Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Magic The Gathering Mishmash Game thread Magic The Gathering Mishmash Game thread

01-25-2013 , 03:24 PM
I'm disappointed tweedy hasn't made any choking references ITT
Magic The Gathering Mishmash Game thread Quote
01-25-2013 , 03:27 PM
Wolves needed more end game wolves to win this.
Magic The Gathering Mishmash Game thread Quote
01-25-2013 , 03:27 PM
I was planning on photoshopping your avatar onto reggiemillerchokeface.jpg, but apparently it was just a flip so nbd.
Magic The Gathering Mishmash Game thread Quote
01-25-2013 , 03:27 PM
FYI the PM related modkills in this game are a subject of discussion in the grievances thread.

See This post and subsequent.

For anyone interested who isn't reading that thread
Magic The Gathering Mishmash Game thread Quote
01-25-2013 , 03:27 PM
Balance thoughts that might improve things for MTG2: The Expansion (IMO)

ITAs: Yeah, they're incredibly pro village, there's no getting around it. Some more variation in power/toughness (on both sides) might change this a fair amount -- give each side a 4/15 or two and make a couple villagers 0/4 or something and you've got yourselves a more fun ITA period.

Spells: To alleviate most (not all) of the rungood/runbad, which can honestly completely break the game, maybe have a set village deck and a set wolf deck BEFORE the game (with predetermined numbers of each type of card in it -- so drawing like 5 Breath of Life cards isn't possible), from which each side draws from.

As a spectator who was very glad to die when I did and then decided to ask the mods wtf was going on (not like I was getting brought back anyway) the godfather/shapeshifter combination is pretty much game breaking, I think, and needs to be changed somehow. That's something that I think is basically un-figure-outable from a village perspective, and then it truly is just an absurdist fox hunt and not WW any more.




Would play again.

On a personal note, I'm glad I only sucked half as bad as I thought I did during the game.
Magic The Gathering Mishmash Game thread Quote
01-25-2013 , 03:29 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chilltown
Wolves needed more end game wolves to win this.
So have you gotten to the part of the thread where the village was 50% to lose after I "lost" at f3?
Magic The Gathering Mishmash Game thread Quote
01-25-2013 , 03:29 PM
Both sides feel the game was tipped in the favor of the other side. Means it was pretty balanced imo
Magic The Gathering Mishmash Game thread Quote
01-25-2013 , 03:30 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by SGT RJ
I felt sort of bad that I was sucking up a lot of the good wolf actions (angels, life burst, etc.) but it was so worth it to watch everyone try to kill me like 7x on d3 and fail.

Then give up when I was completely vulnerable (except to the lynch) on d4.
I attacked you on D4, GOAT right here
Magic The Gathering Mishmash Game thread Quote
01-25-2013 , 03:32 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Hurp Durpington
vagos i was really thinking

what'd you do to dseserve this AND burn notice rofl
Don't forget American Rebellion with vixt/noah/wangz and that controversial f4 no lynch ending. I'm at end game for all the classics.

Quote:
Originally Posted by diskoteque
GOGOGOGOGO VAGOS

thanks to the mods - this mustve been a pain in the ass to keep track of.

i played terribly this game but still had a blast. think my only solid read was on scootaloo and he was janitored so i didnt even get to enjoy it. just a super confusing game for me but definitely enjoyed it.
Me not completely standing up to your lynch was prob one of my most disappointing moments in the game. Not that it would have mattered in the grand scheme, but I just knew you were a villager and I still went down the POE like a sheep.
Magic The Gathering Mishmash Game thread Quote
01-25-2013 , 03:32 PM
Nah the shapeshift stuff is great. Wolves need some way to get at least one person "clear" or its just not so good for them - that or plenty of roles to claim etc. Chips is right obv.
Magic The Gathering Mishmash Game thread Quote
01-25-2013 , 03:33 PM
Ghost Shark - crushes the wolves

Peeked lock clear Shark - does not give any ****s about the game

Hmmm
Magic The Gathering Mishmash Game thread Quote
01-25-2013 , 03:34 PM
Anybody else wanna comment on how ****ty it is to completely rail on somebody's play once they die and the game is still ongoing?

Chilly, I gotta call you out man, you do this, A LOT and it is pretty terrible. When somebody dies in the game, your next post doesnt need to be "You are so terrible, I am the best, never play WW again"

Its taking a shot at someone who has absolutely no way of defending themselves, and is pretty awful.
Magic The Gathering Mishmash Game thread Quote
01-25-2013 , 03:34 PM
Yeah Im completely fine with the balance, Im just loling at the wolves who are complaining at the balance when they were guaranteed to make it to f3 by d2.
Magic The Gathering Mishmash Game thread Quote
01-25-2013 , 03:34 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by metsandfinsfan
After 3 Villagers angleshot themself clear and it out it like 3 walls it would have been pretty hilarious if vil actually lost
it spewed about 10 people

the only inaccurate thing from the whole saga was that daisou was not a wolf. i'm still scratching my head about that one.

but you're the one who got yourself in trouble for that so its hard to feel bad
Magic The Gathering Mishmash Game thread Quote
01-25-2013 , 03:36 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by younguns87
Yeah Im completely fine with the balance, Im just loling at the wolves who are complaining at the balance when they were guaranteed to make it to f3 by d2.
As Chips pointed out though, it was unimaginative POEtarding that got me to f3. I never should have gotten there on the merit of my posts.
Magic The Gathering Mishmash Game thread Quote
01-25-2013 , 03:36 PM
Domer A+ ghost
Rollwave, not so much.
Magic The Gathering Mishmash Game thread Quote
01-25-2013 , 03:36 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shark Sandwich
So have you gotten to the part of the thread where the village was 50% to lose after I "lost" at f3?
Have you gotten to the part where it says VILLAGE WINS?

Quote:
Originally Posted by master3004
Anybody else wanna comment on how ****ty it is to completely rail on somebody's play once they die and the game is still ongoing?

Chilly, I gotta call you out man, you do this, A LOT and it is pretty terrible. When somebody dies in the game, your next post doesnt need to be "You are so terrible, I am the best, never play WW again"

Its taking a shot at someone who has absolutely no way of defending themselves, and is pretty awful.
They have their chance to say something now.
Magic The Gathering Mishmash Game thread Quote
01-25-2013 , 03:38 PM
chances that daro ever makes a list again as a wolf are not looking too bright

thenothing was outed immediately
Magic The Gathering Mishmash Game thread Quote
01-25-2013 , 03:38 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by younguns87
Yeah Im completely fine with the balance, Im just loling at the wolves who are complaining at the balance when they were guaranteed to make it to f3 by d2.
that took the absolute perfect storm of events to happen. insanity gets to f3 as a revived villa the majority of the time and you were guaranteed to have a sizeable number of lock clear villas at end game because of the spells available that the wolves really couldnt counter. but to be results oriented it came down to a coin flip so cant complain all that much, though i am really upset that the mod didnt let vagos do it with "if this post is even the village wins, if this post is odd the wolves win"
Magic The Gathering Mishmash Game thread Quote
01-25-2013 , 03:39 PM
i'd say chill ghana chill

and i'll also say try to be a bit nicer chill

i think you've improved tons as a villa

but cooperation, and having the sway and the voice to have people listen to you rather than resent you and spite you by ignoring your reads isn't optimal
Magic The Gathering Mishmash Game thread Quote
01-25-2013 , 03:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JimHalpert
Both sides feel the game was tipped in the favor of the other side. Means it was pretty balanced imo
while playing, i thought it was slightly tipped in favor of the village, but that could have just been run-hot with the rand

and now that i know the shark/amp godfather deal, maybe we didn't run as hot as i thought

thanks again gabe and noah, was very fun. loved my role
Magic The Gathering Mishmash Game thread Quote
01-25-2013 , 03:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by master3004
Anybody else wanna comment on how ****ty it is to completely rail on somebody's play once they die and the game is still ongoing?

Chilly, I gotta call you out man, you do this, A LOT and it is pretty terrible. When somebody dies in the game, your next post doesnt need to be "You are so terrible, I am the best, never play WW again"

Its taking a shot at someone who has absolutely no way of defending themselves, and is pretty awful.
It's completely ****ty.

At the other forum I've played at, Rule #1 is "Thou shalt not speak ill of the dead", and it's pretty seriously enforced.
Magic The Gathering Mishmash Game thread Quote
01-25-2013 , 03:40 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by master3004
Anybody else wanna comment on how ****ty it is to completely rail on somebody's play once they die and the game is still ongoing?

Chilly, I gotta call you out man, you do this, A LOT and it is pretty terrible. When somebody dies in the game, your next post doesnt need to be "You are so terrible, I am the best, never play WW again"

Its taking a shot at someone who has absolutely no way of defending themselves, and is pretty awful.
I agree with this entirely FWIW. It's a kicker taunting a linebacker and then hiding behind multiple big offensive linemen because he knows there reasonably can't be much of a response.

It's bush league.
Magic The Gathering Mishmash Game thread Quote
01-25-2013 , 03:42 PM
[1/18/2013 3:36:11 PM] vixticator: one question pls tell me dkgo wasnt a wolf
[1/18/2013 3:36:15 PM] vixticator: or i will has sad
[1/18/2013 3:36:25 PM] Noah: final answer on resurrection list?
[1/18/2013 3:36:30 PM] vixticator: yep
[1/18/2013 3:36:35 PM] Noah: dkgo woof
[1/18/2013 3:36:42 PM] vixticator: ffffffffffffuuuuuuuu
[1/18/2013 3:36:43 PM] vixticator: omg
[1/18/2013 3:36:52 PM] vixticator: i am so ****ing mad
[1/18/2013 3:36:53 PM] vixticator: lol
[1/18/2013 3:36:59 PM] Noah: i got the popcorn out when you came into the thread and said dkgo right away
[1/18/2013 3:37:09 PM] vixticator: god dammit
Magic The Gathering Mishmash Game thread Quote
01-25-2013 , 03:42 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by master3004
Anybody else wanna comment on how ****ty it is to completely rail on somebody's play once they die and the game is still ongoing?

Chilly, I gotta call you out man, you do this, A LOT and it is pretty terrible. When somebody dies in the game, your next post doesnt need to be "You are so terrible, I am the best, never play WW again"

Its taking a shot at someone who has absolutely no way of defending themselves, and is pretty awful.
yeah people insulting dead players is really annoying


Quote:
Originally Posted by younguns87
Yeah Im completely fine with the balance, Im just loling at the wolves who are complaining at the balance when they were guaranteed to make it to f3 by d2.
i didnt see wolves complaining, mostly saing good game and complimenting the mods. did u play?
Magic The Gathering Mishmash Game thread Quote

      
m