gonna respond goofy, I think you took some things out of context
Quote:
Originally Posted by goofyballer
- 380: wtf??? thinks aloud wondering if we should keep our wagons close together so we figure out who the RR is. obviously the wolves would LOVE it if we cleared that up for them.
This for instance. I wasn't advocating we do it, I was wondering aloud if there would be any gain in doing so. It was speculation, harmless speculation at that. re-read more of the discussion than just my posts and you'll get what i mean
Quote:
Originally Posted by goofyballer
- 968: asks caedus if he really has that much of a strong villa read on nightwood. I think this could easily be a wolf probing caedus (who had been dropping seer cover hints about me and now nightwood apparently) to see if he could be a seer. caedus did then get NKed that night.
Would a wolf do that though? Openly question somebody he suspected of being a seer? I think that's pretty unlikely. In any case I'm asking for caedus' opinion here because I think he's an amazing ww player and he and I had conflicting reads on nightwood, so I wanted his take before really trying to wagon night.
Quote:
Originally Posted by goofyballer
- 1261: does a complete reread of gtpitch. points out a post where gtpitch says WER/brian/nightwood suspicious and says that usually wolves include one wolf in these lists. of course, we now know that everyone in that list is villa. dj gives villa points to mdom, oobrian, thinks people looking wolfy (from gtpitch) are malgin, mrsbutton
- 1292: gtpitch d2 analysis: villa points to karak, nightwood, stark, brian, slink, corsakh, possible wolfy points to mburke, bingo (interestingly because he pointed out another gtpitch wolf list which DID have a wolf on it, corsakh, but dj thought corsakh was villa)
yeah I was almost completely wrong, par for the course unfortunately.
Quote:
Originally Posted by goofyballer
- 1354: switches to mrsbutton at last minute, v/v wagon though so doesn't really matter. his reason for switching is interesting though, he says it needs to be closer. curious if he's trying to sniff out the 3x villa. malgin was up like 7-3 before dj switched (and made it 6-4).
I voted for mrsbutton (and it wasn't last minute) because malgin was racing ahead at the time and we get much more information from 2 wagons that one. Seemed like a good idea, and there was time to change my vote again before EOD to malgin who I liked better as a possible wolf, so my voting button just served to tighten the race a bit and get us more information than we would have had otherwise.
Quote:
Originally Posted by goofyballer
- 1417: switches back to malgin. between when he voted for mrsbutton and now, mrsbutton had taken the lead and was now up 6-4, so it seems like he's going back to even up the vote count. this seriously reeks of 3x hunting, esp coming from the guy who advocated that we intentionally rig out votes to figure out who the 3x is on d1.
Again, I always liked malgin better than buttons and said so, but I didn't want the malgin wagon to take off without competition. Once the mrsbutton wagon got going again I switched to the person I felt was the more likely wolf.
Quote:
Originally Posted by goofyballer
- 2666: says we (villa) have much better leads on the SK than the wolves at this point. ok, that's just ******ed, because the villa has LESS information than the wolves. our read on anyone CAN'T be better than what the wolves know. this really sounds like a wolf trying to get villas to hunt the SK for them. although the last two times i've made that argument in favor of someone being a wolf I was wrong so w/e.
You misunderstood what I was saying. I was saying that the village had better leads on who the SK was than who the wolves were. Not that we had better leads on the SK than the wolves did.