thanks. I've got these two plus BEG and me as four solid villas.

riverfenix is a wolf imo.

he could be
he is very questionny since he came back in the game

Just logged on for the day. To interject some humor, here is how officedog's mind works under stress:

Crap! Craptastic day and now I have to pick up kids and get dinner and HOLY CARP I HAVE TO VOTE OTHERWISE I'LL LET FOLKS DOWN QUICK QUICK QUICK FIRE UP THE LAPTOP!!

*turn on computer, get dinner on stove, deal with several tween-life-emergencies*

Ok, now who do I vote for? What's happened today? I should catch up before I accidentally vote for the wrong person. No, no I don't have time, just use my logic. But what if I'm wrong? What if I vote for the wrong person? NO I DON'T HAVE TIME TO BE YOUR PARENT RIGHT NOW CAN'T YOU SEE I'M MAKING IMPORTANT INTERNET DECISIONS?!?!?!

OK, fine, I can do this. I was looking into that one guy, and that river guy has been bugging me. Just pick someone, OD, it's no big deal. *post*

*stir noodles* *open bag o salad* *answer homework question about the great lakes*

Wait...lakes....rivers...aren't there two rivers in this game? OMG, did I vote the right one? What if I didn't vote the right one? HANG ON EVERYBODY I HAVE A GAMING EMERGENCY.

*repost*

There. I think that's right. OK.

Wait. Is that the right guy? Is that guy even still alive? Where are my notes? SHAT THEY'RE AT WORK ON MY OTHER COMPUTER ZOMG I DON'T KNOW IF THIS IS THE GUY AND WHY IS THE SMOKE ALARM GOING OFF AND THE YOUNGEST ONE CRYING??? Just. Post. Something. Gaaaaaaahhhhhhhh!!!!

**********************
So, yeah, I probably won't be voting again without reading at least some of what happened during the day. Sorry all.

Wait, am I even still alive today? *reads* Oh good, I am.

Man, I suck at this game!

************DEAD**************

Go village!

************DEAD**************

tbh that last minute vuroth wagon last night stunk to high heaven (though I may be a little biased since I knew Tabako was lieing). Only strange thing is no neutral kills. However, the mods never said that the neutrals are out of the game so they may have gone no kill tonight. Whoever manufactured that wagon last night is highly suspect in my book (and hopefully I'll talk the time to go back and reread it today).

I agree. There is no need for this post. I really like RiverFENIX

BEG now is not the time for spite voting. You're better than that and we need your help. You're not being helpful by just parking votes on aces and pushing wagons with little to no analysis. We have 10 days worth of info and you're voting for the weakest of reasons. I don't see why you're being so defensive either since you're not even going to be a wagon anytime soon.

also my OBSERVATION about you coming around the same time of day each day was not a case against you. It was actually a defense.

I have some responsability in this vuroth wagon
but I stay on my stance that lynching tabako would have been bad as he was likely to get NKed at night by wolves even as neutral (which I think is what happened, as umaine is saying that he is not the one behind the theoden NKs)
but the curious thing is that tabako had been the leading wagon all day and that no alternative wagon took off before the vuroth one

imo starting the wagon isnt as bad as hopping on late (which i know i did, but this was bc i was sponging goofy and bc he and kukra made a good point about gollum being possibly NK'd as a neutral)

so yea telcontar doesnt look great with respect to the late hoppers bc of the tone of his post. idk just seems like someone trying a bit too hard to justify their vote and look villagery


tabako started it
scrubbo got on
kukra got on
goofy got on
TL gets on
shelob gets on
jonnyd gets on
umaine gets on
telcontar gets on
riverfenix gets on


heres the vote posts.. although there are more posts concerning the wagon i just didnt quote the whole thing.


i feel like goofy trusted kukra (who made a good point) and then a lot of people who (rightfully) trusted goofy hopped on. i bet tabako/scrubbo were surprised that the vuroth wagon took off as fast as it did.

I think telcontar's vote looks the worse
the part about tabako looks kinda n/n too

Here is how he has been talking about vuroth in this game

he is saying that he is suspicious of him
but in his following lists he is coloring him villa without giving new reasons:
And then when vuroth is starting to get suspected he has him as suspicious again:
inconsistent imo

ok. . . First. . U need a valium. second. . U might b a wolf. All u have done the entire game is coast & tell us how busy, confused, and sucky u r. . . Great cover for a wolf to hide & go unnoticed

fine. . . . Can u look at OFficdog & when i get home tonight we will compare

[2] - riverfenix (voters: Riverfish1, umaine89)
[2] - telcontar (voters: Kukraprout, TimeLady)
[1] - the huntcontinues (voters: shelob)
[1] - thehuntcontinues (voters: jonnyd)
[1] - jonnyd (voters: BrownEyedGirl)

Not Voting: officedog, RiverFenix, Scrubbo, Telcontar, theHuntContinues, Zeturd

interesting vote o****

are you guys for real?



THC BOOK IT!
THC BOOK IT!
THC BOOK IT!
THC BOOK IT!
THC BOOK IT!
THC BOOK IT!
THC BOOK IT!
THC BOOK IT!

I told him claim right now if he isn't (which I think at this point of the game is a good idea)
The guy doesn't claim and just stalls. All he says is how can I be neut/wolf and does absolutely nothing else to defend it.
THC IS DYING TONIGHT! If we fail as a village I hope theoden/eomer can see this.

actually since we arent even sure if theoden is deciding his kills, just have eomer kill THC(if villa fails). that way theoden doesnt double up on one guy and waste us a vig. at this point we are getting like 2.5 villa kills for every 1 non-villa kill. its pretty hard to lose. kill everyone on that list.

I'm a ******:

[2] - riverfenix (voters: Riverfish1, umaine89)
[2] - telcontar (voters: Kukraprout, TimeLady)
[2] - thehuntcontinues (voters: jonnyd, shelob)
[1] - jonnyd (voters: BrownEyedGirl)

Not Voting: officedog, RiverFenix, Scrubbo, Telcontar, theHuntContinues, Zeturd

I need this. Office dog are you going to update this today? I liked the stream of conciousness post, btw.

dont you have some theoden claiming to do? did you nk tabako or no

for beg

NOTES on officedog

villa
has been wolfhunting
took it upon himself to keep the color coded link post updated (this can easily be a reverse tell though)

wolfy
is a bit overdefensive (esp considering he has never been a wagon)


role neutral- or weak but important points:
-is a self-proclaimed noob, so im not really finding his tone to be too reliable, but it has been generally villa
-has played murder mystery games where the dynamics are a bit different to WW and has been misapplying some of the things he does in that game in this game (which may explain why his posts have been a bit off, probably bc he's not used to WW where the villas have little to no info other than their role, where in MMG it seems that the "good guys" have evidence on the bad guys, or thats atleast how he put it)
----that said his naivety towards game mechanics has stayed fairly consistent throughout the gameand dont seem faked (or easily faked) so thats some villa points
-seems to be a bit UTR at times but looks like he is honestly busy but is trying hard to participate (this is villagery, but the UTRness is wolfy so i guess thats why its null)
-def makes a good amt of fluff posts


tbh i think im on the fence, but i think he's villagery enough that he should be low on the lynch list

SUMMARY

Day 1 - Final player list
ANNOUNCEMENT: The story starts. Rules of combat(no N0 actions, DO NOT EDIT POSTS, DO NOT NIGHT POST). Research is recommended.
ANNOUNCEMENT: As regards roleclaiming, special rules.
ANNOUNCEMENT: Day 1 and 2 maximum posts(25 and 30 respectively).
ANNOUNCEMENT: Night at 8 PM EST. Let the mod know what you think about the posting limit. Posting limit stays!

LYNCH 1: housenuts. Votecount. Writeup. TJT1 modkill.

FIRST BATTLE: NKS 5. Dead: Wahoopride, Atakdog, ewalsh, Quadstriker and DKgojackets. Dying: Sun Tzu.

Day 2 - player list
ANNOUNCEMENT: 30 post restriction
ANNOUNCEMENT: Smaug is hungry for more modkills, so watch out.
EVENT: Fellowship leaves Rivendel.
ANNOUNCEMENT: Ewalsh subs for JG.
ANNOUNCEMENT: Smaug is still hungry, dont discuss modkills.
ANNOUNCEMENT: Peoples in danger of modkill.
EVENT: Balrog blowup. Dead: TEPM, DanivbDH. XXsooted was saved by Gandalf. Gandalf was hurt in the process. To be saved by Gwaihir.

LYNCH 2: A.ertjberg. Votecount, writeup and again.

SECOND BATTLE: NKS 3. Dead: lsc1022, biggerboat, Brian. Dying: Felix the Cat, Cadaz, Sun Tzu.

Day 3 - player list
EVENT: Sun Tzu is healed!
EVENT: Gwaihir failed to rescue Gandalf.
ANNOUNCEMENT: Poisoneds: can post and vote, no powers.
ANNOUNCEMENT: Primary mod partially absent for the day. Night falls at 9 PM EST.
ANNOUNCEMENT: Non-posters will be thrown to smaug/subbed out.

LYNCH 3:PVN. Votecount. Writeup.

THIRD BATTLE: NKS 7. Dead: RiverFenix, Aceshigh, FCBLcomish, Drontier, DannyKGB, PointertoVoid, Legend. Dying: Cadaz (Felix the Cat was healed).

Day 4 - player list (not available)
EVENT: Gandalf returns 'the White'.
EVENT: Frodo has reached Mordor.

LYNCH 4: Coordi. Votecount, writeup.

FOURTH BATTLE: NKS 4. Dead: Aceofspades, Diggerthedog, wineveryrace, aaronks son, vayacondios. Dying: Cadaz, last night.

Day 5 - player list (not available)
ANNOUNCEMENT: Double lynch day. Explanation.
ANNOUNCEMENT: Note on the 'in Mordor' stuff.
ANNOUNCEMENT: VCD now comod, espec for votecounts.

LYNCH 5: The_GF and Ewalsh Votecount. Writeup.

FIFTH BATTLE: NKS 5. Dead: Andrex puppy, Bsball, Pyromaniac, OTI, drubell, Cadaz. Dying: keanureaver

Day 6 - playerlist
EVENT: Mcavoy warning, again and modkill. Explanation.
ANNOUNCEMENT: One lynch today, night at 8pm EST sunday.
lsc subs for FelixtheCat
EVENT: Night comes early

LYNCH 6: ElliotR Votecount. Writeup.

SIXTH BATTLE: NKS 3. Dead: Tao1, Willd, Chips Ahoy. Dying: keanureaver

Day 7 - player list
EVENT: Gollum has stolen The One Ring from Merry
ANNOUNCEMENT: Anyone not voting today will be eaten by Smaug
ANNOUNCEMENT: Drontier subs for youngplayer9
ANNOUNCEMENT: Double lynch day. Explanation.

LYNCH 7: Thingyman, J.D. Votecount. Writeup.

ANNOUNCEMENT: DiggerTheDog subs Keanu; RiverFenix subs for Sun Tzu;
G1982's role revealed: you are the Mouth of Sauron. You die when Sauron dies. You cannot be lynched or night killed.

SEVENTH BATTLE: NKS 4. Dead: lsc1022 v2.0, Xxsooted, Luckbox Inc, globetrotter; Dying: DiggertheDog

Day 8 - player list (not available)
EVENT: Regular lynch today. Double lynch tomorrow
EVENT: Saruman and the neutral team have found Gollum! Saruman is in possession on The One Ring! Gollum is now a member of the neutral team!
ANNOUNCEMENT: J.D. subs for G1982

LYNCH 8: essedarius Votecount. Writeup.

EIGHTH BATTLE: NKS 6 . Dead: mflip, BombayBadboy,
Old Man Willow, AriesRam, TehVader, KeanuReaver DiggerTheDog v2.0.

Day 9 - player list
EVENT: double lynch day! 1 list. 2 votes each. 2 people lynched.

LYNCH: Ludovic Banhammer, G1982, semper fidelis Votecount. Writeup.

NINTH BATTLE: NKS 3. ZomgHax,mrs. Jonnyd, Mr. Smaug

Day 10 - player list

LYNCH: Vuroth Votecount. Writeup.

TENTH BATTLE: NKS 2. Tabako, Goofyballer

DAY 11 - player list
(since list is short and embedded in another thread, I'm posting it here today only):
BrownEyedGirl
jonnyd
Kukraprout
officedog
Riverfish1
RiverFenix (subbed for Sun Tzu)
Scrubbo
shelob (subbed for youngplayer9)
Telcontar
TimeLady
theHuntContinues
umaine89
Zeturd

wtf is wrong with people, THC THC THC THC!!

also, umaine can you decide your kill or not. this is getting ridiculous. you gotta communicate wiht us.

Day 1

housenuts - Lobelia Sackville-Baggins (vanilla hobbit) - lynched
TJT11 - Gorbag (lost wolf) - modkilled
wahoopride - Sam Gamgee (hobbit mason w/ Frodo) - Nazgul kill
atakdog - Lotho Sackville-Baggins (neutral hobbit godfather) - Sauron kill
ewalsh420 - Rosie Cotton (vanilla hobbit) - Saruman kill
Quadstriker - a Nazgûl (vote power w/ other Nazguls) - Eomer vig kill
dkgojackets - Landroval (eagle w/ power to save the Ring Bearer from Mount Doom) - Gimli vig kill

Day 2

DanivbDH - Durin's Bane (balrog suicide bomber) - suicide bombed
The Evil Polka Man - Lord Celeborn (elf seer) - suicide bombed
A.Ertbjerg - Faramir (human half vigilante) - lynched
lsc1022 - Gamling (vanilla human) - Sauron kill
biggerboat - Barrow-wight (neutral shape-shifter) - Nazgul kill
Brian - Bregalad/Quickbeam (ent w/ ability to change own vote once) - Saruman kill

Day 3

pvn - Bill Ferny (wolf janitor) - lynched
RiverFenix - Bilbo Baggins (hobbit w/clues about the gameplay) - Sauron kill
xxaceshigh77xx - Tom Bombadil ("eldest being in existence" w/ immunity against The One Ring) - Treebeard kill
FCBLComish - Barliman Butterbur (human half seer) - Saruman kill
Drontier - Elrohir (vanilla elf) - Gimli vig kill
DannyKGB - Gimli (dwarf vigilante) - Eomer vig kill
PointerToVoid - Legolas (elf vigilante w/ power to poison) - Nazgul kill
legend42 - Radagast (Istar wizard vote manipulator) - Warg kill

Day 4

coordi - Frodo Baggins (mason w/ Sam and Ring Bearer) - lynched
AceofSpades - Farmer Maggot (vanilla hobbit) - Éowyn 1-time kill
DiggertheDog - Glorfindel (mason w/ Arwen and race seer) - Saruman kill
WinEvryRacex - Glóin (vanilla dwarf) - Warg kill
Aaronk56's Son - Gwaihir (eagle w/ power to find Gandalf and save the Ring Bearer from Mount Doom) - Nazgul kill
VayaConDios - Théodred (vanilla human) - Galadriel gift receiver kill

Day 5
ewalsh420 v.2 - Treebeard (ent w/ immunity against neutral NK) - lynched
The_GF - The Shadow Lord (Yakuza) - lynched
Andrex Puppy - the Captain of the Southron Army (lost wolf who joins pack at n4) - Eomer vig kill
bsball8806 - Barrow-wight (wolf shape-shifter) - Saruman kill
Pyromaniac - Lady Galadriel (elf gift giver) - Warg + Sauron kill
OnThInIcE911 - Fredegar 'Fatty' Bolger (hobbit who peeks as Frodo) - Nazgul kill
drubell - a Nazgûl (vote power w/ other Nazguls) - Gandalf kill
Cadaz - Prince Imrahil (vanilla human) - poison kill

Day 6
McAvoy - a Nazgûl (vote power w/ other Nazguls) - modkill
ElliotR - a Warg (lost neutral masoned w/ Sharku) - lynched
Tao1 - Éowyn (human w/ 1-time vig kill after n4) - Sauron kill
Willd - Nob (vanilla hobbit) - Nazgul kill
Chips Ahoy - a Nazgûl (vote power w/ other Nazguls) - Saruman kill

Day 7
JD - Shelob (poisons people) - lynch
Thingyman - Gothmog (roleblocker) - lynch
lsc1022 v2.0 - Merry (inherited ring) - neutral kill
Xxsooted - Goldberry (vanilla impervious to ring) - Nazgul kill
Luckbox Inc - Khamul (nazgul race-seer) - vigged by Eomer
globetrotter - nazgul - vigged by Digger

Day 8
essedarius - Nazgul - lynch
mflip - Nazgul (role-blocker) - vigged by Aragorn
Old Man Willow - Grima Wormtongue (protects Saruman from night actions, votebuyer) - killed by orcs
BombayBadBoy - ranger of something - Nazgul kill
AriesRam - Gandalf (seer) - Saruman kill
TehVader - Aragorn (angel, 1-time NK) - neutral Uruk-Hai kill
DiggertheDog v2.0 - Arwen (hobbit angel) - poison

Day 9
Ludovic Banhammer, you are Sauron, the Dark Lord of Mordor -lynched
G1982, you are the Mouth of Sauron.-lynched with auron
semper fidelis, you are Lurtz. - lynched
ZomgHax, you are Saruman the White. - Sauron kill
mrs. Jonnyd, you are the captain of the Corsairs of Umbar. - vigged by Eomer
Mr. Smaug, you are Elladan - vanilla elf - vigged by theoden? (allegedly)

Day 10
Vuroth, you are Gildor Inglorion, a vanilla elf.
Gollum is dead. Tabako
Peregrin Took is dead. Goofyballer, you are Peregrin "Pippen" Took..

36 villas dead. 7 neutrals dead. 19 wolves dead. (if I counted right)