one of your biggest villa leans." Your stated reasoning was pvn's endorsement of Karak's wagon being troublesome, despite pvn being seer cleared by DukeSucks. You decided pushing hard for nutshot was the optimal play.

nutshot said he was the angel on multiple occasions after Steroid Boy outed himself as seer to avoid a Whitegoose mislynch (a wagon which I was also opposed to but hey, whatever), and I'm going to guess he was probably the guy that protected SB for the first night - something he actually said he'd do in a post - but was unable to protect him on consecutive nights; nofear was killed on the night SB would've been killed had he not received protection, but SB also got roleblocked as well, then died the next night with only one angel left in the game. nutshot then asked for clarification on what happened in the next post; poor bastard probably thought his protection of SB saved him from all actions, not just death.

I mean, I don't know how else I was supposed to say "hey, I think nutshot is actually the angel and we should probably leave him alone" without explicitly declaring my belief he was a power role by providing evidence. Seems like that'd be a pretty good way to provide an easy target for the wolves. But I'm sure I wasn't the only player to notice his posts. I never voted for nutshot, I told Palo on multiple nights I disagreed with any nutshot wagon and nutshot never really provided any material to confirm him as a logical target for indictment.

I mean, ffs, this was nutshot's largest and most elaborate post all game:

Quote:
Originally Posted by nutshot2
yo

im a villager, seriously. i still don't even know how to play, really. i don't have any reads because i fall behind on the thread too much and then start skimming and have no clue whats going on. all i know is that you guys are real dumb if you think that low-content posts from me are a wolf tell. have you seen my other 18000 posts on 2+2? about 11k of them are thumbs. also, since i have no clue how to play, how could i go like 7th level and intentionally vote those two wolves early on and start wagons? gmafb

spend your time on line and let this villager chill, sons.
He never lied, he admitted he was in over his head and he trolled Karak right from the beginning of the game, which is like an SE tradition. It was vintage nutshot, posting exactly like he posts in SE. The best arguments against him were "zomg he's UTR."

This episode is your main basis for me being a wolf? If anything, I think this confrontation makes you look far worse than I do. Your "98% villa lean" on Karak is just atrocious; it's the kind of post that suggests you're privvied to information others aren't. All 3 seers are dead, so I wonder how else you could figure out Karak was clean?

Once again, I'm moving over to McAvoy and I think a wagon setup of McAvoy/kkc is a solid plan moving forward for today.
SE MegaElite Werewolf Crossover GAME THREAD Quote
11-28-2011 , 03:40 AM
Geddy,

I like how you conveniently left out the rest of the posts from our interaction. I'll get them tomorrow for you. I'll watch you slither in the meantime.
SE MegaElite Werewolf Crossover GAME THREAD Quote
11-28-2011 , 04:01 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kkcountry
maybe i should get all butthurt and take my ball and go home since it seems like i'm the only one interested in finding wolves today
I'm also trying to do the same thing and I've put forward an early target that's not you.

I mean, MEb's post about you is a really strong case in support of your lynching; DukeSucks' belief (perhaps aided by a peek) that you're a wolf, voting for pvn during the manji lynching, remaining high on MEb's hitlist after he dies and flips villa, confirming his work as genuine...it doesn't look good. But obviously there's more than one wolf left to kill, so regardless of who you are, you make a valid point either way - we need everyone to hunt today.
SE MegaElite Werewolf Crossover GAME THREAD Quote
11-28-2011 , 04:10 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kkcountry
exhibit a - piling on a vanilla wofl, saving a roleblocker

_D1D2D3*D4D5D6D7
Debo9LLOYDUT2010CVIGNO VOTENO VOTEEADGBEDUKESUCKS
72offMCBEEFVICTORCVIGVYKMASTER/KKCEADGBEJUMANJI
DaerLLOYDUT2010CVIGSMIEEADGBEEADGBEJUMANJI
DukeSucksIRMVICTORRIVERMANVYKCHILLYEADGBEJUMANJI
riverboatkingNO VOTETUMAPALOVYKCHILLYEADGBEJUMANJI
showerman9BASAINTUT2010KARAKSMIEEADGBEEADGBEJUMANJI
tweedy/chipsahoyNO VOTETUMANO VOTESMIEEADGBEEADGBENO VOTE
DCIAceIRMTUMARIVERMANVYKLINEGUYEADGBEPVN
HungryH/mcavoyIRMTUMARIVERMANSMIEEADGBEEADGBEPVN
KarakIRMUT2010CVIGVYKLINEGUYEADGBEPVN
LuckyLloydTUMATUMACVIGVYKNATHEADGBEPVN
nutshot2NEEDLETUMACVIGVYKLINEGUYEADGBEPVN
PaloIRMUT2010RIVERMANSMIECHILLYEADGBEPVN
mjw0586TUMAUT2010VARIANCEVYKNO VOTEEADGBEXXXXXX

dci, karak, nutshot, palo all dead villagers, leaving lloyd, mcavoy and chips (kinda sorta, i think that was the day tweedy disappeared)

you want to see some bad pvn votes? there you go imo
Wait, are you trying to imply here that pvn is a wolf? Like, am I missing something, or was pvn not seer cleared by DukeSucks?
SE MegaElite Werewolf Crossover GAME THREAD Quote
11-28-2011 , 04:24 AM
Nooooooo, I'm saying people who voted EADGBE one day and pvn the next are likely to be wolves since they piled on a wolf that was 'winning' by a sizable margin anyway to look good then tried to save their roleblocker the next day by voting pvn
SE MegaElite Werewolf Crossover GAME THREAD Quote
11-28-2011 , 04:28 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kkcountry
Nooooooo, I'm saying people who voted EADGBE one day and pvn the next are likely to be wolves since they piled on a wolf that was 'winning' by a sizable margin anyway to look good then tried to save their roleblocker the next day by voting pvn
Ahhh, okay that makes sense.

"Piling on a vanilla wolf...then trying to save a roleblocker."

Thanks for the clarification, sorry about that.
SE MegaElite Werewolf Crossover GAME THREAD Quote
11-28-2011 , 04:29 AM
This is why time of vote is so important, so we can figure out who's leading the wagons and who's hopping on last minute

(which is why your vote on pvn looks so bad)
SE MegaElite Werewolf Crossover GAME THREAD Quote
11-28-2011 , 04:30 AM
kkc's chart suggests McAvoy and Lloyd as wolves
SE MegaElite Werewolf Crossover GAME THREAD Quote
11-28-2011 , 04:31 AM
And I bet there's at least some chance C-Vig and Lloyd staged a fight on day 1 to keep Lloyd alive as long as possible as a power wolf

Maybe not a big chance-- certainly not our best lead-- but something to keep an eye on, especially since we have two days before the wolf vigilante strikes again
SE MegaElite Werewolf Crossover GAME THREAD Quote
11-28-2011 , 04:37 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Geddy Lee
Why would they kill DCI? That just seems really ****ing stupid...they wanna be knocking off confirmed villas at this point, right?
Indeed. Let's review who's seer peeked:

Whitegoose - Steroid Boy peek
showerman9 - DuckSucks peek
aejones- DukeSucks peek
pvn - DukeSucks peek
SE MegaElite Werewolf Crossover GAME THREAD Quote
11-28-2011 , 04:39 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by nath
This is why time of vote is so important, so we can figure out who's leading the wagons and who's hopping on last minute

(which is why your vote on pvn looks so bad)
I will do some research on the timing. Lynching the roleblocker is very different from some vanilla wolf.
SE MegaElite Werewolf Crossover GAME THREAD Quote
11-28-2011 , 04:50 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by nath
And I bet there's at least some chance C-Vig and Lloyd staged a fight on day 1 to keep Lloyd alive as long as possible as a power wolf

Maybe not a big chance-- certainly not our best lead-- but something to keep an eye on, especially since we have two days before the wolf vigilante strikes again
agree non zero chance

I have no great reason to read you villa so strong but damn it really really seems like I'm right. Since no one else is getting cleared you might have to die later (much later) but know it was for the village... heh
SE MegaElite Werewolf Crossover GAME THREAD Quote
11-28-2011 , 04:51 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chips Ahoy
Indeed. Let's review who's seer peeked:

Whitegoose - Steroid Boy peek
showerman9 - DuckSucks peek
aejones- DukeSucks peek
pvn - DukeSucks peek
More if you including McBeef "never lynch" list
SE MegaElite Werewolf Crossover GAME THREAD Quote
11-28-2011 , 05:03 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by vixticator
More if you including McBeef "never lynch" list
Yes, but that's risky. IMO McBeef 'peeked' DCI wolf, but that's impossible. Also, his never lynch list was long enough that if he had that many peeks he would almost certainly have claimed with a live angel.

When a seer dies without clear peeks, my policy is to not try to manufacture peeks. It's too frustrating to lose to a peek that wasn't.
SE MegaElite Werewolf Crossover GAME THREAD Quote
11-28-2011 , 05:32 AM
We can't just say he left us nothing or we are ****ed. Have to assume as if don't lynch list are mostly peeks. When it gets later in the game we re-evaluate.
SE MegaElite Werewolf Crossover GAME THREAD Quote
11-28-2011 , 05:39 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by vixticator
We can't just say he left us nothing or we are ****ed. Have to assume as if don't lynch list are mostly peeks. When it gets later in the game we re-evaluate.
4/18 players are peeked. Getting 2 peeks in a 17er is average so we're in a good spot.

I have no problem with lynching better suspects first, but if any of those peeks disappears, they can't be forgotten.
SE MegaElite Werewolf Crossover GAME THREAD Quote
11-28-2011 , 05:46 AM
Ya I agree.
SE MegaElite Werewolf Crossover GAME THREAD Quote
11-28-2011 , 10:23 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by nath
This is why time of vote is so important, so we can figure out who's leading the wagons and who's hopping on last minute

(which is why your vote on pvn looks so bad)
Yeah but it still only counts as one vote, just like anybody else's
SE MegaElite Werewolf Crossover GAME THREAD Quote
11-28-2011 , 10:29 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kkcountry
bump

nath
yeah this just seems too easy.

which is probably what they want us to think, of course. IF one of the two is indeed a wolf then why would they signal to us which one and eliminate the need for us to mislynch?

On the other hand, if they're both villas why would they eat one of our mislynches?

The action makes no sense in either case.

So the best course of action is to continue as we were, I believe.

nath
SE MegaElite Werewolf Crossover GAME THREAD Quote

      
m