Once Upon A Time In Pogwarts - Game Thread
03-20-2017
, 08:31 PM
03-20-2017
, 08:32 PM
03-20-2017
, 08:33 PM
03-20-2017
, 08:33 PM
03-20-2017
, 08:33 PM
03-20-2017
, 08:34 PM
03-20-2017
, 08:34 PM
03-20-2017
, 08:34 PM
03-20-2017
, 08:35 PM
03-20-2017
, 08:35 PM
03-20-2017
, 08:36 PM
Diceman iso. I dont have the nifty extension so this was manual, aka FUUUUU if I missed any and want to use that to somehow make a case to lynch me
Quote:
Thats why he can be a villager for now. Asking questions is a good start. I want to give him time and see where he goes from there. Even if he doesn't follow them up himself I still believe asking questions is pro village as it helps put info in the thread.
Sometimes you need to ask a bunch of questions before you can figure out your thoughts.
Sometimes you need to ask a bunch of questions before you can figure out your thoughts.
Quote:
One of the top posters as a wolf, maybe I can buy this theory. Its often true but the question is where do you draw the line. Top 3 posters? Top 4? Top 5?
You listed 9 people and said there is a wolf there. You realise I could go to random.org and put in the player list and pull out 9 people at random and there would almost always be a wolf in there right?
My point was your post was pointless and silly.
You listed 9 people and said there is a wolf there. You realise I could go to random.org and put in the player list and pull out 9 people at random and there would almost always be a wolf in there right?
My point was your post was pointless and silly.
Quote:
Different games are different.
Last game I basically did 0 RL work as I was posting so much and paying too much attention to the game. Plus there was much easier interaction. Here it feels like a lot of people saying stuff about each other and less interaction.
I have seen a few questionable posts by people but nothing for me to get overly excited about.
Last game I basically did 0 RL work as I was posting so much and paying too much attention to the game. Plus there was much easier interaction. Here it feels like a lot of people saying stuff about each other and less interaction.
I have seen a few questionable posts by people but nothing for me to get overly excited about.
Quote:
I asked you to clarify what you were asking me so I could answer it. I don't believe any questions jpeg asked needed clarifying, so the comparison is poor.
You were an early read and there has been no progression since then. What progression would you like me to shave shown if there has been none?
You were an early read and there has been no progression since then. What progression would you like me to shave shown if there has been none?
Quote:
iamnotawerewolf
I guess this is the progression you have been looking for.
You seem to be throwing shade my way about my jpeg read yet have not really been able to dispute it. You then started pushing xnerd about mechanics rather than interacting more with me.
There is also this post earlier in the day and I don't think you pushed him for making THE EXACT SAME READ that I made. If you really had issue with my read then you should have had the same issue with Donatello, except it seems no one was calling him a wolf so that might be a bit tougher.
I guess this is the progression you have been looking for.
You seem to be throwing shade my way about my jpeg read yet have not really been able to dispute it. You then started pushing xnerd about mechanics rather than interacting more with me.
There is also this post earlier in the day and I don't think you pushed him for making THE EXACT SAME READ that I made. If you really had issue with my read then you should have had the same issue with Donatello, except it seems no one was calling him a wolf so that might be a bit tougher.
Quote:
I could lynch him. He doesn't seem to be doing much, although that might be his day 1 shtick, I cant remember.
Unfortunatly I feel like Well Named has not been villagery as well. I dislike this because he had me on his lynch list and it looks like im just going after people who call me a wolf even though that is not the case.
Unfortunatly I feel like Well Named has not been villagery as well. I dislike this because he had me on his lynch list and it looks like im just going after people who call me a wolf even though that is not the case.
Quote:
He seems less active at the moment but I don't remember him being one of the top posters last game either.
ChrisV is less active than last game too but I don't feel you can judge his role based on that.
Manasi has been less active too (less spam) but has provided about the same level of content as last game, I feel that should be more concerning.
ChrisV is less active than last game too but I don't feel you can judge his role based on that.
Manasi has been less active too (less spam) but has provided about the same level of content as last game, I feel that should be more concerning.
Quote:
I have been giving reads and reasons throughout the day, if you want them they are there. If you want an excuse to vote me then pretend they don't exist. If you do that though I will be forced to waste my time going back and quoting them and making you look silly.
I would prefer not to do your work for you though.
I would prefer not to do your work for you though.
Quote:
Full reads with some details. Lot of people that I have no read on at the moment but I feel like I have enough on others to make a reasonable call at EOD.
CalledDownLight - I remeber him being a good wolf, a very good wolf. Once we had a werewolf draft and I picked him to be on my wolf team and he didnt dissapoint. While this was a very long time ago I dont think this is his wolf game.
Donat3llo - Doesnt seem as vilagery as last game, except he was a wolf last game, so villager?
jepg - Villager, pretty sure. See his reads post that he replied to me with as a good example.
JMurder3 - Villager. Pure as snow. No one seems to be questioning this though.
Reaperlicious - Slight villa lean. Seems to be very involved.
xander biscuits - Seems to be posting well after getting some early heat, good sign
Xkf - I have to go with the general trend and say he is villagery. Personally I have trouble seeing the difference in his games.
AllInBluff - Not seeing why so many are after him. He hasn't been super villager but I don't think he was last game, he even mentioned that he didn't vote D1 last game but people don't seem to care.
ChrisV - Nothing to see here
Crossnerd - Her movements lead me to believe (for now) that she is genuinly busy. The mecanics talk is fine and doesnt bother me.
johnny_on_the_spot - Same as last game. He was a villager then too but its not a good endorcment if his content levels are always like this.
Jon Paul - Hard to read. Unsure.
Montecore - Who knows. I just dont worry about him until later if he is still alive. Seems like a reasonable plan as he isnt going to get lynched D1 anyway so why worry.
NeedMoreManasi - Possibly a wolf. The only difference between this game and last game is a lower number of posts.
thabighurt35 - No idea, not seen enough
TheBrokenATM! - Who can read him?
theknightsofneeee - 50/50 seen a few posts that sounded good and a few that were not so good.
younguns87 - No idea
iamnotawerewolf - Think he is. I have posted about this, click on my vote for him to see it.
iraisetoomuch - Im suspicious of him at the moment but willing to give a pass because he said he would be busy today.
iversonian - Doesnt seem to be doing anything positive. Not really sure what his plan is, probably a wolf.
well named - Doesnt seem to be doing much solving, claimed to have a few reads but little to back them up.
CalledDownLight - I remeber him being a good wolf, a very good wolf. Once we had a werewolf draft and I picked him to be on my wolf team and he didnt dissapoint. While this was a very long time ago I dont think this is his wolf game.
Donat3llo - Doesnt seem as vilagery as last game, except he was a wolf last game, so villager?
jepg - Villager, pretty sure. See his reads post that he replied to me with as a good example.
JMurder3 - Villager. Pure as snow. No one seems to be questioning this though.
Reaperlicious - Slight villa lean. Seems to be very involved.
xander biscuits - Seems to be posting well after getting some early heat, good sign
Xkf - I have to go with the general trend and say he is villagery. Personally I have trouble seeing the difference in his games.
AllInBluff - Not seeing why so many are after him. He hasn't been super villager but I don't think he was last game, he even mentioned that he didn't vote D1 last game but people don't seem to care.
ChrisV - Nothing to see here
Crossnerd - Her movements lead me to believe (for now) that she is genuinly busy. The mecanics talk is fine and doesnt bother me.
johnny_on_the_spot - Same as last game. He was a villager then too but its not a good endorcment if his content levels are always like this.
Jon Paul - Hard to read. Unsure.
Montecore - Who knows. I just dont worry about him until later if he is still alive. Seems like a reasonable plan as he isnt going to get lynched D1 anyway so why worry.
NeedMoreManasi - Possibly a wolf. The only difference between this game and last game is a lower number of posts.
thabighurt35 - No idea, not seen enough
TheBrokenATM! - Who can read him?
theknightsofneeee - 50/50 seen a few posts that sounded good and a few that were not so good.
younguns87 - No idea
iamnotawerewolf - Think he is. I have posted about this, click on my vote for him to see it.
iraisetoomuch - Im suspicious of him at the moment but willing to give a pass because he said he would be busy today.
iversonian - Doesnt seem to be doing anything positive. Not really sure what his plan is, probably a wolf.
well named - Doesnt seem to be doing much solving, claimed to have a few reads but little to back them up.
Quote:
Why me is a better question. No one plays exactly the same in every game. You said in your read of me that I wasn't asking questions or commenting on things but that was not exactly true as your post was a response to questions by me.
Other than not posting 100 times and having to hard defend myself, what are the differences this game in your opinion?
Other than not posting 100 times and having to hard defend myself, what are the differences this game in your opinion?
03-20-2017
, 08:36 PM
03-20-2017
, 08:36 PM