Reread of chatterbox:
day 1
#55
Standard 1st post, seems pretty honest.
#106
States that 64 is obviously a villager.
#111
response to wahoo saying #106 was very 1st level thinking, tongue in cheek.
#291
1st post he's made that can really be analyzed, says that andrewx is the most obvious villager in history (2nd time he's used that phrase). Votes guinessz due to a post where he questions andrex and AAO, quotes another post of guinessz which he says is a clever wolf tactic to not get voted.
End of day one, summary: He seems very quick to make all or nothing assumptions based on very little evidence. Granted this is day 1, so it's not like there's much evidence going around, so I'm not sure what to make of it yet. His defense of andrewx I find odd, the same way I find AAO's odd, because andrewx could easily have been told in d1 wolfchat to ask nub questions and not be UTR by a more experienced wolf. I believe -EV mentioned this as well. Chatter/AAO could easily be brother wolves attempting to sell the cover, so to speak, though I think they've been a bit too vocal about it for it to be very likely (AAO at least, chatter if I remember correctly hasn't piped up in andrewx's defense lately)
day 2
#514
Comments on a couple posts of LC's
#517
gives us our 1st list of reads from him and a sixfour vote because he "agrees with soah", which would be parroting except I know from memory he goes much more indepth later on. Him leaving semper on the wolf list was odd, but I actually think that gives him village points. A wolf would be more careful about his posts and have caught that.
#518
Now this I find wolfy, he assigns LC to his village list (after calling him out on a inconsistancy) after LC backtracks and says he doesn't really believe himself. I don't see how this would give chatter a villager read on LC, normally inconsistancies and waffling on reads are wolfy characteristics.
#528
Throwaway post, nothing to see.
#535
Another wolfy post, for a few reasons. One, he unvotes sixfour for reasons I'm not entirely sure of (I don't know what he means by take the cake), which would be innocent if he didn't swing back to sixfour in a major way at the EOD. Two, he makes another screwup on his lists and votes Wahoo, a villager read, and says it's likely to be his final vote. One list screwup could be simply that, a screwup, but 2 in a row makes it more likely to be a strategy. He also comes out in defense of Zhaorx, but very weakly, simply saying he's a bad wagon. I would expect a villager who truly believed Zhaorx was villa to actually try and convince people to get off that wagon, especially if it was likely that chatter wasn't going to return, instead he simply says it's bad and then leaves which looks like a wolf trying to score cheap villa points.
-Aside: There is quite a bit of chatter on chatterbox after this series of posts, most being that he's a possible wolf, which might have influenced chatter's return at the EOD to go after sixfour (if he wasn't being discussed, and was a wolf, I'd expect him to quietly let night come and go)
#763
Explains why he's not around much during the day. Says that him being around at the EOD on d2 is an "abnormality" (possibly giving him excuses to let the EOD float by quietly in the future without making noise, wolfy tactic imo), and again gives a very opinionated and empty defense of Z. I have the same thoughts on this as I had before.
#770
Unvotes wahoo, gives a consistant reason for it when compared to previous posts. Though his willingness to blindly follow soah is annoying me.
#781
Says officedog is clearly a villager for a post extremely similar to the one guinessz left (both basically saying to go ahead and lynch them). I find it weird that for one he says it's an obvious wolf tactic, and the other is an obvious villager comment.
He then makes a throwaway vote for AAO based on him not doing the ssod yet (it's day 2, even if it had been done it would have been essentially worthless due to lack of good data), and again defends Z with a bit more of an argument than before. Though he seems to know it's weak and that he has no chance of derailing the wagon. Which is odd seeing as he makes a very concerted effort to derail the wagon when he goes after 64 later on, and almost succeeds. Again this looks like a wolf trying to earn villa points cheaply by defending somebody he knows is villa, but not hard enough to actually stop the mislynch.
#785
another list of reads, not that much to talk about.
#804
His case against sixfour, posted 4 minutes before EOD (he says 10 which I believe it was when he started typing the post), much too late to have a very likely chance to stop the wagon.
His case itself has a few odd notes to it, he tries to make sixfour look inconsistant by quoting some posts where sixfour is varying degress of certain and uncertain, the problem being that the subject of sixfour's posts is frequently different so 64 being certain about one read and somewhat unsure of another makes perfect sense. The meat of it is based on a phrased used by 64 that chatter claims is wolf speak, I don't particularly agree with this but I'm not as well versed on wolf tells as other people.
In any case the primary thing I take out of this is that it comes simply too late in the day to have a good shot at derailing the Zhaorx wagon. I don't think chatterbox really intended to stop the Zhaorx mislynch
809
votes 64 2 minutes before EOD
#814
Gives more evidence against 64 1 minute before EOD
#817
And odd throwaway post at 5 PM, one would think he would be still trying to push 64 over Zhaorx since he believes 64 is a wolf and Zhaorx isn't, but he doesn't.
End of day 2, summary: His series of posts early on in the day definitely give him wolf points, but most of what I wanted to say about them I already have. Instead I want to focus on his EOD posts. I backtracked the timestamps to see if there was anything there. Chatter made post #770 at 4:37, post #781 at 4:45, post #804 at 4:56. The point I'm trying to make is, why did he wait so long to go after 64? 770 had some merit to it, but it could have been stuck on at the END of post 804 and still had the same impact. 781 was an almost entire waste of time, by chatterbox's own admission he doesn't expect it to make an impact in the least. So why did he spend precious time at the EOD posting it? We know from past posts he suspected 64, had he made post 801 around 4:40 it would have given people enough time to react and change their votes if persuaded, but instead he chose to waste time and post it at the last possible moment where it was very unlikely that it would affect anything.
Nothing about this looks to me like he was really trying to stop the Zhaorx wagon as a villager in his position would.
day 3:
#834
Continues to push 64, also makes a comment about how he would kill soah d1 no matter what soah says about him (basically saying it's a null tell). My memory is saying this same topic came up earlier and that chatter had a different take on it, but I could very easily be wrong and it's hard to backcheck in this post since I don't have the links handy. If somebody could see if I'm right it would be appreciated.
#835
Quotes something from officedog and says it's clearly the peek, I agree so not much to see.
#842
Response to a question about his participation. I believe his reasons in general and don't think anything can be drawn by them except for what I've mentioned earlier about the EOD.
#844
Another list of reads, not much seems out of place. He says the LC "I don't believe...." is a villager tell which would explain his earlier conclusion.
$845
A rather conversational post, nothing stands out.
#848
See above.
#850
Questions AAO as to why he hasn't put out the spreadsheet yet. Can't really draw much from this interaction since I haven't played with either of them before.
#851
Asks OTI why he thinks he's wolfy
#858
Response to OTI's response, don't know what to make of it really.
#862
Says he will be gone sat
#1082
Returns today, waffles on 64, votes me for a BS reason. AAO is somehow off his list after posting the ssod, which doesn't make sense because AAO was on his list in the first place because he dragged his feet in doing it. Why does AAO succumbing to peer pressure (so to speak) clear him?
#1084
Backtracks a bit on his andrewx is an obvious villager read
Which brings us too the present, I'll post closing thoughts once I have iced down my shoulder.
