Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Save Our Souls Mish Mash GAME THREAD Save Our Souls Mish Mash GAME THREAD

01-24-2012 , 01:24 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by CPHoya
I'm becoming pretty convinced that SYF is a neutral by the way.
Most people that jump to neutral conclusions rather than wolf are >rand wolves. Why neutral and not wolf?
Save Our Souls Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-24-2012 , 01:25 PM
and to echo whoever has been saying it before, I think halpert is a wolf also
Save Our Souls Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-24-2012 , 01:27 PM
is ITA over?
Save Our Souls Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-24-2012 , 01:28 PM
So wait Steve. I scream and yell at Telco and generally antagonize a neutral, then accuse you of being a neutral, and your response is "I think the same of you"? Why?

I think you're a neutral because you soft-peddle what you say and because this post:

Quote:
Because I've been asking about you all day and no one has responded. At least you are starting to redeem yourself with your reasons for shooting dryice. Thoughts on Hoya since I have your attention? Oh and also Eadgbe and gadarene?
is you cherry picking currently active players to look like you're contributing and analyzing current events.
Save Our Souls Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-24-2012 , 01:29 PM
i thought they were gonna be at 12 i took a nap and set an alarm and everything
Save Our Souls Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-24-2012 , 01:29 PM
But you're not a wolf, probably, because you'd just back off instead of discussing it.

How on earth I could be a neutral is something you need to explain.

Also Jim doing a weird thing where he clears me on tone and in his very next post makes up a broadly applicable theory that "most people who think someone is a neutral are > rand to be wolves," then applies that same broadly applicable theory to me to challenge me to explain the Steve read. Which is weird in like 135316136 ways.
Save Our Souls Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-24-2012 , 01:29 PM
I will now begin going through some UTRs


The complete archives of FCBLComish


Quote:
Originally Posted by FCBLComish
Hi everyone

Phone posting for now

Great news

I AM THE SEER

Luckay Luck is a villager

JUST KIDDING I'M NOT THE SEER
Quote:
Originally Posted by FCBLComish
Why?
Quote:
Originally Posted by FCBLComish
I would not exceed a 100 posts per game restriction.
Quote:
Originally Posted by FCBLComish
I always leave my seer cover with one of my first posts of the day. There is always a chance that I will be called away and not be able to get back to the thread before end of day.
The main wave of posting from FCBLComish comes on page 1 on a phone. It's uber thin and I will not be making my conclusion based off of it, but I do think starting off early and posting a lot on the phone at thread open is mildly, mildly, mildly villagery. There's no need to be in the thread at that time as a wolf if it's inconvenient.

As for the posts themselves, he has a logical explanation for leaving his seer cover as first post (which he always does).


Quote:
Originally Posted by FCBLComish
NL Soldier


I am caught up and going out for the afternoon. I will TRY to get back before EOD.
Places a vote and leaves, but no reason.

Quote:
Originally Posted by FCBLComish
HI GUYS


I AM THE SEER

FOR SOME REASON I DID NOT GET A PEEK LAST NIGHT

JUST KIDDING, I AM NOT THE SEER
Quote:
Originally Posted by FCBLComish
Today is Tuesday, and I will not be available at all.

Here are a few thoughts.

1) Please don't ITA me.
2) LYNCH XXSOOTED
3) Booker WOLFBOX.... FUUUUUUUUUU








Conclusion: Indecisive. There is nothing here he cannot post as a wolf, but also nothing that makes me think is is >rand to be a wolf.
Save Our Souls Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-24-2012 , 01:30 PM
how about we not go over UTRs. seems like busy work
Save Our Souls Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-24-2012 , 01:32 PM
That really sucks about vlad.
Save Our Souls Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-24-2012 , 01:32 PM
First thought while I read: VMF being gone all day, showing up right before EoD, and then apparently not catching up on the thread until it reopens is pretty wolfy. I would think he would've reread at least some of the thread during the night. If he was a wolf, he would obviously have read the thread during the night, so it seems likely to me that he's posting his page-by-page reads as if he's catching up right when the thread opens as a bit of a show. Also hate that he's never going to be around during the day and will instead just show up 10 min before EoD.
Save Our Souls Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-24-2012 , 01:33 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by CPHoya
But you're not a wolf, probably, because you'd just back off instead of discussing it.

How on earth I could be a neutral is something you need to explain.

Also Jim doing a weird thing where he clears me on tone and in his very next post makes up a broadly applicable theory that "most people who think someone is a neutral are > rand to be wolves," then applies that same broadly applicable theory to me to challenge me to explain the Steve read. Which is weird in like 135316136 ways.
more like 2 ways
1. its weird because you are viewing it as me trying to put heat on you rather than me saying "bro, normally people who say that are wolves, can you explain why you jumped right to neutral because i just called you a villager and im curious what makes you jump there".
2. its weird because you think you're way too good to have general principles applied to you in any instance
Save Our Souls Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-24-2012 , 01:33 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jonnyd
how about we not go over UTRs. seems like busy work
what?
Save Our Souls Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-24-2012 , 01:33 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Felix the Cat
younguns87

He has taken hero shots in the past as villager. So taking a hero shot here as a villager is not the problem per se. The problem comes from him discussing taking hero shots yesterday - it looks way too much like a setup to dispel any heat from misses in advance.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Loretta8


my thinking exactly
Is was a psuedo set up, but the reasoning behind it is just. I knew I was gonna take a hero shot eventually, and I knew there would be a rebuttle as was the case in Disney,HP3 and Dark Materials? In all these mishmashes villagers made hero shots, and villagers were able to clear themselves thereafter. I have never been lynched for my hero shot as of yet, not saying I don't or haven't deserved it, but I have managed to clear myself in some fashion thereafter. Obviously as a wolf I would do the same thing, as I have the perfect cover to do so.

It is not anti-village behaivor either, If I am a villager how are the wolves increasing their kill rate? There's a chance I hit a wolf or a neutral for that matter, as Seen by Chrja's Shot.
Save Our Souls Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-24-2012 , 01:34 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JimHalpert
more like 2 ways
1. its weird because you are viewing it as me trying to put heat on you rather than me saying "bro, normally people who say that are wolves, can you explain why you jumped right to neutral because i just called you a villager and im curious what makes you jump there".
2. its weird because you think you're way too good to have general principles applied to you in any instance
Re: 2, I am and I think you know that.

Re: 1 you have an explanation.
Save Our Souls Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-24-2012 , 01:35 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by CPHoya
AFK ten minutes, back for ITAs. Telco, you dead son.
Just quoting a random post cause the 2p2 app is being ******ed and won't reload past page 99.
Save Our Souls Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-24-2012 , 01:37 PM
You killed Lyra Silvertounge!!!

I'd have shot him too.

Also YG if you're a villager you have the WOAT luck with ITAs
Save Our Souls Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-24-2012 , 01:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jonnyd
how about we not go over UTRs. seems like busy work
im ever so sorry my contributions are insufficient to your desires.
ill be sure to just stop trying to solve peoples roles that are likely to be targeted for ITAs
Save Our Souls Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-24-2012 , 01:37 PM
Are the ITAs still open?

Is there anyone who needs pew pewing?
Save Our Souls Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-24-2012 , 01:38 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by CPHoya
So wait Steve. I scream and yell at Telco and generally antagonize a neutral, then accuse you of being a neutral, and your response is "I think the same of you"? Why?

I think you're a neutral because you soft-peddle what you say and because this post:



is you cherry picking currently active players to look like you're contributing and analyzing current events.
Because you present a case to shoot telco which is fairly sound but then others and yourself ultimately decide that you want to wait on him rather than ITA him. I agreed with this and thought you should wait and let things resolve themselves before using your ITA.

All of a sudden you attack vlad. I don't understand that. I can understand why you may do it later but it seems odd to not save your ITA to maybe use on telcon later or someone else.
Save Our Souls Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-24-2012 , 01:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JimHalpert
im ever so sorry my contributions are insufficient to your desires.
ill be sure to just stop trying to solve peoples roles that are likely to be targeted for ITAs
No need to get self righteous about it im just saying we just had an ita period that could probably give us more info
Save Our Souls Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-24-2012 , 01:39 PM
Sigh this app is ****ing ******ed. I try to change the ppp an it keeps crashing.
Save Our Souls Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-24-2012 , 01:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by DonkDonkDonkDonk
You killed Lyra Silvertounge!!!

I'd have shot him too.

Also YG if you're a villager you have the WOAT luck with ITAs
Ive shot 2 wolf in 12 attempts now. but it was the GOAT wolf snipa PBaL both times so I can take that to the grave with me.
Save Our Souls Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-24-2012 , 01:41 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jonnyd
how about we not go over UTRs. seems like busy work
what? this just seems, idk. explain jonny
Save Our Souls Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-24-2012 , 01:42 PM
just saw your post.

i do agree with knowing we can learn a lot about the ITA period we had and reading those wolves killed for spew. but doing UTR work is helpful too. we have another period in just over 3 hours, and plenty of shots left. we should be looking at both UTR and the ITA period.
Save Our Souls Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote
01-24-2012 , 01:42 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jonnyd
No need to get self righteous about it im just saying we just had an ita period that could probably give us more info
well why dont you do work with that or say something like "lets do utrs in a bit but lets look at ita stuff first" instead of just saying its useless?
Save Our Souls Mish Mash GAME THREAD Quote

      
m