Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
POG Republic Game Thread POG Republic Game Thread

10-27-2010 , 01:06 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by McAvoy
Where did I say to reward the behaviour? I'm just ignoring him this game. I also am making it very clear the lines, so that when people kill certain people, they look bad.
you're rewarding this behaviour by granting him a villager lean

i'm not conceding that he's a villager

but let's assume for a second

everyone reads this, they go 'i can clear myself by being antivillage'

what happens next
POG Republic Game Thread Quote
10-27-2010 , 01:07 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Titanrulez
so you're basically saying people read you villager and therefore you're a villager

what about me

i read you wolf

therefore you're a wolf
I am responding to you saying that "Larry was right all along". If all along includes he being convinced I am a villager at the time of the death then yes, your posts make sense.
POG Republic Game Thread Quote
10-27-2010 , 01:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Titanrulez
everyone reads this, they go 'i can clear myself by being antivillage'

what happens next
Very simple, don't play ww in a vacuum.

50% of my plays are probably anti village on level 1. But they are done for a reason, to see who else I can get to follow anti village play.

wolves don't want to start bad plays but they will support them. it also makes it easier to weed out the obvious bad villagers, who spew themselves villa for retartedness
POG Republic Game Thread Quote
10-27-2010 , 01:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by T!ghterThanU
so who are we nominating to lynch lxt
come on guys i got things to do
POG Republic Game Thread Quote
10-27-2010 , 01:09 PM
I've never said larry was right all along

read it again

i said he had it right about you avoiding interaction
POG Republic Game Thread Quote
10-27-2010 , 01:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Titanrulez
I'm going to sleep now

when I wake up i expect to at least see some justification

i've done my part
Quote:
Originally Posted by T!ghterThanU
even now he says hes leaving and doesn't. this allows him to cherry pick what he responds to doesn't it?
QFT.
POG Republic Game Thread Quote
10-27-2010 , 01:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Oreos
heh.

I followed this game pretty closely. I'd like to add a +1 to what birdman has posted since ml+1 (4 days ago). Minus the gratuitous insults.

He did as he said -- birdman guided the village through a tough spot to a good one. No wolf ever does that.

Anyways, I'd like to take a shot at some logic that was annoying to me. I've seen it in plenty of games, but especially in this one:

1. Titan does something that helps the wolf team
2. Titan says he would never do that as a wolf, because it would be too bold.
3. Titan claims he should be cleared for what he did.

The trouble is in step 2. Why would a wolf never do something that helps the wolf team a lot? The implied reason is helping the wolf team a lot gets you lynched. But if helping the wolf team a lot doesn't actually get you lynched, there's no reason for a wolf not to do it.

You can never clear a player for helping the wolf team. Doing so puts the incentives in the wrong direction. Which is not to say you can't clear them when they do something anti-village, but it has to be for a reason other than "a wolf would never do something that helps the wolf team".

Another common example of this is when a late game NK implicates player X, then people say "X would not make that kill, so I'm clearing him". Don't clear people for doing something that helps the wolf team.

From the sidelines, ibavly was obviously the wolf at F3. I don't know if I could have voted for him if I was in the game though. I know McAvoy and Dustin are able to set aside how painful it is to let somebody blatantly wolf (like Titan did) and win. Not many others would though. Kudos to birdman for being open minded.

Tough to win a 13er with 4 wolves.
bump for titan learns his lessons
POG Republic Game Thread Quote
10-27-2010 , 01:11 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bobman0330
QFT.
gfy you are useless
POG Republic Game Thread Quote
10-27-2010 , 01:11 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bobman0330
QFT.
was about to say that

does it matter

it's not like what tighter is saying makes sense
POG Republic Game Thread Quote
10-27-2010 , 01:12 PM
Nvm mac got a special mention in that which explains it
POG Republic Game Thread Quote
10-27-2010 , 01:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by T!ghterThanU
gfy you are useless
lol

he's killed the only woof
POG Republic Game Thread Quote
10-27-2010 , 01:13 PM
So

any response from bobman and Wellnamed?
POG Republic Game Thread Quote
10-27-2010 , 01:14 PM
we need tosomeone who will kill a wolf and not someone who will lynch a villager who hurt his feelings
POG Republic Game Thread Quote
10-27-2010 , 01:15 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by McAvoy
lol

he's killed the only woof
that was vaya imo
POG Republic Game Thread Quote
10-27-2010 , 01:15 PM
I'm starting to come off obnoxious so i'm going to sleep

but you guys need to start justifying your reads on lxt

or start questioning it

because if you can't justify it then it's obviously built on air

this applies to everyone except mac because I know what he's talking about, been there done that, probably will never come to a consensus about antivillage plays so nevermind that
POG Republic Game Thread Quote
10-27-2010 , 01:16 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Titanrulez
I've never said larry was right all along

read it again

i said he had it right about you avoiding interaction
Saying the obvious when I put a player on ignore.
POG Republic Game Thread Quote
10-27-2010 , 01:17 PM
I'd rather die in real life than keep going with this ********.
POG Republic Game Thread Quote
10-27-2010 , 01:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by LXThrottle
I'd rather die in real life than keep going with this ********.
options are bountiful!
POG Republic Game Thread Quote
10-27-2010 , 01:19 PM
nominate well named
POG Republic Game Thread Quote
10-27-2010 , 01:20 PM
if lxt hangs himself does it bount as a lynch?
POG Republic Game Thread Quote
10-27-2010 , 01:21 PM
nominate wn better than cdl imo
POG Republic Game Thread Quote
10-27-2010 , 01:23 PM
its fustrating that lxt is on so many lists and has been saying to lynch him 2 days straight but lives.
POG Republic Game Thread Quote
10-27-2010 , 01:26 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Titanrulez
I'm starting to come off obnoxious so i'm going to sleep

but you guys need to start justifying your reads on lxt

or start questioning it

because if you can't justify it then it's obviously built on air

this applies to everyone except mac because I know what he's talking about, been there done that, probably will never come to a consensus about antivillage plays so nevermind that
aka you guys need to unclear your cleared villagers.
POG Republic Game Thread Quote
10-27-2010 , 01:30 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by LXThrottle
My tone reads are based on logic also. Something I don't expect you to understand.

What you do on d1?

...

Seriously.

Good Bye. Will only come back to decide who I vote for.unless of course people actually dont fall for my misdirection and try to lynch me
fyp
POG Republic Game Thread Quote
10-27-2010 , 01:35 PM
elect flytrap
nominate flytrap
POG Republic Game Thread Quote

      
m