Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Pirates of Pogglesport III - The Final Hunt Pirates of Pogglesport III - The Final Hunt

08-08-2008 , 06:52 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by fnord_too
So you think taking a total gamble on you is better than a situation where you have a legitimate chance to make a good read?

But on to important matters, what about MDD?
no, if the majority reads me as wolf (will never happen), then i should be lynched. what you were implying was simply if i wasnt peeked, i should be lynched regardless (for fear i may be a wolf once in a while).
i guarantee you fnord, if im ever lynched (ever, not just this game), wolves were involved.

re mdd: i hope he has been peeked. i have nothing to go on really.
Pirates of Pogglesport III - The Final Hunt Quote
08-08-2008 , 06:59 PM
the real question here is how many pieces of double bubble can i fit in my mouth. Im thinking >40
Pirates of Pogglesport III - The Final Hunt Quote
08-08-2008 , 07:00 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by MDoranD
the real question here is how many pieces of double bubble can i fit in my mouth. Im thinking >40
LOL.
Pirates of Pogglesport III - The Final Hunt Quote
08-08-2008 , 07:00 PM
note to villagers:

if ever it is found that shorty is in fact a wolf, please to be rereading today and yesterday after shortys "claim" and take notice to the people who were most vocal about insisting shorty gets lynched.
doesnt make them wolves, but it certainly doesnt make them villagers. standard practice is to allow for the real (if shorty wasnt) seer to claim, then work from there. theres no reason to make a big deal about it if youre village. a wolf may try to gain some village points however by showing how eager he is to lynch shorty.
again, doesnt guarantee anything, but if you keep adding up wolf points, you know, you might find a wolf or three.
Pirates of Pogglesport III - The Final Hunt Quote
08-08-2008 , 07:03 PM
Actually scott, I was talking about this game when I made my statement. I have made no secret of the fact that I am leery of you. I would feel more or less conviction if I recalled your villager games as well as I recall your wolf games. In particular, I recall two wolf games: One where we were wolves together and that one where it went to three way and you pwned me. In the latter, the day before three way I almost pulled off of whoever got lynched instead of me and sacrificed myself because I had a revelation. But I had lingering doubts and couldn't pull the trigger.

At any rate, I see a lot of subtle things you did in those games and this one that are similar in nature. Moreover, they are what I would consider more useful to a wolf than a villager. So, in general, I have wolf leanings on you. I don't doubt that you can play your way out of anything but a peek in case you are a wolf, and anything as village, which is why I am giving my advice to the village.

There is a very real chance I get lynched tonight, and I would be remiss if I didn't give my thoughts and opinion.
Pirates of Pogglesport III - The Final Hunt Quote
08-08-2008 , 07:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ScottHoward v5.0
note to villagers:

if ever it is found that shorty is in fact a wolf, please to be rereading today and yesterday after shortys "claim" and take notice to the people who were most vocal about insisting shorty gets lynched.
doesnt make them wolves, but it certainly doesnt make them villagers. standard practice is to allow for the real (if shorty wasnt) seer to claim, then work from there. theres no reason to make a big deal about it if youre village. a wolf may try to gain some village points however by showing how eager he is to lynch shorty.
again, doesnt guarantee anything, but if you keep adding up wolf points, you know, you might find a wolf or three.
Wonder who he's talking about... I bet ZT could figure it out!
Pirates of Pogglesport III - The Final Hunt Quote
08-08-2008 , 07:04 PM
also when u reread look for people who make a post saying to reread...it shows that theyve planned this event thoroughly and want to keep u focused on the wrong people
Pirates of Pogglesport III - The Final Hunt Quote
08-08-2008 , 07:05 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by MDoranD
also when u reread look for people who make a post saying to reread...it shows that theyve planned this event thoroughly and want to keep u focused on the wrong people
nice!
Pirates of Pogglesport III - The Final Hunt Quote
08-08-2008 , 07:06 PM
this thread is very confusing

i feel like i should tell the village something about the seer that the wolves already know, but some people haven't put together yet
Pirates of Pogglesport III - The Final Hunt Quote
08-08-2008 , 07:06 PM
also, MDD is having the same sort of strange reaction that chim had where he's choosing to focus on the weirdest things, making his stand at the weirdest time...
Pirates of Pogglesport III - The Final Hunt Quote
08-08-2008 , 07:09 PM
meh not really a stand i just prefer standard plays made by villagers, which u claim to be is a villager or seer making a nonstandard play and i hate it. lynching you solves the problem and makes this **** easier to go thru because theres less people in the thread pretending.
Pirates of Pogglesport III - The Final Hunt Quote
08-08-2008 , 07:09 PM
vaya
Pirates of Pogglesport III - The Final Hunt Quote
08-08-2008 , 07:11 PM
consideration: the wolves know i am not a wolf.


scenario 1: the seer is one of my villager peeks

the wolves can kill from those peeks, hedging their bets between my being the seer and their kill being the seer. if the seer is one of my villager peeks, they know they are in danger and will possibly be more forward with their peeks.

scenario 2: the seer is one of my non-peeks

the wolves can kill from those non-peeks, but if i am actually the seer they are taking a really big risk. thus a seer who is in one of my non-peeks will be more likely to choose to hide knowing that they are not in as much danger tonight.

scenario 3: i am the seer

in this case, killing anyone but me is pretty much a mistake.




from this it seems clear that if you are the seer and one of my villager peeks you should not go to the grave with anything

however, if you are the seer and not one of my peeks, it is my advice to stick around, stay quiet and try not to get yourself lynched.
Pirates of Pogglesport III - The Final Hunt Quote
08-08-2008 , 07:13 PM
of course, if i'm still around tomorrow i'm going to have to reconsider the villagers i listed... although they seem to be very safe bets.

if i die tonight, you will know 100% my listed villagers are indeed villagers - the wolves definitely wouldn't kill me at this point if there was no chance i was seer.
Pirates of Pogglesport III - The Final Hunt Quote
08-08-2008 , 07:13 PM
and i also have a wolf peek, either chim or kyro
Pirates of Pogglesport III - The Final Hunt Quote
08-08-2008 , 07:13 PM
< 3 HOURS UNTIL NIGHT

1 Ackbleh - Vaya
0 Bob - Vaya
0 Chim - WDCBooks
0 Epi -
2 Fnord - MDD
0 Hitch - Fnord
1 Kyro - Shorty
0 Lastchance - Fnord
0 Luckay - WDCBooks
1 MDD - Shorty
0 ScottHoward -
3 Shorty - Kyro
2 Vaya - Ackbleh
2 WDCBooks - Shorty
0 ZeTurd -

NIGHT AT 10PM

10:00PM is good.
10:01PM is not.
Pirates of Pogglesport III - The Final Hunt Quote
08-08-2008 , 07:15 PM
cmon one time let shorty get lynched right here
Pirates of Pogglesport III - The Final Hunt Quote
08-08-2008 , 07:15 PM
Wow, the vote is pretty gross.
Pirates of Pogglesport III - The Final Hunt Quote
08-08-2008 , 07:16 PM
dinner break cya
Pirates of Pogglesport III - The Final Hunt Quote
08-08-2008 , 07:17 PM
the fact that anyone at all is voting me is crazy

the wolves really don't want to have to decide on me tonight

MDD is the "drunk" wolf who can make obvious bad-for-village plays and we'll all just say "awwwwww, poor thing"
Pirates of Pogglesport III - The Final Hunt Quote
08-08-2008 , 07:19 PM
Shorty,

Then I suggest you vote for him. just sayin.
Pirates of Pogglesport III - The Final Hunt Quote
08-08-2008 , 07:26 PM
are you joking? if i vote for him he'll never get lynched
Pirates of Pogglesport III - The Final Hunt Quote
08-08-2008 , 07:27 PM
You know what would be really cool? If we had someone as a clear leader in the vote count before 9:00 or so, so we don't have another fire drill like last night.
Pirates of Pogglesport III - The Final Hunt Quote
08-08-2008 , 07:27 PM
btw, shortline is clearly just trolling the thread to make it hard for everyone to pay attention to figuring out who to lynch. Which has two implications:
1. Put shortline on ignore until tomorrow.
2. Don't feel bad about lynching him if we can't get a wagon on a sensible target, because there's no reason to ever act like he is as a villager.
3. Keep an eye on the votes, as the wolves have a good opportunity to manipulate wagons and they will probably do so.
Pirates of Pogglesport III - The Final Hunt Quote
08-08-2008 , 07:30 PM
Bob,

I think you are correct. My faith that shorty is a wolf has been increasing, though I still think we need to let the wolves resolve it tonight.

I think MDD is a fine lynch right now.

Oh well.
Pirates of Pogglesport III - The Final Hunt Quote

      
m