K necro is good. Hifi looks better.

necro

Iversonian is the best vote I think.

Its not too late to lynch him, 20 mins left.

Look how little he has done other than defend himself after I called him out for downplaying his wolf game.

I tend to agree with magic gazz. I think a villager that was reading carefully would notice if their reads were identical to most of one of their wolf reads.

I don't, as a general rule, like long lists of reads. I was actually getting pretty suspicious of magic gazz when I read him throwing out that list and repeatedly trying for comments. Personally I see that as either wolfing or lazy villaging. Villagers should be trying to show evidence for their reads, or at least show how they arrived at those reads, not throwing them out there and seeing what sticks, which is how I perceived what magic gazz was doing.

But given what he was trying, I agree it is at least moderately strange that jim halpert didn't notice his list of reads was identical to his top wolf lean. Most people, when someone they believe is a wolf gives a long list of reads calling them a villager and otherwise agreeing, would react to the fact that the "wolf" is calling them a villager, at the very least.

I agree that it's not reflective of a villager mindset.

That entire case is awful and nonsensical

<3 tho

First sentence doesn't jive with the rest of the post.

First underlined bit is super thin. I think she's done a suitable amount of playing for day 1. I don't know what your expectations are.

Second underlined bit: everyone is presumably "trying to avoid a lynch", it's when someone seems to be approaching the game only doing the minimum necessary to avoid a lynch that we have a problem. "Is possibly uncomfortable actively wolfing" is an unfounded assumption and shows that you're taking your conception of HiFi = wolf and tossing out reasons she may be a wolf, rather than considering evidence and drawing conclusions.

And to top it all off, the entire chunk of reasoning is applicable several times over to necro, yet you don't even mention him. In necro you have a guy who is actually unambiguously UTR, has done almost zero playing, has disappeared and reappeared, and so on. If this is what you're looking for to find a wolf day 1, then how do you end up voting HiFi over necro?

(Note: I'm not making a case on necro, mostly because the case has already been made. I'm saying that TBob, given what he's telling us, ought to be leading the charge on necro, not ignoring him.)

Are you even reading the thread?

Does anyone find it odd that Mac has done **** all and is now trying to lead the lynch?

Does it help that I decided to call him a wolf before a read a single one of his posts because of a meta read with him only having 10 posts?

Votes as of post 1308
Night in 00:19
---

Votes	Lynch	Voters
6	necro	Aksdal (46), chrja (30), Gadarene (92), HiFi (33), teddyyyr1974 (83), Tehtoes (39)
3	Felix the Cat	Steve Yzerman fan (59), TheNothing (27), Willi (45)
3	TheNothing	Felix the Cat (38), OrangeRake (60), Sun Tzu (3)
2	HiFi	TBobLP (70), captain binkles (97)
2	OrangeRake	JimHalpert (134), Swiitch (82)
1	chrja	VarianceMinefield (99)
1	iversonian	magic_gazz (109)
1	JimHalpert	VoraciousReader (27)
1	magic_gazz	McAvoy (44)
1	McAvoy	J.D. (17)
1	TBobLP	iversonian (38)
1	not voting	necro (10)

:00 good :01 bad

But OR declining to quote McAvoy's EIGHT POSTS showing which ones were villagery is ultimately worse. I do want to express support for magic gazz's theory though. It seems as though everyone else is dismissing it, and I don't think that makes sense.

orangerake

cool story

care to explain the wording and how you weight those two things as more important than my content which you describe as good?

That was a rude way to point out that false statement. I'm trying to behave, sorry

So you had time to read that did you......

I think Iversonian has been villagery, he's a bad option

yes? not as closely as I would like since I had to read most of the last half of the day from my phone at work while fielding phone calls, but I didn't want to show up without having read anything and try to catch up on 600 posts or something.

not really

it's within normal Mac range

I meant Tehtoes' case on me

Mac's Lock meta read #2

OrangeRake wouldn't spend 60 posts playing ww on day one when her wedding is in two weeks. That makes her a lock villager in Mac's book.

Ww is ez

Sure it does

it's really villagery of him but there's no way to use that and make the connection that jim is a wolf given that jim had already clarified he didn't really feel strongly about his magic read at all

so it's perfectly reasonable he's just not paying that much attention to what magic was doing

iversonian sorry binkles but I've got to trust Orangerake's read plus i like messing with magic.

VR, thanks for the support.

Im never sure if what im saying makes any sense.

It doesnt help when people read what they want rather than try to understand what the person is actually trying to express.

I made multiple statements that my read on magic was very thin, that I didn't want to really focus on him at this point as I'd have a better grasp after a day or 2, and that I was iffy on a few things. He certainly wasn't my largest wolf read like you're attempting to portray it. I'm wondering if you just didn't really read the interaction very closely or if you're trying to manipulate it.

Felix, point made and understood. I am happy w a necro lynch even tho I haven't said much.

Votes as of post 1324
Night in 00:15
---

Votes	Lynch	Voters
6	necro	Aksdal (46), chrja (30), Gadarene (92), HiFi (33), teddyyyr1974 (83), Tehtoes (41)
3	Felix the Cat	Steve Yzerman fan (59), TheNothing (27), Willi (45)
3	OrangeRake	JimHalpert (136), Swiitch (82), VoraciousReader (29)
3	TheNothing	Felix the Cat (39), OrangeRake (60), Sun Tzu (3)
2	HiFi	TBobLP (71), captain binkles (99)
2	iversonian	magic_gazz (111), McAvoy (47)
1	chrja	VarianceMinefield (99)
1	McAvoy	J.D. (17)
1	TBobLP	iversonian (38)
1	not voting	necro (10)

:00 good :01 bad