Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
PTP Vanilla+ Game Thread PTP Vanilla+ Game Thread

09-27-2013 , 07:59 PM
Votes from post 1 to post 1175
Night in 0:01:56

---
VotesLynchVoters
5 Askthepizzaguy DividedSky (55), Charry (22), thediceman (28), ReddBoiler (45), mexineil (24)
4 DividedSky ShipItUp (95), bhuber2010 (40), well named (100), chrisrjdk (66)
3 CPHoya Luckbox Inc (98), HUstylez (53), comeasur337 (15)
2 ReddBoiler tmleafs1967 (81), Askthepizzaguy (100)
2 bhuber2010 tappokone (33), CPHoya (100)
1 VarianceMinefield Felix the Cat (72)
1 mexineil VarianceMinefield (75)
1 comeasur337 Xkf (43)

:00 good :01 bad
PTP Vanilla+ Game Thread Quote
09-27-2013 , 07:59 PM
sweet lord DividedSky
PTP Vanilla+ Game Thread Quote
09-27-2013 , 07:59 PM
jesus you're going to lynch pizza??

thats beyond bad

this game is going to be a disaster if people play like this
PTP Vanilla+ Game Thread Quote
09-27-2013 , 07:59 PM
Votes from post 1 to post 1178
Night in 0:01:22

---
VotesLynchVoters
5 DividedSky Felix the Cat (73), ShipItUp (95), bhuber2010 (40), well named (100), chrisrjdk (66)
5 Askthepizzaguy DividedSky (55), Charry (22), thediceman (28), ReddBoiler (45), mexineil (24)
3 CPHoya Luckbox Inc (99), HUstylez (53), comeasur337 (15)
2 ReddBoiler tmleafs1967 (81), Askthepizzaguy (100)
2 bhuber2010 tappokone (33), CPHoya (100)
1 mexineil VarianceMinefield (75)
1 comeasur337 Xkf (43)

:00 good :01 bad
PTP Vanilla+ Game Thread Quote
09-27-2013 , 07:59 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Felix the Cat
I didn't explicitly call him a wolf, but I'm pretty sure we weren't having a friendly "let us resolve our villagery differences" conversation at that point (yes, at the point you were talking about)

I want to be sure before I call VMF a wolf.

I am now sure. Thought I would have to reread (and I will for completeness) but his posting since I've been back today has been so excessively howly that even I can see that it's out of his villager range
Exactly, he was saying you were confidently pushing him, I was pointing out that it was a lie. This isn't hard to understand, read the conversation and stop making assumptions.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Felix the Cat
SWEET JESUS I JUST NOTICED SOMETHING OMG
Hurry up and post it then!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Luckbox Inc
The first post WN quoted did seem really wolfy...the rest of his case? meh..

But since he's been back DS has felt villagery

vote for Hoya
I'll cast my own vote thank you.
PTP Vanilla+ Game Thread Quote
09-27-2013 , 08:00 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by VarianceMinefield
we really cant lynch hoya or pizzaguy when they have used up all their posts

they could be power roles and this is day 1. we cant punish them for making a mistake

but they need to make sure not to spew so much so early
probably not I don't think either are that bad to put themselves in such a position, and theyd prolly risk the 1/50 modkill if they were a PR At risk
PTP Vanilla+ Game Thread Quote
09-27-2013 , 08:00 PM
WE ARE LYNCHING VMF TOMORROW NO OTHER LYNCHES WILL BE CONSIDERED THANK YOU FOR YOUR COOPERATION
PTP Vanilla+ Game Thread Quote
09-27-2013 , 08:00 PM
Votes from post 1 to post 1182
Night in 0:00:48

---
VotesLynchVoters
5 DividedSky Felix the Cat (74), ShipItUp (96), bhuber2010 (40), well named (100), chrisrjdk (66)
5 Askthepizzaguy DividedSky (55), Charry (22), thediceman (28), ReddBoiler (45), mexineil (24)
3 CPHoya Luckbox Inc (99), HUstylez (54), comeasur337 (15)
2 ReddBoiler tmleafs1967 (81), Askthepizzaguy (100)
2 bhuber2010 tappokone (33), CPHoya (100)
1 mexineil VarianceMinefield (75)
1 comeasur337 Xkf (43)

:00 good :01 bad
PTP Vanilla+ Game Thread Quote
09-27-2013 , 08:00 PM
dividedsky

mayor I hope you're right

pizza.. we'll chat tomorrow
PTP Vanilla+ Game Thread Quote
09-27-2013 , 08:00 PM
SIU i will respond tomorrow i had better things to do

you are not concerned with eod why?
PTP Vanilla+ Game Thread Quote
09-27-2013 , 08:00 PM
Angel put me in the rand, thanks.
PTP Vanilla+ Game Thread Quote
09-27-2013 , 08:00 PM
Votes from post 1 to post 1186
Night in 0:00:14

---
VotesLynchVoters
6 DividedSky Charry (23), Felix the Cat (75), ShipItUp (97), bhuber2010 (40), well named (100), chrisrjdk (66)
4 Askthepizzaguy DividedSky (55), thediceman (28), ReddBoiler (45), mexineil (24)
3 CPHoya Luckbox Inc (99), HUstylez (54), comeasur337 (15)
2 ReddBoiler tmleafs1967 (81), Askthepizzaguy (100)
2 bhuber2010 tappokone (33), CPHoya (100)
1 mexineil VarianceMinefield (75)
1 comeasur337 Xkf (43)

:00 good :01 bad
PTP Vanilla+ Game Thread Quote
09-27-2013 , 08:00 PM
peek or kill hoya
PTP Vanilla+ Game Thread Quote
09-27-2013 , 08:01 PM
Votes from post 1 to post 1188
It is night

---
VotesLynchVoters
7 DividedSky Charry (23), Felix the Cat (75), ShipItUp (97), bhuber2010 (40), well named (100), chrisrjdk (66)
4 Askthepizzaguy DividedSky (55), thediceman (28), ReddBoiler (45), mexineil (24)
3 CPHoya Luckbox Inc (99), HUstylez (55), comeasur337 (15)
2 ReddBoiler tmleafs1967 (81), Askthepizzaguy (100)
2 bhuber2010 tappokone (33), CPHoya (100)
1 mexineil VarianceMinefield (75)
1 comeasur337 Xkf (43)
PTP Vanilla+ Game Thread Quote
09-27-2013 , 08:03 PM
The last vote count has been edited to take into account SiU's vote

5 minutes for corrections. Remember I don't reveal the full role, just the faction. For the Gypsy this is the villager faction despite them winning with the wolves.
PTP Vanilla+ Game Thread Quote
09-27-2013 , 08:14 PM
The crowd started to gather outside DividedSky's house. They claimed his sky was way too divided to be a villager. There may have been multiple MQs thrown around in an all too dangerous fashion. Divided Sky was promptly taken to the gallows with a noose tied around his neck, waiting for the night to come for an attempt to escape with his mighty WOLF claws. However just before the sun escaped down the sky he dropped and was instantly killed.

IT IS NIGHT

Night actions by 5am please.
PTP Vanilla+ Game Thread Quote
09-28-2013 , 03:30 AM
Seeking revenge for their fallen sky brother, the other wolves pounced on their opportunity to take revenge. Being of the Lupine variety of animals they took their first shot at Felix the Cat, a villager to remove the Feline presence.

The lunatic lived up to his name last night. Wielding landmines he planted them outside VarianceMinefield's house blowing up the entire neighborhood. Good thing the lunatic had his dental records! VarianceMinefield was a villager

It is day!
PTP Vanilla+ Game Thread Quote
09-28-2013 , 03:33 AM
Playerlist:
Askthepizzaguy
bhuber2010
Charry
chrisrjdk
comeasur337
CPHoya
HUstylez
Luckbox Inc
mexineil
ReddBoiler
ShipItUp
tappokone
thediceman
tmleafs1967
well named
Xkf

I'm going to bed late so no vote counts until like noon. You're free to make your own. 100 post restriction still applies today.
PTP Vanilla+ Game Thread Quote
09-28-2013 , 03:47 AM
All right, apologies to Felix the Cat, he's the one I had in red which I wasn't as sure about. His posts were about 30% villager tell and 60% wolf tell and 10% utter nonsense, and like I said, irredeemable regardless of role.

VarianceMinefield was an absolutely atrocious vigilante hit, I had that one as villager all day long. Utterly annoying, continuously said I had no offense. What the hell game was VMF reading? Certainly not any game containing my posts. That one was too oblivious to what I had posted to be a wolf. Not a very helpful villager, we could have lost someone more useful who was paying attention to the game, so no great loss there.

Lunatic should have shot ReddBoiler. Hell, you should have lynched ReddBoiler. Alpha wolf lynches are superior to vanilla wolf lynches.

Happy to see that DividedSky the lurking wolf I had in dark red did indeed flip wolf. No surprises that DividedSky tried to get me lynched while I was not able to post. Surprised however that he got the necessary votes to be lynched.

Glad to see I was not the nonsense lynch yesterday. But I'm still completely pissed off that ReddBoiler is alive. No guts, no glory, after all.

If you're going to ignore me then what's the point of me posting? Most of the people who commented about my posts clearly hadn't read then and then mischaracterized the content of those posts to other people who hadn't read them. I continue to think ReddBoiler is your best lynch, but after certain Musketeer games, it is now my policy not to press the same person day after day after day.

if ReddBoiler is lynchable, I am there. However, since everyone and their brother thinks he's villager, I'm wasting my time pursuing it. If he's the alpha wolf he's completely un-clearable. You'll just have to take my word for it when he's still alive near endgame I suppose. Or maybe the lunatic could flip that card over and see what it says, since village doesn't have the balls.

The person I am most disappointed in is mexineil. You turned on me.

I gave you the alpha wolf
and you turned on me.

This, I cannot forgive.

mexineil

Kool Kids club access revoked.
PTP Vanilla+ Game Thread Quote
09-28-2013 , 03:55 AM
No need to thank me guys, just doing my job(and not articulating it at all :P)
PTP Vanilla+ Game Thread Quote
09-28-2013 , 03:56 AM
ShipItUp clearly destined to be Mayor. Clearly made the best choice yesterday.

Well played, SIU. Pleased to see leafs and bhuber with excellent play. HUstylez should probably be given Kool Kids access where mexineil's was revoked.

Don't know where CPHoya went yesterday or why. I can't believe you got suckered in by that ReddBoiler "lynch me" gambit. It's quite obviously a level, no villager *WASTES A LYNCH* in order to get killed. There's a Lunatic who can do that sort of thing. A lunatic doesn't follow the democratic process. Putting yourself up for a lynch by asking to be lynched has the opposite effect, as you saw yesterday. Ergo, because it causes the opposite effect, it improves the odds you do not get lynched, as opposed to reducing the odds you get lynched. That's why it's not on the level. People don't do that sort of thing to get lynched, they do it to NOT get lynched.

Don't see any case on bhuber at all. We should have stuck together.

The Alpha Wolf managed to get a conversion off by now. As such, I'd recommend seer scanning the folks who were least likely to be lynched at any point anytime soon. Since I clearly am not comprehending what you folks find lynch-worthy, I haven't the foggiest idea who is the most cleared yesterday who should not be cleared now. I'm open to suggestions.
PTP Vanilla+ Game Thread Quote
09-28-2013 , 04:02 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Luckbox Inc
jesus you're going to lynch pizza??

thats beyond bad

this game is going to be a disaster if people play like this
I can't decide if you're white knighting me again or if you're legitimately villaging.

I won't know until I see ReddBoiler. I felt a w/w interaction between you too and of the two of you, Redd is clearly more w than v, if either one of you are v.

Quote:
Charry (23), Felix the Cat (75), ShipItUp (97), bhuber2010 (40), well named (100), chrisrjdk (66)
Folks on DividedSky

CHarry and ShipItUp most directly responsible for the death, considering SIU's mayorship and CHarry's vote movement.

As such, I give CHarry a pass for this round. SIU obviously not going to touch that one.

Bhuber seems fine.

I need to read where and why well named and chris ended up on that wagon. A wolf is going to be on that wagon for credit.

Well named still looks like the gypsy, wriggling around for village credit here, not gonna happen.

It might have just been well named.

I pressed hard on Chris yesterday and I'm still here. I'm not clearing Chris but I will, as with ReddBoiler, move on, and cross my fingers I was wrong.
PTP Vanilla+ Game Thread Quote
09-28-2013 , 04:16 AM
Went through felix real quick here

Quote:
Originally Posted by Felix the Cat
lock in that Xkf villa read

this reaction is very natural
This almost looks like what should be peekish except for the "read" part - But it would also be a really lazy seerhunt going on because he questions xkf several times like

Quote:
Originally Posted by Felix the Cat
Xkf
32 first non-game-related post of the thread is an aidsy vote on chrisrjdk, this is xkf's second post
looking back at previous games of his to see if this is normal:
7 Sep No Sub #25 first post, appears to be a reasonably serious vote on remedys, Xkf is villa
Star Trek vanilla #60-65 opening posts are much more jokey, there is a game related post at #64 but it is much less direct
So this post is closer to Xkf's last villa game than his last wolf game (both fairly recent), stylistically he had a much lighter approach to very early d1 in his wolf game, this game he had a more direct approach to reading people which is also more in line with the linked villa game.
#113 thinks pizza is villagery on a player specific read "I think more obnoxiousness = more villagery in his case". further converses with wn on pizza, shows desire to get it right by referencing past games.
#118 thin villa read on dustbox
#134 HUstylez vote "for a couple reasons" not elaborated
etc. stopping here, no need to go further right now

I could probably reread more, but since Xkf this game is stylistically much more in line with his linked villager game than in his linked wolf game and he is not a lynch candidate at this point I'm comfortable giving him a villa lean and moving on to more productive rereads.
Ends up giving the village read there too, but have a tough time believing wolf's would take xkf as a peek.

Then there's this peculiar one off

Quote:
Originally Posted by Felix the Cat
HOWLS IT GOING THERE STRANGER
(directed at thediceman)

I think they wound up killing him for going pretty relentlessly against divi and figured that there was a fine chance he had peeked him wolf, and if not, they killed a really good villager without leaving a shc.

Of course, one might argue this could be the peek
Quote:
Originally Posted by Felix the Cat
this is a bad vote, chris looks like a villager to me
May have missed something, quick skim, won't be here the next 15ish hours
PTP Vanilla+ Game Thread Quote
09-28-2013 , 04:19 AM
Revised list

Kool Kids Club
  • Askthepizzaguy
  • ShipItUp <-----My faith in you was not misplaced.
  • CPHoya <----Needs to stand his ground more. Excellent villager.
  • tmleafs1967 <----Made me proud yesterday
  • bhuber2010 <----Still seems fine.
  • Charry <----Gets a bump from the DividedSky lynch.
  • HUstylez <----Not sure why you're chasing CPHoya but otherwise fine.
Villagin' Village Club

  • comeasur337 <----Villagery still.
  • tappokone <----Need to read more of him but nothing jumps out as wrong.
"Gentleman's wolf" or "Gentleman's villa" club.
  • Luckbox Inc <----Questionable reversal on Redd, but if he's a wolf, he's a gentleman wolf. I won't lynch this one unless I get resolution on Redd first. If he's a villager he's obviously worth keeping around, so I defer judgment.
"Roomba" Row
  • chrisrjdk <---Not letting go, but not pushing you today either. See below.
  • ReddBoiler <----Leaving this one up to our esteemed mayor and the vigilant ones, since a lynch seems impossible.

***Meaning: I still think you are wolf, but I pressed you hard yesterday. I need to examine other candidates and also be open to the idea I was wrong. Roomba tried to lynch you and failed, Roomba hits the wall, turns, continues Roomba'ing.***
  • thediceman <---- If I am a suspect on your list, and I'm willing to lynch basically every other suspect on your list, you have me assist you in lynching those shared suspects first. Why I needed to be lynched first is beyond me. That's not the proper progression
  • Xkf- Didn't do jack yesterday to help out. Can't see how he's villaging.
  • well named <---Gypsy. No need to lynch, just need to ignore.
  • mexineil <----Already explained this vote.
PTP Vanilla+ Game Thread Quote
09-28-2013 , 04:23 AM
There's no way I hit 100 posts today. Week vacation is over, work begins at 4pm daily from now on. Will never be here for End Of Day until I have a day off.

I also sleep before work, and this thread moves extremely fast while I am asleep.

As with the Musketeer game, my most effective hours will be just after opening of day, until I fall asleep mid-morning.

As such, for my vote to be useful, it needs to be on a candidate that could possibly be lynched. Otherwise like Musketeers I will not have any effect most rounds.

ShipItUp, consider me your third vote. Put me on the correct suspects or at least on a suspect you want to pressure.
PTP Vanilla+ Game Thread Quote

      
m