Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
POG Anniversary IV:Attack of the Subs Game Thread POG Anniversary IV:Attack of the Subs Game Thread

04-14-2010 , 01:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kokiri
This post by birdman I think is astoundingly villagey. Amazingly so. Pretty much insta-clearingly so

That relativity post was hilarious, however. Do graduate students often say things like that? Like, ever?
I was referring to someone who would have been a grad student at the time the theory came out--when it still was not understood completely. Obviously no grad student today would say that.
POG Anniversary IV:Attack of the Subs Game Thread Quote
04-14-2010 , 01:39 PM
Dear TL

if your like for birdman prevents you from shooting him tonight, please shoot chips ahoy


metsy
POG Anniversary IV:Attack of the Subs Game Thread Quote
04-14-2010 , 01:39 PM
Chips being a wolf fits with my "WhiteGoose avoided choosing the UTR players that he was a wolf with to attack" theory

POG Anniversary IV:Attack of the Subs Game Thread Quote
04-14-2010 , 01:40 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TimeLady
I've had you as a villager since early d1, you've been my in-thread mason for a while now
Cool beans

Quote:
Originally Posted by Chips Ahoy
I'm a little tilted at the moment. I don't think I should be. I'm not a good villager when I'm tilted.
See, i feel like all the short sentences and one-liners aren't very becoming of your villager game
POG Anniversary IV:Attack of the Subs Game Thread Quote
04-14-2010 , 01:40 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by metsandfinsfan
Chips lets get this straight

1 - goose was a wolf
2 - his role was aao
3 - in mishmashes the wolves know each others roles
4 - you explicitly said that he is not a wolf who know his aao role
5 - but you are saying he might be a wolf

just making sure thats correct

and now, your voting me for saying that villagers who vote themselves should not sign up for games

just making sure thats correct too



I've highlighted the incorrect parts. Hope this helps.
POG Anniversary IV:Attack of the Subs Game Thread Quote
04-14-2010 , 01:41 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by metsandfinsfan
Dear TL

if your like for birdman prevents you from shooting him tonight, please shoot chips ahoy


metsy
I'll take it as long as you get shot after my reveal. Deal or no deal?
POG Anniversary IV:Attack of the Subs Game Thread Quote
04-14-2010 , 01:42 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chips Ahoy
I've highlighted the incorrect parts. Hope this helps.
Number 3 is not incorrect, in the one wolf mishmash I've played I got a list of all the wolf roles/role names
POG Anniversary IV:Attack of the Subs Game Thread Quote
04-14-2010 , 01:42 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chips Ahoy
I've highlighted the incorrect parts. Hope this helps.
name one mishmash that the wolves didnt know each others names if people were told their own names

name one

and

why did you vote me?
i bitched about iflat ****ing up and then selfvoting and leaving, and said if hes a villager thats gonna do that he should sign up anymore. and then you voted me

so please assplain
POG Anniversary IV:Attack of the Subs Game Thread Quote
04-14-2010 , 01:42 PM
TL both you and Akson left your mason codes d1?
POG Anniversary IV:Attack of the Subs Game Thread Quote
04-14-2010 , 01:43 PM
I can still name all the wolf roles from Monty Python
POG Anniversary IV:Attack of the Subs Game Thread Quote
04-14-2010 , 01:44 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kokiri
This post by birdman I think is astoundingly villagey. Amazingly so. Pretty much insta-clearingly so

That relativity post was hilarious, however. Do graduate students often say things like that? Like, ever?
I must be missing something. Did you mean to quote a different post?
POG Anniversary IV:Attack of the Subs Game Thread Quote
04-14-2010 , 01:44 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chips Ahoy
I'll take it as long as you get shot after my reveal. Deal or no deal?
TL has one shot

i expect to be shot at some point since i wont get lynched

hopefully later rather than sooner

Quote:
Originally Posted by kwami42
Number 3 is not incorrect, in the one wolf mishmash I've played I got a list of all the wolf roles/role names
Wolves get a complete list in mishmashes. there could be some roles that are hidden or you have to find, but that would have come up in goose's writeup if he was one

but we all know this already, so what are we arguing about
POG Anniversary IV:Attack of the Subs Game Thread Quote
04-14-2010 , 01:45 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kwami42
Number 3 is not incorrect, in the one wolf mishmash I've played I got a list of all the wolf roles/role names
I was a wolf in WW3. Can I tell you right now which wolves had which role names? No, I cannot. Also, early in the game I couldn't even tell you who my partners were without checking the PM.

So have a PM that tells you is not the same as "knowing".

I'm not even sure which day / how early whitegoose made that post.

There are 12? wolves in this game. I dare each of them to list the names & role names of their partners. The average will be 50%?

Which is why #3 is incorrect. If WER is a wolf, that doesn't mean he "knows" Goose is aao.
POG Anniversary IV:Attack of the Subs Game Thread Quote
04-14-2010 , 01:45 PM
Chips here's some advice

admit you were wrong, suck some face, and let's move on
POG Anniversary IV:Attack of the Subs Game Thread Quote
04-14-2010 , 01:46 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chips Ahoy
btw, the gimmick that showed up out of nowhere (ScottHoward v10), that could easily be the bsball / Dirk role, right?
Quote:
Originally Posted by derwipok
no
Chips did you just believe me here? I'm wondering why you'd ask such a question and then just drop it.
POG Anniversary IV:Attack of the Subs Game Thread Quote
04-14-2010 , 01:46 PM
@ derwi:

Quote:
Originally Posted by TimeLady
Anyone else think this game has stalled?

Kokiri's random ramblings about offtopic stuff isn't helping me increase my villager lean on him, but still have him there. Some people are voting maruchan for reasons I can't remember, and I don't think maru had done anything Outstandingly wolfy.

Now I'm adding mets and boo to my villa leans, but only very tiny weak ones
Captial letters, post 417

Quote:
Originally Posted by Aaronk56's Son
81 Bitches!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Aaronk56's Son
From the coast of gold, across the seven seas,
I'm traveling on, far and wide,
But now it seems, I'm just a stranger to myself,
And all the things I sometimes do, it isn't me but someone else.
81 is the atomic number of Thallium, [TL], and the lyrics are from Iron Maiden's "Wasted Years", the cover of which references Doctor Who [TimeLady]
POG Anniversary IV:Attack of the Subs Game Thread Quote
04-14-2010 , 01:46 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chips Ahoy
I was a wolf in WW3. Can I tell you right now which wolves had which role names? No, I cannot. Also, early in the game I couldn't even tell you who my partners were without checking the PM.

So have a PM that tells you is not the same as "knowing".

I'm not even sure which day / how early whitegoose made that post.

There are 12? wolves in this game. I dare each of them to list the names & role names of their partners. The average will be 50%?

Which is why #3 is incorrect. If WER is a wolf, that doesn't mean he "knows" Goose is aao.
Okay, what. Does this argument make sense to anyone?
POG Anniversary IV:Attack of the Subs Game Thread Quote
04-14-2010 , 01:47 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chips Ahoy
I was a wolf in WW3. Can I tell you right now which wolves had which role names? No, I cannot. Also, early in the game I couldn't even tell you who my partners were without checking the PM.

So have a PM that tells you is not the same as "knowing".

I'm not even sure which day / how early whitegoose made that post.

There are 12? wolves in this game. I dare each of them to list the names & role names of their partners. The average will be 50%?

Which is why #3 is incorrect. If WER is a wolf, that doesn't mean he "knows" Goose is aao.
you would have at least read the pm, and then you wouldnt have the balls to just go out and say "shut up aao". you wouldnt unless you knew it was him and were leveling. otherwise you wouldnt do it

im done arguing with you. i hope tl shoots you
POG Anniversary IV:Attack of the Subs Game Thread Quote
04-14-2010 , 01:47 PM
Chips is not making sense, which is not necessarily wolfy

Dustin is not posting itt, is posting in POG. That is necessarily wolfy
POG Anniversary IV:Attack of the Subs Game Thread Quote
04-14-2010 , 01:47 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TimeLady
@ derwi:



Captial letters, post 417





81 is the atomic number of Thallium, [TL], and the lyrics are from Iron Maiden's "Wasted Years", the cover of which references Doctor Who [TimeLady]
Yeah I had seen that, just didn't remember if you left those d1
POG Anniversary IV:Attack of the Subs Game Thread Quote
04-14-2010 , 01:48 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kwami42
Number 3 is not incorrect, in the one wolf mishmash I've played I got a list of all the wolf roles/role names
This.

Plus, if the wolves didnt get each others role, you would have to assume that they communicated their powers to each other. I would think it very likely that goose would have mentioned his rolename at that time.
POG Anniversary IV:Attack of the Subs Game Thread Quote
04-14-2010 , 01:48 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Zurvan
Chips is not making sense, which is not necessarily wolfy

Dustin is not posting itt, is posting in POG. That is necessarily wolfy
As is Reno.
POG Anniversary IV:Attack of the Subs Game Thread Quote
04-14-2010 , 01:48 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Birdman10687
I was referring to someone who would have been a grad student at the time the theory came out--when it still was not understood completely. Obviously no grad student today would say that.
meh, maybe literature grad students.
POG Anniversary IV:Attack of the Subs Game Thread Quote
04-14-2010 , 01:48 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by kwami42
Okay, what. Does this argument make sense to anyone?
no

but hes voting me for what i said about iflat, so what can you expect

TL - stop tapping on the glass. let the morans find your claim, you've posted it, you;ve explained it, you've given us a peek. you've done your job
POG Anniversary IV:Attack of the Subs Game Thread Quote
04-14-2010 , 01:49 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by metsandfinsfan
why did you vote me?
because you were being a bully (surprise) and you asked him to not play anymore. because I think IFlat is a villager and the way people were picking on him disgusted me. He enjoys playing, he tries, and he gets dumped on. It's awful.

If I had to pick one person to not play werewolf it would be you, not him.

That's why I said "no u".

I want you dead in this game, I think it would be pro-villa even if you are seer.
POG Anniversary IV:Attack of the Subs Game Thread Quote

      
m