Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
POG Politics Thread POG Politics Thread

01-25-2019 , 12:14 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by filthyvermin
it will come as news to no one that i am not an expert on venezuelan governments. so im just kinda guessing that chavez and meduro aren't the villains usa makes them out to be. but i do know that usa has a history of villainizing people like chavez. and usa has a history of reigning(raining?) misery all around the planet.
https://youtu.be/Id--ZFtjR5c

Watch this on Chavez. It's super powerful and I've seen it make people cry. The poor people in the movie that you see cheering for Chavez are now cheering for the opposition.
01-25-2019 , 12:27 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Luckbox Inc
This is what we've spent the last two days discussing here (when not on AOC).

I have no problem distributing the blame between both the West and the regime and you and Birdman ought to do the same because that is the only rational thought to this
enlightenedcentrism.jpg
01-25-2019 , 12:28 PM
It’s important to know the VZ is not really socialism. It is a social democracy that happens to be in opposition to imperialism
01-25-2019 , 12:58 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Luckbox Inc
But I don't think you can fully blame the west for the hyperinflation there. That has to be the fault of the Venezuelan government's economic policies and specifically creating money.

And it is the hyperinflation that has caused the collapse of the economy and the suffering. People literally can hardly use cash. And how many poor people in Venezuelan don't have cards? Probably tons.
First off, you can blame the hyperinflation on the West. The US has been engaged in currency manipulation in VZ for a while.

As far as “normal” inflation it isn’t actually the evil you are making it out to be. It’s actually not a bad policy in certain situations. The thing is, inflation is always going to hurt the rich a lot which is why you hear so much screaming and yelling about it from the opposition (which is made up predominantly of the wealthy in VZ) and in the US media.
01-25-2019 , 01:10 PM
Also this whole paradigm of "who is to blame" is bad. It inserts us and by proxy the US/west as neutral arbiters of global justice whose job it is to determine who is right or to blame for stuff and fix it.

The only thing we should be worried about is what our country(ies) are doing that they should not be. The US has been meddling in VZ affairs for a long time. Manipulation currency, blocking trade, pushing for a coup, etc. And that should stop. It does not matter if the Maduro is partially to blame or whatever. That is not our problem. That is for the people of VZ to solve.
01-25-2019 , 01:15 PM
Agreed that the US should not meddle, obviously. Disagree that discussing who is to blame is some problem.

Last edited by Luckbox Inc; 01-25-2019 at 01:21 PM.
01-25-2019 , 01:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Birdman10687
First off, you can blame the hyperinflation on the West. The US has been engaged in currency manipulation in VZ for a while.
While I don't doubt they have I would like to know what exactly it was and how it lead to the hyperinflation. Because if hyperinflation were such an easy thing to inflict on the West's enemies, I would think you would see it more often.
01-25-2019 , 01:45 PM
https://www.forbes.com/sites/garthfr.../#57391f0515e4

Here is a Forbes article on the hyperinflation there and of course the only thing Forbes loves more than the green new deal is trashing Venezuela so take it for what it is worth, but it seems fairly objective:
Quote:
Hugo Chavez came into power in 1998. The near decade-long rise in oil prices that followed improved government finances and allowed the socialist regime to increase both spending and borrowing. Their agenda was interrupted by a 2003 labor strike at PDVSA, the state-owned oil company. The strike severely impacted oil production and crippled the economy, with GDP falling 27% during the first four months of 2003. After the strike, Chavez instituted a series of measures to stop the slide in the Bolivar, the Venezuelan currency, and seek revenge on those responsible. The introduction of a currency peg, installation of import controls, the nationalization of other industries, and the establishment of subsidies for food and consumer goods all followed the strike. These actions sowed the seeds for the future inflation crisis.
01-25-2019 , 01:47 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Luckbox Inc
While I don't doubt they have I would like to know what exactly it was and how it lead to the hyperinflation. Because if hyperinflation were such an easy thing to inflict on the West's enemies, I would think you would see it more often.
Remember that guy who "worked at Home Depot" down in Alabama or something that was running a currency exchange website? He was like a former VZ national who was in the military and participated in at least one or two coup attempts against Chavez? That was obviously a CIA op.
01-25-2019 , 01:48 PM
Inflation hurts the poor more than the wealthy, just like linear taxation.


I don't think Western millionaires have been buying Venezuelan pesos, so I don't believe our Elite is concerned about Venezuelan inflation except insofar as it strengthens our buying power there (but afaiu we aren't buying* much anyway).


The concentration of the Venezuelan economy in a single resource is a failing arisen from their command-style economic policies, with Chavez buying into the imperialistic "this is what makes us valuable" narrative.
01-25-2019 , 01:49 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Birdman10687
Remember that guy who "worked at Home Depot" down in Alabama or something that was running a currency exchange website? He was like a former VZ national who was in the military and participated in at least one or two coup attempts against Chavez? That was obviously a CIA op.
First I've heard of this but obviously whatever he did wasn't the cause.
01-25-2019 , 01:50 PM
*it's unclear whether the threads' malcontents would prefer trade, ie imperialism, or isolation, ie strangulation.
01-25-2019 , 01:50 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by iamnotawerewolf
Inflation hurts the poor more than the wealthy, just like linear taxation.
Was wanting to save this for another day but glad someone is taking this up.
01-25-2019 , 01:53 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by iamnotawerewolf
*it's unclear whether the threads' malcontents would prefer trade, ie imperialism, or isolation, ie strangulation.
Make Venezuela Great Again.
01-25-2019 , 01:54 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by iamnotawerewolf
*it's unclear whether the threads' malcontents would prefer trade, ie imperialism, or isolation, ie strangulation.
*it is unclear why IANAW believes trade is synonymous with imperialism
01-25-2019 , 01:55 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by iamnotawerewolf
I don't think Western millionaires have been buying Venezuelan pesos, so I don't believe our Elite is concerned about Venezuelan inflation except insofar as it strengthens our buying power there (but afaiu we aren't buying* much anyway).
There are rich capitalists in VZ believe it or not, IANAW
01-25-2019 , 01:55 PM
Or why countries can't be self-sufficient.
01-25-2019 , 02:06 PM
Most investments are relatively inflation-proof. The people who get hurt by inflation are the ones who don't have enough money to invest in anything.
01-25-2019 , 02:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by soah
Most investments are relatively inflation-proof. The people who get hurt by inflation are the ones who don't have enough money to invest in anything.
I feel like you do not understand what inflation is or something
01-25-2019 , 02:12 PM
So, next steps seem predictable

Trump declares national emergency to fund wall

Trump re opens gov

Trumps says see you at the State of the Union Nancy
01-25-2019 , 02:18 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Birdman10687
I feel like you do not understand what inflation is or something
I feel like you don't understand that wealthy people don't store their wealth in hard currency beneath the mattress.
01-25-2019 , 02:19 PM
But yeah, what do I really know about inflation anyway? Not like I live in a country where money loses half its value every couple years or something.
01-25-2019 , 02:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by soah
Most investments are relatively inflation-proof..

Time to pile into Zimbabwe bond notes
01-25-2019 , 02:21 PM
I wonder how it is that I can have a lot of savings and not be freaking out over all the inflation here. Oh wait, it's I rubbed two braincells together and realized I should only convert my wealth to pesos right as I spend it.
01-25-2019 , 02:33 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by soah
I feel like you don't understand that wealthy people don't store their wealth in hard currency beneath the mattress.
lol and what you don't understand is that poor people don't have wealth to store at all.

Inflation decrease the value of money you don't spend (i.e. save). The poorer you are the lower your savings rate and thus the less you are affected by inflation.

There are ways that inflation hurts poor people depending on how the inflation occurs. But generally speaking wages are sticky and so if inflation happens very quickly (i.e. the hyperinflation that Dustin was talking about) poor people can be in a bind.

You talk about investments being "inflation proof" which is more or less a paradox. The only thing that is immune to inflation is not having money saved.

In any case, I'm not sure what your ultimate solution is--orchestrate a coup against a democratically elected President because you from your vantage point in Argentina think his policies are bad? Surely that is not what you are suggesting.

      
m