Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Pink Floyd Discography Vanilla+ 17er Pink Floyd Discography Vanilla+ 17er

05-12-2021 , 06:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sun Tzu
were you really thinking all the wolves were posting enough to make lunching low posters bad?

who did you think the wolves were?
idk i was tinfoiling a lot of ppl like are thye just posting a lot more freely bc they have the ez lunches

mostly monte/irtm/wiggles/ami
Pink Floyd Discography Vanilla+ 17er Quote
05-12-2021 , 06:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by metsandfinsfan
But you thought Creature was for some reason
was what?

did u misread
Pink Floyd Discography Vanilla+ 17er Quote
05-12-2021 , 06:11 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ShipItUp
It wouldn't surprise me if both Creature/Manasi were villa, I feel better about Manasi then Creature. I think 1123 is villagery from Creature and gives off lazy villa vibes.
hmmm
Pink Floyd Discography Vanilla+ 17er Quote
05-12-2021 , 06:11 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NeedMoreManasi
idk i was tinfoiling a lot of ppl like are thye just posting a lot more freely bc they have the ez lunches

mostly monte/irtm/wiggles/ami
who do you think the wolves are now?
Pink Floyd Discography Vanilla+ 17er Quote
05-12-2021 , 06:11 PM
Maybe creature tried to self pres onto manasi and his internet went out
Pink Floyd Discography Vanilla+ 17er Quote
05-12-2021 , 06:11 PM
I'm not sure I'm going to sign up for another game w/ Sun it it after this
Pink Floyd Discography Vanilla+ 17er Quote
05-12-2021 , 06:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ShipItUp
I'm not sure I'm going to sign up for another game w/ Sun it it after this
because I think you could be a wolf?

seems extreme
Pink Floyd Discography Vanilla+ 17er Quote
05-12-2021 , 06:13 PM
I'm done for now, I just can't deal with this game atm.
Pink Floyd Discography Vanilla+ 17er Quote
05-12-2021 , 06:13 PM
Can we stop the meta-narratives about who's being mean to whom and what that means for future games; it's easy for wolves to fake and makes the rest of us have to level ourselves
Pink Floyd Discography Vanilla+ 17er Quote
05-12-2021 , 06:18 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sun Tzu
how do you know? has it ever been tried?
what happened to the narrative of me missing eod?

siu just made that up?
Pink Floyd Discography Vanilla+ 17er Quote
05-12-2021 , 06:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ShipItUp
Luckbox
Sun
Crossnerd
Manasi
Creature
Wiggles
Fanmail

This is how I'd order my POE, I think it's 3 of these and I got a villager wrong who I'll need to figure out in the upcoming days if I'm still living. If you're not on this list I have you as either a villager or somewhat villagery.
looks bad if dr z is a wolf
Pink Floyd Discography Vanilla+ 17er Quote
05-12-2021 , 06:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Montecore
Can we stop the meta-narratives about who's being mean to whom and what that means for future games; it's easy for wolves to fake and makes the rest of us have to level ourselves
Itt we learn that 17ers are a lot like 13ers, just with 4 more people. But seriously-- this whole trend in general and especially the dropping out of sign up threads is incredibly unhealthy for pog.
Pink Floyd Discography Vanilla+ 17er Quote
05-12-2021 , 06:24 PM
I'm around til EOD, right now I'm happy with removing Cross.

Manasi hasn't been enough yet too, saying she has 9 tabs open and then just didn't come in with the oomph or vigour that post portrayed.

Sun's meta-y return was eyeroll but I've liked his energy on the ISOs and thoughts on old posts, i don't feel he's agenda'd on his reads, his conclusions based off the creature posts/about creature seem reasonable.
Pink Floyd Discography Vanilla+ 17er Quote
05-12-2021 , 06:26 PM
Maybe we should just clear up those day 1 wagons from when we lunched the seer...
Pink Floyd Discography Vanilla+ 17er Quote
05-12-2021 , 06:26 PM
summary of mostly/all creature posts and interactions. I have some thoughts of a lot of this but I must go eat and do stuff. will be back in a bit n go thru day2. But I think there's some decent info(and a couple key vote counts) in here so please read thru



Spoiler:
monte voted creature #74
monte comments on creature quite a bit pg1 and top of pg2
nmm post#102 "creature, probably"
wiggles #115 - "Creatures entrance and lack of further engagement is pretty bad tho"
creature has (2) posts at this point
wiggles#164 "That creature post is legit hurting my stomach"
wiggles#167 still questioning creature
creature #172 I think he'scalling monte, irtm, wiggles wolfy?
luckbox #175 says creature probably good
wiggles #180 in re: to luck^ "I kinda feel he might be but this page of exchanges with him was really hard to experience."
kawami #279 "creature obvious villager - lol! I hope there's a vig cc lol
kawami #283 lists all villagers as wolves (5) exception monte not flipped yet
DZ #299 "Creature just chucking stuff out there willy nilly and without much thought. Literally looks like hurling darts at random" good look imo

creature - #440ish two posts @ mets. 1 vote and onesaying he's unimpressed by him. Nai imo
creature - #449 "cool VR is town"
luck and creature have casual convo in thread about books on pg5. gad also pops in
DZ - #591 suggesting I soft cleared creature (did not btw) and possibly w/w but weighs in on how creature was pretty wolfy
fanmail (v) - #598 calls out DZ^post as a fake read
wiggles #602 - Creature has hints of what I expect his town personality to but he's really not making use of his time in thread while he claims he's busy today, no idea why he's discussing books as either alignment.
350pm d1 monte still voting creature (54posts) and ccreature voting mets
DZ - #685 voting manasi and "Charry, creature, mets, irate etc. all have things worthy of investigating, but manasi ain't saying nothing"
monte - #793 list and then poe's charry, creature, dz, manasi
manasi - #815 comparing herself to creature. Asking why she isn't LHF if he is
shipitup #857 Creature asking to sheep someone. SIU directs him to vote fanmail (v)
creature - #860 creature votes fanmail as per SIU post
creature - #869 - "Still thinks mets is wolf here" (still voting him)
SIU - #871 after siu directs creature to vote fanmail, makes a list and has fanmail at bottom and creature 3rd from bottom with manasi
creature - #878 "ShitItUp feels town here"
#913 VC 6pm. Creature voting fanmail, monte still voting creature
"SIU-#915 list and claims 2 wolves are in there Luckbox Sun Wiggles Cross Creature Manasi"
pg 10 - luclbox engaging with creatures obviously jokey posts "is deadline today"luck asks him what are his thoughts on anything
wiggles - #959 "Somewhere in crossnerd/mets/manasi/charry/creature there's most of the wolves I hope" and adds luckbox second handedly
luckbox -#988 "We're probably just going to end up on Creature and shrugging our shoulders when he flips v."
kawami - #990 "i dont think creature or manasai are wolfy"
wiggles - #991 replying to luck-"I feel like if he's a villa he's vanilla because he does not seem thrilled by this game."
kawamii - #996 ""charry/manasai/creature/ami/siu/luck are my villagers

gad/irtm/mets/zeus/wiggles all sus"""
kawamii - #1025 re: IRTM "His reaction to my sus was fake, his post about creature was fake, everything is him struggling to not look wolfy"
8pm VC #1037 monte (80) still voting creature, creature/ship/cross voting fanmail
monte - #1048 "Creature has made zero effort at solving or clearing himself and I still think he's a fine choice absent someone compelling"
luck - #1051 replying to monte post "I sort of hate it but it's impossible to argue against it."
"AMI - #1073 wolf list - shipitup Creature sun tzu manasi fanmail"
manasi - #1077 replying to ami's list calling it mostly incorrect
luck - #1092 1 1/2 hr to eod votes creatures "Feels dirty I won't lie"
wiggles - #1093 ""I'm drifting off but I wanna make a meaningful vote. My manasi vote feels lazy/too easy or something. Considering creature"""
manasi - #1097 - "i think creature votes are equally lazy/lhf but we've gotta die at some point i suppose!"
monte - #1132 quoting his own case to manasi regarding creature. Manasi just switched vote to luckbox at this point
manasi - #1147 ""i just feel bad pushing creature too hard bc it seems like he's had some rough connection issues but in the midst of that there hasn't been much of anything so it's a hard pill to swallow and it feels dirty in the same way that lunching a 0 poster villager in a mash over posting wolves or w/e like. just feels bad. u know""

wiggles - #1156 ""creature (this is a vote)

his posts are so full of ****, said he won't be here but he's been in and out posting random nonsense.

this is kinda the last straw for me:

Quote:
Originally Posted by Creature View Post
I tried to post something useful a while ago but it crashed and I lost it

I really don't want fanmail lunch. Manasi lynch is okish and if she's w fanmail v.

I'm going to sleep. bye"""

manasi - #1160 asking why her and creature can't both be villlagers
kawamii - #1161 calls wiggles vote post a "bad post"
luck - #1176 "Mislunching Mets would in fact be a worse result than mislunching Creature."
manasi - #1177 commenting on a creature post ""this 100%

wow i'm mind melding with creature and kami someone take me out back"""
"creature - #1186 ""Quote:
Originally Posted by Kawamii View Post
irtm/wiggles/gad all wolves i expect the postgame cred
This is a spicy list I can buy"""

#1209 VC important wagons. Fanmail, manasi, creature Votes from post 11 to post 1208
Night in 0:59:54
---
Votes Lynch Voters
4 fanmail Crossnerd (6), ShipItUp (51), Creature (44), A missread issue (150)
3 NeedMoreManasi fanmail (66), Doctor Zeus (36), VoraciousReader (53)
3 Creature Montecore (102), Luckbox Inc (120), KingWiggles (65)
2 metsandfinsfan Charry (56), Sun Tzu (30)
2 KingWiggles Kawamii (69), metsandfinsfan (90)
1 Luckbox Inc NeedMoreManasi (78)
1 Doctor Zeus Gadarene (89)
1 unvote iraisetoomuch (76)"

creature - #1216 saying dz is a "meh target"
creature #1260 ""Quote:
Originally Posted by Montecore View Post
Remind me again of your preferred targets
idk, I have mets who posted a fair bunch by now but has been unimpressive and AMI who seemed to be only going for the easy pushes. Feels like in irtm, Wiggles and Gad should have wolves too."""

pg13 luclbox and creature have casual interaction. Asking why he's posting 10 minutes apart, procrastination, etc
creature - #1287 votes mets when wagons are tight. Fanmail (5 before creature switch), manasi (3), wiggles (3), creature (3-monte/luck/wiggles), and mets (1)

VC #1326 Votes from post 11 to post 1325
Night in 0:29:56
---
Votes Lynch Voters
5 fanmail Crossnerd (8), ShipItUp (64), A missread issue (160), Sun Tzu (40), Kawamii (80)
4 KingWiggles metsandfinsfan (94), NeedMoreManasi (87), Montecore (115), fanmail (75)
3 NeedMoreManasi Doctor Zeus (36), iraisetoomuch (81), VoraciousReader (59)
2 Creature Luckbox Inc (128), KingWiggles (65)
2 metsandfinsfan Charry (64), Creature (49)
1 Doctor Zeus Gadarene (90)"

Shipitup- #1337 "It wouldn't surprise me if both Creature/Manasi were villa, I feel better about Manasi then Creature. I think 1123 is villagery from Creature and gives off lazy villa vibes"

VC #1379 Votes from post 11 to post 1378
Night in 0:14:58
---
Votes Lynch Voters
7 fanmail Crossnerd (8), ShipItUp (71), A missread issue (161), Sun Tzu (40), Kawamii (89), metsandfinsfan (101), Montecore (122)
3 NeedMoreManasi Doctor Zeus (36), iraisetoomuch (82), VoraciousReader (59)
3 KingWiggles NeedMoreManasi (88), fanmail (86), Luckbox Inc (133)
2 metsandfinsfan Charry (64), Creature (51)
1 Creature KingWiggles (65)
1 Doctor Zeus Gadarene (90)"

SIU - #1414 poe list - Luckbox Sun Crossnerd Manasi Creature Wiggles Fanmail"
Pink Floyd Discography Vanilla+ 17er Quote
05-12-2021 , 06:28 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Crossnerd
Maybe we should just clear up those day 1 wagons from when we lunched the seer...
Why are you focused on cleaning up the counter to the runaway wagon on the seer rather than the extremely close wagon from last night?
Pink Floyd Discography Vanilla+ 17er Quote
05-12-2021 , 06:28 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by KingWiggles
I'm around til EOD, right now I'm happy with removing Cross.

Manasi hasn't been enough yet too, saying she has 9 tabs open and then just didn't come in with the oomph or vigour that post portrayed.

Sun's meta-y return was eyeroll but I've liked his energy on the ISOs and thoughts on old posts, i don't feel he's agenda'd on his reads, his conclusions based off the creature posts/about creature seem reasonable.
the 9 tabs were all the posts i responded to

smh
Pink Floyd Discography Vanilla+ 17er Quote
05-12-2021 , 06:29 PM
manasi
Pink Floyd Discography Vanilla+ 17er Quote
05-12-2021 , 06:30 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NeedMoreManasi
the 9 tabs were all the posts i responded to

smh
It sounded like you'd have detailed answers but it was just normal posting. Maybe my expectation was wrong but I was expecting spice
Pink Floyd Discography Vanilla+ 17er Quote
05-12-2021 , 06:31 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by KingWiggles
Why are you focused on cleaning up the counter to the runaway wagon on the seer rather than the extremely close wagon from last night?
You should be lynching Manasi then.
Pink Floyd Discography Vanilla+ 17er Quote
05-12-2021 , 06:34 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Doctor Zeus
Sun's posting good today in general.

Crossnerds not. Creature style defensive.




Manasi just doesn't care about the game and it kinda sucks
Dr z seems pretty in line with exactly what I think today and I like his Manasi line of posts recently.
Pink Floyd Discography Vanilla+ 17er Quote
05-12-2021 , 06:34 PM
a lot of people came right out of the gate d2 pushing creature

I might have to look at d2 twice based on whether creature was a planned bus or not
Pink Floyd Discography Vanilla+ 17er Quote
05-12-2021 , 06:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Crossnerd
You should be lynching Manasi then.
That's avoiding the question, I'm enquiring you about it because it looks to me like you're engaging with mechanical information that suits your agenda rather than solving the game through conversation and live werewolf play.

I'm trying to get an answer for you why the day 1 specifically matters to you and I'd also like to know if you're considering any other context with regard to that lynch like whether specific people REALLY wanted that lynch or if certain people didn't want that lynch and what the person you're trying to kill was voting for on that night.
Pink Floyd Discography Vanilla+ 17er Quote
05-12-2021 , 06:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by KingWiggles
It sounded like you'd have detailed answers but it was just normal posting. Maybe my expectation was wrong but I was expecting spice
you've known me for like 6 years when have i ever come out with spice
Pink Floyd Discography Vanilla+ 17er Quote
05-12-2021 , 06:40 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sun Tzu
a lot of people came right out of the gate d2 pushing creature

I might have to look at d2 twice based on whether creature was a planned bus or not
not eye feelsgoodman
Pink Floyd Discography Vanilla+ 17er Quote

      
m