Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Pogcathlon Codenames 2-Team Long-List Game Thread Pogcathlon Codenames 2-Team Long-List Game Thread

02-03-2019 , 09:49 PM
Nothing else on the board relates to caduceus...period.

Ascelpius has at least loose connections to Jupiter and centaur, and isn't as well known as caduceus, so also much riskier.
Pogcathlon Codenames 2-Team Long-List Game Thread Quote
02-03-2019 , 10:05 PM
Caduceus isn’t actually a medical thing tho; Hermes has nothing to do with medicine

If he wants to go greek to let us know Greece wasn’t architecture then he googles Greek god of medicine and gets Asclepius and finds out he has the staff that doctors use and then he clues it
Pogcathlon Codenames 2-Team Long-List Game Thread Quote
02-03-2019 , 10:14 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nicholasp27
At this point cold was snow and disease
I think pole may be right, but I don't agree on why. If the missing word here is pole, I think it is because it is the second snow word.. I don't think cold 2 was ever disease and snow. A cold is mostly thought of as a virus as opposed to a disease (I am not even sure if it is a "disease," per se).

Let's remember it was a 2 clue early in the game. Why give us cold 2 to get snow and disease when there are better "direct" picks than disease on the board.... like penguin and pole and Jupiter.

So I like pole I think ( and not by much), but for different reasons than others, I guess..
Pogcathlon Codenames 2-Team Long-List Game Thread Quote
02-03-2019 , 10:14 PM
Huh? Isn't the caduceus literally the symbol of medicine?

Last edited by D1iabol1cal; 02-03-2019 at 10:15 PM. Reason: @nich
Pogcathlon Codenames 2-Team Long-List Game Thread Quote
02-03-2019 , 10:17 PM
My vote is pole model pass

He forced an esoteric Greek dude here for a reason...either he didn’t realize Greece was off the board or he wants to let us know Greece wasn’t architectural

My vote is to trust the spymaster and go with the latter option...and he woulda seen model for architectural so it’s at worst neutral


He coulda done mythology or god or Zeus to get jupiter and Greece if those were both on the board instead of forcing this dude and tougher choice
Pogcathlon Codenames 2-Team Long-List Game Thread Quote
02-03-2019 , 10:18 PM
There is ZERO chance he has cold 2 as first clue and misses that disease fits there...ZERO

And ZERO he misses snow for cold

There is a 40% or whatever chance he misses pole for cold tho
Pogcathlon Codenames 2-Team Long-List Game Thread Quote
02-03-2019 , 10:22 PM
I don't know how he would expect us to say disease before penguin for cold. Or pole for that matter. This whole game is confusing me actually.

Just lock in pole then since everyone likes it. Not really keen on saying model tho.
Pogcathlon Codenames 2-Team Long-List Game Thread Quote
02-03-2019 , 10:25 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by D1iabol1cal
Huh? Isn't the caduceus literally the symbol of medicine?

I think i can visualize the winged staff at pharmacies so you may be right that it’s used, but so is the snake

And the winged staff is Hermes who has no connection to medicine so that may be wrong.

Again, if we need to debate which of the two clues is better, then I argue that if he researched Greek medical god he gets the god and just goes with that
Pogcathlon Codenames 2-Team Long-List Game Thread Quote
02-03-2019 , 10:27 PM
Doesn't it have wings and a snake?
Pogcathlon Codenames 2-Team Long-List Game Thread Quote
02-03-2019 , 10:27 PM
Doesn’t matter what he’d expect us to say

Again, as spymaster you come up with a clue linking 2+ words and then you go over your list to see if any others fit...you never miss disease there for cold

Then you look at assassins and blue and then neutral to see what else fits...you shouldn’t miss penguin there but he did

Galápagos penguins aren’t in cold water but people associate them with the cold so he shoulda seen that coming but long list you can hit an assassin so maybe he just yoloed it thinking disease and snow are more direct, we’ll find out in the postmortem
Pogcathlon Codenames 2-Team Long-List Game Thread Quote
02-03-2019 , 10:29 PM
Hermes wings, thus not medicine

And again, you are assuming he knows that that is to start with...I’m assuming he researched it and got the god and that is more likely since that’s the clue he went with

He also maybe didn’t want hermes due to ship as another reason
Pogcathlon Codenames 2-Team Long-List Game Thread Quote
02-03-2019 , 10:31 PM
I understand reluctance to say model but then WHY did he go with a Greek god right after we got Greece? Why not an easier clue? The only thing I can see is he wants to communicate that Greece wasn’t for architectural...maybe you have another explanation I’m not seeing?

I think he did it for a reason
Pogcathlon Codenames 2-Team Long-List Game Thread Quote
02-03-2019 , 10:33 PM
I agree we should bold pole and my "opinion" is that we don't have a reason to vote model. I like pole pass and relax
Pogcathlon Codenames 2-Team Long-List Game Thread Quote
02-03-2019 , 10:33 PM
Very much doubt Eric googled that. He knows a lot about mythology...maybe too much for this game.
Pogcathlon Codenames 2-Team Long-List Game Thread Quote
02-03-2019 , 10:35 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nicholasp27
I understand reluctance to say model but then WHY did he go with a Greek god right after we got Greece? Why not an easier clue? The only thing I can see is he wants to communicate that Greece wasn’t for architectural...maybe you have another explanation I’m not seeing?

I think he did it for a reason
I have no idea why, that's why I'm so confused. The possible explanation I gave before was that both disease and Jupiter were ours and he didn't want us to go off of one if the other was correct.
Pogcathlon Codenames 2-Team Long-List Game Thread Quote
02-03-2019 , 10:45 PM
If we are going by consensus, I vote pole and pass

U folks can factor my vote in with the rest..
Pogcathlon Codenames 2-Team Long-List Game Thread Quote
02-03-2019 , 10:52 PM
pole
Pogcathlon Codenames 2-Team Long-List Game Thread Quote
02-03-2019 , 10:55 PM
Pole is neutral.
Pogcathlon Codenames 2-Team Long-List Game Thread Quote
02-03-2019 , 10:56 PM
Welp
Pogcathlon Codenames 2-Team Long-List Game Thread Quote
02-03-2019 , 10:58 PM
Prison - 4
stomach - 5
cold - 2
easter - 3
Architecture - 2
screwdriver - 2
pantry - 2
epidemic - 0
Asclepius - 2


Beat
Centaur
Chair
Cotton
Cycle
Fan
Force
Jupiter
Kiwi
Knife
Mammoth
Mine
Missile
Model
Pass
Pumpkin
Pupil
Ship
Slip
Spot
Strike
Sub
Tablet
Telescope

Block
Compound
State
Bed
Snow
Skyscraper
Greece
Stock
Ketchup
Disease


Organ
Bug
London*
Spring
Chocolate
Spine
Thumb
Bolt
Grace
Drop
File


Tube
Himalayas
Death
Pole

Penguin*
Pogcathlon Codenames 2-Team Long-List Game Thread Quote
02-03-2019 , 11:00 PM
I really did feel like that was wrong too...damn.
Pogcathlon Codenames 2-Team Long-List Game Thread Quote
02-03-2019 , 11:02 PM
Ok so he didn’t think of Jupiter as cold...definitely possible (unlike disease)

And then we talked about both and he doesn’t want us to drop off of Jupiter once we get disease or vice versa

That’s definitely a good theory but then why not go greek god immediately for 3 to get Greece and disease and Jupiter if he was worried about us going off one if we got the other?

But I definitely think it could be correct

Cold was definitely snow and disease but then we started talking about Jupiter also but I’m not sure he cares that much about us not liking Jupiter since it’s a weak connection to cold anyway and he can clue it later...not like we will think it’s 100% out



I dunno I guess we can go Jupiter instead of pole; once we know those 2 words we will hopefully know more about how this played out
Pogcathlon Codenames 2-Team Long-List Game Thread Quote
02-03-2019 , 11:05 PM
Ok so cross post

Now I like your Jupiter theory even better of course

Neutral doesn’t hurt us tho and now we know more

So jupiter is our next makeup word

I still wonder why he didn’t go greek god as second clue then to get Greece and Jupiter and disease

Oh well, we’ll see the next clues and go from there; we can hold off model for a bit...I also think he prolly goes architecture - 3 if it’s model so maybe model isn’t a word

I’m good with Jupiter for extra next and dropping the model thing for awhile
Pogcathlon Codenames 2-Team Long-List Game Thread Quote
02-04-2019 , 12:07 AM
paleontologist - 2
Pogcathlon Codenames 2-Team Long-List Game Thread Quote
02-04-2019 , 01:01 AM
Mammoth is a given. Not sure on the other. Could be that Knife was a word we were supposed to guess before and we lucked into a different word on the list so he clued Knife again?

Nothing else is catching my eye.
Pogcathlon Codenames 2-Team Long-List Game Thread Quote

      
m