If I was a wolf with one of Semper and Zhorax and Wahoo was a villager, this is what I would post too. (Is that too much of a stretch?)

Zhoarx i'm conflicted on because his tone is a bit weird, but his reaction to me on p1 was a little villagey and i don't really have anything wolfy on him, whereas i think semper is a legit good lynch

I am sooooo lost. Please bear with me while I try to figure out who's on first.

I'm beginning to think a spreadsheet might be in order for this game.

i've been very villagery. i've found some wolves and found some supercleared villagers

i'm of the opinion that lynching zhao would be epically bad here

actually i was talking about you and your interpretation of it.

Who?

I think the wolves are Birdman, Scubbo, Zhorax, Chatterbox and Soah. I would be interested to know anyone's opinion on how many I got right.

super cleared villagers: me, kokiri, 64, buttons, soah

wolfs: u, wahoo, semper, last chance, + a newbie

you might have birdman right.

lol - looking at our reads, I am nearly 100% sure that Zhorax and me are on seperate teams and probably at least one of us is reading the wrong thread!

yes, because we can take a stab at an entire wolf team on day 1, and call out someone who's made a grand total of four posts. so are you saying everyone else is a villager, or are you just throwing names out and seeing what'll stick?

so ur saying ur a wolf? cool. ez game.

yea you can be nearly 100% sure we're on opposite teams IF YOU ARE A WOLF. tarped.

wahoo today

[1]aao v zhorax
[1]Andrex Puppy
birdman v G1982
bsball v zhorax
Chatterbox v guiness
chips v wahhopride
djstu v zhoax
[1]G1982 v zhorax
[2]guinnes v Andrex
kokiri v semper
LC v semper
[0]MinusEV v sixfour
MrsButton v
Nicholasp27 v wahoopride
officedog v Guinnessz
OnThInIcE911 v wahoo
scrubbo v wahoopride
[4]semper v wahoopride
[1]sixfour v wahoopride
soah v semper
[7]wahoo v semper
wdcbooks v aao
[4]Zhorax v wahoo

this but imo swap one of the first 4 for wcdbooks.

Night in <1 hour

Interestingly enough, I had SixFour on my list then decided that Chatterbox was playing too unLuckayish to be a villager. Chatter's first post would be pretty sick for someone who had been randed a wolf twice in a row.

Wahoo and Semper both look villagery to me. Apart from this, I have not really seen any strong villager reads.

I can't believe that all the people voting me early were villagers. Soah and Zhorax being wolves seems a bit of a stretch but it would be an interesting dynamic that either could claim was not w/w later and both are experienced enough players to try it.

Birdman and Scubbo, I have explained earlier - although Scubbo does rely on most of the rest of my reads being right.

Since I have about 5 possible wolves, I thought I'd put it out there - I'm not claiming to be 100% sure on d1. One day, I'm going to rand them correct and it will go down in WW history.

also can anyone give me some 'tips for day' in terms of wolf hunting?

To be honest d1 is particularly difficult. When some people have been lynched and we have some confirmed wolves and villagers it becomes easier. For now - look for people who are calling other people wolves for no reason or for reasons that do not make sense.

wolves have to try to pretend to be hunting for wolves, and make reads and so on, and have to hide their knowledge of people's roles. So they have to manufacture a villager's cluelessness and lines of reasoning, and this is difficult. Look for unnatural logic, inconsistencies, and thinking that strikes you as weird.

******FLASH OF INSPIRATION ITP*****************

WAHOO IS NOT A WOLF

He left the thread with the votes:

[4]Semper votes Wahoo
[5]Wahoo votes Semper
[4]Zhorax votes Wahoo

IF HE IS A WOLF AND ZHORAX IS A VILLAGER, HE WOULD HAVE CHANGED HIS VOTE.

Thus Zhorax is a better lynch.

***************DISCUSS*************

I'll vote Semper to save Wahoo if necessary but will probably feel dirty afterwards.

quoted for emphasis.

As far as I can tell the semper wagon is basically wahoo giving a weak reason as to why he thinks semper is wolfy and then a bunch of people saying "I agree". If semper comes up villa then I'd expect more than a couple wolves are on the wagon.

If somebody has some good logic for lynching semper I'd like to hear it, Zhoarx or wahoo are much better lynches for today.