Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
POG Werewolf 2015 Rankings Cup (Qualifying Round) GAME THREAD POG Werewolf 2015 Rankings Cup (Qualifying Round) GAME THREAD

09-25-2015 , 04:49 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by IAmRobik
ARE YOU STILL SAYING THIS? IS THIS REAL LIFE? DID YOU READ THE GAME AFTER YOU ****ING DIED?
Yeah I did read it. He said a lot of other things too that contradicted it, typical BATM "noise" and so on, but he did call it.

I maintain that BATM is good.
POG Werewolf 2015 Rankings Cup (Qualifying Round) GAME THREAD Quote
09-25-2015 , 04:49 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by IAmRobik
You called out jcohen and specifically noted his poor record from 2014-2015. I went on to explain that record isn't everything and that points a, b, c and d are some things that I consider important that aren't going to really be used at all. Saying jcohen doesn't belong there because of his record is short sighted and silly and that's all i pointed out.
He has played 13 long games in his career and has never been a stand out in games I've seen, his record is only a small part of that. He's solid, that's all, and I was disagreeing with baudib saying cohen would be top-5 if he played more. He's a poor long game wolf and quite frankly I don't think he's got the stones to be an elite 2-way player.
POG Werewolf 2015 Rankings Cup (Qualifying Round) GAME THREAD Quote
09-25-2015 , 04:49 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by IAmRobik
ARE YOU STILL SAYING THIS? IS THIS REAL LIFE? DID YOU READ THE GAME AFTER YOU ****ING DIED?
much better
POG Werewolf 2015 Rankings Cup (Qualifying Round) GAME THREAD Quote
09-25-2015 , 04:50 PM
I just sort of assumed "you have to take someone but you don't know what kind of game the next game is going to be"

I don't even know if that's the actual rule or not but I'm pretending it is

in that scenario, as a for instance, jcohen is awesome if it's a turbo, pretty damn good (IMO) if it's a vanilla, and pretty average if it's a mash (but you could still do worse, he at least won't randomly go full ******)


I don't agree with Robik about a lot of what he's saying but I do about lolsample size on W-L records
POG Werewolf 2015 Rankings Cup (Qualifying Round) GAME THREAD Quote
09-25-2015 , 04:50 PM
I think you are making a huge mistake with Rawrs/booker and Duck over stork, UD

but this doesn't matter really
POG Werewolf 2015 Rankings Cup (Qualifying Round) GAME THREAD Quote
09-25-2015 , 04:50 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kioshk
One might describe him as inscrutable.
See, I don't know if inscrutability is necessarily a great quality. It's good for a wolf game, but not for fellow villas.

q_q is inscrutible a lot of the time. I don't think that's a great thing.
POG Werewolf 2015 Rankings Cup (Qualifying Round) GAME THREAD Quote
09-25-2015 , 04:51 PM
and I'm also assuming this game is starting October 1st, so WN is like a 92 year old Peter North: a stud in his prime, no chance he can get it up any more
POG Werewolf 2015 Rankings Cup (Qualifying Round) GAME THREAD Quote
09-25-2015 , 04:52 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by LordJvK
Yeah I did read it. He said a lot of other things too that contradicted it, typical BATM "noise" and so on, but he did call it.

I maintain that BATM is good.
I think you need to reread that part of the game then. He might have noticed the vv thing, but he didn't even believe it to be true as he was certain that AOS was the peek.

I was 100% certain that it was viggo and went through great lengths to hide that opinion for a day. I wanted the wolves to kill Sun as the peeked villager before outing the information so that I would have a clear villager for as long as possible. I lay out very very clearly why viggo was the peek and why sun/aos never as people kept telling me i was wrong (even though post-game).

POG Werewolf 2015 Rankings Cup (Qualifying Round) GAME THREAD Quote
09-25-2015 , 04:53 PM
duckburg is arguably the worst player on that list
POG Werewolf 2015 Rankings Cup (Qualifying Round) GAME THREAD Quote
09-25-2015 , 04:54 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Moocher
He has played 13 long games in his career and has never been a stand out in games I've seen, his record is only a small part of that. He's solid, that's all, and I was disagreeing with baudib saying cohen would be top-5 if he played more. He's a poor long game wolf and quite frankly I don't think he's got the stones to be an elite 2-way player.
This is much better. I wouldn't have argued with this. But laying out his record and stating that he's not good because of that was dumb imo. Having said that, I think he's a good villager from what I've read of his games and would probably have him in my top 5 2p2 villagers.
POG Werewolf 2015 Rankings Cup (Qualifying Round) GAME THREAD Quote
09-25-2015 , 04:55 PM
You did actually call it too Robik, now that I recall. My inability to play seer will likely hurt me in these rankings.
POG Werewolf 2015 Rankings Cup (Qualifying Round) GAME THREAD Quote
09-25-2015 , 04:57 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by IAmRobik
This is much better. I wouldn't have argued with this. But laying out his record and stating that he's not good because of that was dumb imo. Having said that, I think he's a good villager from what I've read of his games and would probably have him in my top 5 2p2 villagers.
Laying out his w/l record was slightly tongue-in-cheek as ever since the WW Database has been around I was one of the first to point out what a useless statistic it is, I have quite enjoyed you bringing it up in every post tho.
POG Werewolf 2015 Rankings Cup (Qualifying Round) GAME THREAD Quote
09-25-2015 , 04:58 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by DWetzel
lol CT basically

just write him in in matchup #8 and all is well
It looks to me like he only has 9 games since 2014, and 3 in 2015. HP6 wasn't counted since he subbed out. He did mod 5 games since 2014, but that wasn't part of the criteria. Database queries are not good at making subjective judgments.
POG Werewolf 2015 Rankings Cup (Qualifying Round) GAME THREAD Quote
09-25-2015 , 05:00 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Abraham deLacey
I think you are making a huge mistake with Rawrs/booker and Duck over stork, UD

but this doesn't matter really
I probably borked Booker/Rawrs, yeah. As for Duck/Stork.. I do understand why you think Duck is bad, but he can be a very good wolf when he wants to be. Stork.. has yet to do anything to stand out in any way. Might be my fault for not remembering enough of her good games.

I agree that it will not matter because none of them are going all the way.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Xkf
duckburg is arguably the worst player on that list
I think that's cjkalt.
POG Werewolf 2015 Rankings Cup (Qualifying Round) GAME THREAD Quote
09-25-2015 , 05:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by LordJvK
You did actually call it too Robik, now that I recall. My inability to play seer will likely hurt me in these rankings.
Pretty sure I have seen you randed other roles than seer.
POG Werewolf 2015 Rankings Cup (Qualifying Round) GAME THREAD Quote
09-25-2015 , 05:06 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by iversonian
It looks to me like he only has 9 games since 2014, and 3 in 2015. HP6 wasn't counted since he subbed out. He did mod 5 games since 2014, but that wasn't part of the criteria. Database queries are not good at making subjective judgments.

Ah, the sub out game doesn't count... Mystery sort of solved.

I would have counted that anyway obv.
POG Werewolf 2015 Rankings Cup (Qualifying Round) GAME THREAD Quote
09-25-2015 , 05:07 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by IAmRobik
So is batman, but they're going to end up in the finals (and if one of them isn't then hoya will be), which proves my point that this whole Rankings Cup is a sham and a popularity contest.
you want odds on this?
POG Werewolf 2015 Rankings Cup (Qualifying Round) GAME THREAD Quote
09-25-2015 , 05:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by LordJvK
You did actually call it too Robik, now that I recall. My inability to play seer will likely hurt me in these rankings.
not really
POG Werewolf 2015 Rankings Cup (Qualifying Round) GAME THREAD Quote
09-25-2015 , 05:09 PM
The f kind of criteria do you guys use for this? Seems to me like even it this thread it's "volume" based mostly, higher volume = better player.
POG Werewolf 2015 Rankings Cup (Qualifying Round) GAME THREAD Quote
09-25-2015 , 05:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Willi
Pretty sure I have seen you randed other roles than seer.
that subtle burn
POG Werewolf 2015 Rankings Cup (Qualifying Round) GAME THREAD Quote
09-25-2015 , 05:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by insanity31
you want odds on this?
You can't call this out loud. If you had pm'd me, I would have taken this, given that they were in separate brackets
POG Werewolf 2015 Rankings Cup (Qualifying Round) GAME THREAD Quote
09-25-2015 , 05:14 PM
POG Werewolf 2015 Rankings Cup (Qualifying Round) GAME THREAD Quote
09-25-2015 , 05:15 PM
Lol BATM is awful, redd is slightly above awful. If either of them make it far it would just be to troll the competition
POG Werewolf 2015 Rankings Cup (Qualifying Round) GAME THREAD Quote
09-25-2015 , 05:18 PM
insanity, you can be my wingman
POG Werewolf 2015 Rankings Cup (Qualifying Round) GAME THREAD Quote
09-25-2015 , 05:22 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kioshk
One might describe him as inscrutable.
icwudt
POG Werewolf 2015 Rankings Cup (Qualifying Round) GAME THREAD Quote

      
m