Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Regular Run of the Mill NO LIST Codenames! Regular Run of the Mill NO LIST Codenames!

09-08-2023 , 07:22 PM
No fans of The Sandlot around here???
Regular Run of the Mill NO LIST Codenames! Quote
09-08-2023 , 07:28 PM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dgEdMldQLT0

I never actually watched it but I've been in the room when it was on.
Regular Run of the Mill NO LIST Codenames! Quote
09-08-2023 , 07:28 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by D1iabol1cal
So this is exactly the situation I was talking about earlier itt where if you have 2 or 3 words left and the next word on the list is correct, an unlimited clue is a much better way to get that across. I was in a super awkward spot at the end where I had no way of linking 3 words and the only other word mentioned was wrong, but my only option was to give a 2 clue and just hope you would avoid cross (I thought crash was really strong tbh, but whatever). It's a huge flaw in the n-1 convention.

I do think you should've known that cross was never gonna be for shrapnel once fire was blue tho. It barely made sense to begin with, but it made even less sense now. But you guys just totally moved on from it after turn 1 and never discussed that clue again.

Oh well, we had no way of winning once Babe whiffed anyway. Does nobody know that Babe is an Australian movie? I honestly thought that was just common knowledge, but maybe not for Americans.

Gg

And yeah, sorry D1iab. I realized right after bolding that I hadn’t considered closing out shrapnel. I never would’ve guessed Cross for that.

I also had no idea that Babe was an Australian movie.
Regular Run of the Mill NO LIST Codenames! Quote
09-08-2023 , 08:57 PM
Yeah I wouldn’t have known king of crash either

Not one of the more known names afaik, but he had dozens of nicknames I think; he was pretty good at stick ball
Regular Run of the Mill NO LIST Codenames! Quote
09-08-2023 , 10:46 PM
I didn't know Crash but IBD did so we coulda gotten it

We shoulda came back to it regardless as mentioned but needed a little more help on Australia, I absolutely had no clue it was an Australian movie but there are Australian babes

Think Babe - 3 woulda worked better cause that would have guaranteed we would never guess cross, (prob shouldn't have anyway but it kinda looked like we mighta spursed into it and you wanted us to fetch it from before + find 2 babe words)
Regular Run of the Mill NO LIST Codenames! Quote
09-08-2023 , 10:53 PM
sent board to neil

if this post is odd, i'll be red




Antarctica
Axe
Big Bang
Blade
Brass
Cherry
Draft
Dressing
Ghost
Greece
Lawyer
Lemonade
London
Minotaur
Parachute
Polo
Rat
Rome
Sister
Sloth
Superhero
Tear
Texas
Thumb
Viking
Regular Run of the Mill NO LIST Codenames! Quote
09-08-2023 , 10:53 PM
it was odd
Regular Run of the Mill NO LIST Codenames! Quote
09-08-2023 , 11:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by AmazingErvin
Think Babe - 3 woulda worked better cause that would have guaranteed we would never guess cross, (prob shouldn't have anyway but it kinda looked like we mighta spursed into it and you wanted us to fetch it from before + find 2 babe words)
Yeah, as I said before, this is the big problem with the n-1 method at endgame. There is no way to get your team off the next word unless you try to force a clue that is very unlikely to work. If we change to unlimited with 2 or 3 words left when next word on the list is correct, it would fix that.
Regular Run of the Mill NO LIST Codenames! Quote
09-09-2023 , 06:02 AM
yea we didn't have to necessarily guess next word....

that's sorta the current meta cause if we don't guess next word what do we do?

leave us w/ 1 word left and them w/ a 2 their turn?

we can do a random I suppose or some direction with a 3 clue

both seem difficult
Regular Run of the Mill NO LIST Codenames! Quote
09-09-2023 , 07:30 AM
Yeah, I don't blame you for guessing cross or anything...I expected it.

What I'm saying is if there is an obvious next guess and you have 2 or 3 words left, then you clue unlimited if it's correct or give a normal clue if it's wrong. There is no confusion there, but everybody sorta has to sign off on it or else it will be if people are doing different things. It would be much better to know that your next word is wrong without having to overclue something just to get your team off of it.

Also, sometimes you've caught up on all the clues but you have a good 2 or 3 clue which will leave one left but you can't finish that turn. If there was another word that was discussed, that means your team will guess it anyway. So you have to give a 1 clue instead and give the bigger clue last which just kinda sucks.

I'm not sure if any of those ramblings were coherent or not...I've had a bit to drink haha.
Regular Run of the Mill NO LIST Codenames! Quote
09-09-2023 , 09:26 AM
It was our bad not considering how any of the words we were suggesting could close out the first clue. That’s priority ahead of conventions like n-1.

I’m good with the unlimited approach D1iab’s preaching, and you’ll see it from me next time I’m clueing in that position.
Regular Run of the Mill NO LIST Codenames! Quote
09-09-2023 , 11:10 AM
re-posting



Antarctica
Axe
Big Bang
Blade
Brass
Cherry
Draft
Dressing
Ghost
Greece
Lawyer
Lemonade
London
Minotaur
Parachute
Polo
Rat
Rome
Sister
Sloth
Superhero
Tear
Texas
Thumb
Viking
Regular Run of the Mill NO LIST Codenames! Quote
09-09-2023 , 11:11 AM
suit - 4
Regular Run of the Mill NO LIST Codenames! Quote
09-09-2023 , 12:53 PM
Lawyer and Superhero by far my favorites.

Other possibilities:
Cherry (color)
Draft (people wear suits at NBA draft)
Ghost (more of a costume, but possible)
Parachute (skydiving suit)
Polo (another form of clothing)
Tear (suit could have a tear)

Not sure what I like most of those. Will let others chime in.
Regular Run of the Mill NO LIST Codenames! Quote
09-09-2023 , 12:58 PM
Lawyer and superhero

Then:

Dressing: putting on a suit is dressing up; decent but don’t love it
Polo: a polo shirt is a more business casual outfit, but also the company makes suits
Draft: players at the draft always wear suits
Brass: the big brass at companies would always wear suits back in the days that we called them brass; also brass buttons on suits
London: known for their tailors and suits


I think I like polo best and no clue on what is fourth; not sure I’d fight for or against any of them…london prolly the most tenuous tho
Regular Run of the Mill NO LIST Codenames! Quote
09-09-2023 , 06:00 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by IBeDrummin
It was our bad not considering how any of the words we were suggesting could close out the first clue. That’s priority ahead of conventions like n-1.

I’m good with the unlimited approach D1iab’s preaching, and you’ll see it from me next time I’m clueing in that position.
Yea I've been a vocal opponent of n-1 on the last turn so I'm not guessing the last considered word anymore unless I see an unlimited clue
Regular Run of the Mill NO LIST Codenames! Quote
09-10-2023 , 01:21 PM
bump
Regular Run of the Mill NO LIST Codenames! Quote
09-10-2023 , 02:53 PM
Id put dressing as 3. They are very closely related

Id go lawyer 4th?

Cuz of the show
Regular Run of the Mill NO LIST Codenames! Quote
09-10-2023 , 04:50 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Doctor Zeus
Id put dressing as 3. They are very closely related

Id go lawyer 4th?

Cuz of the show
Very confused as to what your top two are.
Regular Run of the Mill NO LIST Codenames! Quote
09-10-2023 , 05:13 PM
Lawyer and superhero

Im really tired sorry
Regular Run of the Mill NO LIST Codenames! Quote
09-10-2023 , 05:14 PM
We have a clear top 2 so need 2 more

I like polo and dressing but I’m open
Regular Run of the Mill NO LIST Codenames! Quote
09-10-2023 , 05:47 PM
Lawyer
Superhero
Regular Run of the Mill NO LIST Codenames! Quote
09-10-2023 , 05:55 PM
Lawyer
Superhero
Regular Run of the Mill NO LIST Codenames! Quote
09-10-2023 , 06:31 PM
I'm on team Polo here.
Regular Run of the Mill NO LIST Codenames! Quote
09-10-2023 , 06:32 PM
Me too
Regular Run of the Mill NO LIST Codenames! Quote

      
m