biggerboat, you are a Barrow-wight. You are a shape-shifter. Each night, you may send me one player's name, and if you are peeked by a seer, you will be revealed as that person to the seer. You are part of the neutral team.

Just breaking this down in more detail for myself and for anyone else who might like it

Dead

housenuts (Lynch D1) - Lobelia Sackville-Baggins - good guy - Vanilla-Hobbit
TJT11 (ModKilled N1) - Gorbag - Bad guy - Wolf team?
wahoopride (NK N1) - Sam Gamgee - Good Guy - Hobbit
atakdog (NK N1) - Lotho Sackville-Baggins - Neutral - Hobbit
dkgojackets (NK N1) - Landroval - good Guy - Eagle
ewalsh420 (NK N1) - Rosie Cotton - Good Guy - Vanilla Hobbit
Quadstriker (NK N1) - Nazgul - Bad Guy - Wolf team ?

A.Ertbjerg (Lynch D2) - Faramir - good guy - Vigilante
DanivbDH (suicide D2) - Balrog - bad guy (not wolf) - Suicide bomber
The Evil Polka Man (dead D2) - Celeborn - good guy - Seer
lsc1022 (NK N2) - Gamling - good guy - Vanilla
biggerboat (NK N2) - Barrow-wight - neutral - not wolf
Brian (NK N2) - Bregalad - Good guy - Vanilla Ent with a raspberry swirl

So far 1 nazgul has died, 8 remain
2 of the neutral team have died, x remain ?
8 good guys have died.
A balrog, (suicide bomber, evil faction? )
Gorbag, potential wolf.

62 players left in the game?

Are the nazguls actually the wolves in this game or is there another faction of wolves which are called wolves lurking around somewhere ?

So, now all we have to figure out is if this is the ORIGINAL Ewalsh, or the replacement Ewalsh.

I really wish people would use a DIFFERENT account when subbing back into games. So many people complain about gimmick accounts, yet this is the ONE time that they would be useful.

I got that

Wanting to lynch villas b/c they are a distraction is uber wolfy. This whole post feels like a set up to allow you to back into voting dront. It sets up a passive "I thought he was villa, but he still had to go. Its all his fault." type accusation/reason.

And even a cursory exam of aert role conditions would lead someone to extrapolate why the other villa vigs didnt get a kill last night.

lol

so

fcbl is posting a lot and acting really villagery and am not sure what that means for him but its probably not good

From personal experience, this is true. Eventually you learn to laugh at it.

It happens. But I am guessing Daniv is much less likely to do that than most people.

okay luckbox/dustin needs to be lynched at some point. He's starting to look wolfy imo.

Pyro - you're missing one reason why you, as a wolf, would come out of "comfortable UTRness" and start busing ajertberg.

And Telcontar - want to post analysis instead of rehashing who was killed when and then posting a bunch of questions?

************ VOTE COUNT ************

At #1809

[3] - mcavoy

voters: bsball8806, Chips Ahoy, goofyballer

[2] - pvn (voters: OnThInIcE911, WinEvryRacex)
[2] - pyromaniac (voters: BrownEyedGirl, G1982)
[2] - drontier (voters: Felix the Cat, theHuntContinues)
[2] - aaronk56's son (voters: Mr. Smaug, riverfish1)

[1] - bsball (voters: vuroth)
[1] - ariesram (voters: jonnyd)
[1] - the_gf (voters: AceofSpades)
[1] - onthinice (voters: Kukraprout)
[1] - legend (voters: Luckbox Inc)

half the people voting drontier dont even seem to think he is a wolf but are just saying he will be a wagon every day and a distraction.
guess what? if you stop voting him because of it, he stops being a wagon every day.

I dont get why no one is voting OTI when:
- he is XXSooted's most likely "peek"
- he is lurking and posting no content
- he is lying about never doing it as a wolf

do I answer this?

do you want me to speculate hypotheticals, "if i were a wolf, why i might do this?"

for my post about fcbl?

seriously?

how about you guys start by lynching the wolfiest player in the game and then i'll work on finding some more wolves

Pyro made a well reasoned, pretty logical case on AErt, that just happened to be wrong. That happens. In order to believe that Pyro is wolf, then one of AKS/Dront pretty much has to be. Why would wolf Pyro push AErt in that situation? Since I am pretty suire Dront is village, and I kinda lean villa on AKS, I dont think Pyro is wolf. Plus he has been villagery on tone all game.

kukra,

I have never been able to read OTI in any role. He's too much of a spazzmonkey. I've seen him do stuff that I've said he would never do that as a wolf and I'm seen him do stuff that I thought there is no way villa OTI would ever do that and he was villa.

So I don't really see any point in me doing a re read of him.

ok if you cant read OTI do a reread of XXSooted and vote OTI

Re Dustin: Disagree. He has been vilalgery on tone all game.

If you are talking about Pyro saving wolves, then who was he saving? If you are talking about something else, then I am missing it too.

Agree about Telcontar.

I quoted this post day 1. Nobody repsonded to my thoughts, so here it is again. Clear your mind and read this post. There are many uses of wolf language here.

1) Too much knowledge
2) Extreme use of wolfy words like "probably" and "looks like" and "maybe" and "it is possible"

Reread this, and tell me if this is not so full of wolf, that it should not have been missed by over 60 villagers.

Summary:

Coordi is a wolf

Ewalsh is a confirmed villager (ENT)


COORDI

For some reason, Dustin(Luckbox) usually says this about me. It is generally not related to Dustin's role. He has done this when he is a villager, and when he is a wolf. I can not tone read Dustin, and have given up trying.

yes



and Pyro - sure why not speculate. I wasn't around at eod yesterday and only did a brief skim through but if a wolf was a lead wagon, its very plausible for you, as another wolf, to come out of UTRness and manufacture a reason to wagon ajertberg.

i think you're probably a villager

its just that i would not expect you to be putting a ton of effort into a game of this size, and you are

Reading last night.

This normally would be villagery to call out an utr wolf like this. But given there was a decent chance the wolves knew Daniv would go boom in a little bit, it loses a lot of its luster. Young had to have known assumed that Daniv wasn't really going to fly as a wagon, so this vote feels funny.

I wouldnt be surprised if FCBL is in one of the evil faction, and that he thinks that coordi is in the other evil faction because a lot of his theories are correct

fwiw I had noticed that ewalsh was a tree but thought it was anti village to mention it because he was under no heat anyway and the saruman team might be after trees (especially since they killed brian)

This thread is gong to explode now without post restictions.
Ok, this is mostly for my own reference, but people who are definately left in the game.


In the N1 write up, there was an Black Horse Rider kill, "A group of saurons minions" kill, Uruk-hai kill, Eomer kill, Gimli kill, one poisoner, presumably one failed poisoner.

In the N2 write up, there was a Orc kill, Nazgul kill, Uruk-hai kill, and two poisons.

I would think that "A group of saurons minions" would be the orcs, which would mean that the Nazguls didn't kill anyone N1, and the Black Horse Riders didn't kill anyone N2. Would the evils have alternating night kills?

It is likely that since Faramir was an even night vig, either (or i guess maybe both) Gimli and Eomer is an odd night vig, which explains their absence.

Also, saurons team is doing an excellent job of killing the neutrals for us.