This is most important obviously. I dont know how strong neutrals are, granted they have the ring but their numbers would never be higher than the wolves to start. Clear more villas, lynch more nonvillas.

.

i really doubt neutrals win condition is same as werewolves. they started with way fewer numbers and their won condition has never been posted. we should tread carefully.

tabako - you claim to have figured out Aries' identity the night after he vigged someone, but those posts you quoted are from when Aries basically claimed seer after being roleblocked. Anything from before the rest of us knew?

I don't necessarily disbelieve you, but obviously anything that would, in hindsight, show concretely that you had this knowledge when everyone else did not would help.

There was a group of 3 neutrals in Lost (like a 40-player game) whose win condition was outlasting everyone else. It's not that improbable.

telcontar is generally posting an insane amount of smiley faces, a lot of recaps, but very few reads
he is a good wagon too imo
apparently it's his first game on this site but he played with drubell and vuroth before

VUROTH if you are around what do you think of telcontar in this game?

telcontar
riverfish

kukra can u confirm u did nothing night 4? cuz if tabako is lying, both you and him are dying tomrorow.

tabako have you played in a game with a tracker before?

it is true

Quoted for information on who has The One Ring. Look at the 2nd sentence. Of course, it should say possession OF The One Ring, not on, lol.

the vig kill and him being roleblocked and coming out all happened the same day iirc

i mentioned in my claim post that it was a bit confusing because the vig kill succeeding was at odds with the roleblock claim

yes i played a 9 player game that you modded (iirc), based on a setup from other forum with 2 yaks

i understand that any sort of claim will be met with a little cautiousness, but realize this is not by any means a reasonable claim to fake.

i'll continue to answer all questions

lol ok I guess this one doesnt really count

you realize that someone not visiting strongly indicates that he is not a wolf?
did you post hints about it?

no i didnt realize that, and that was the only game i have played that involved a tracker

are you saying that somebody without a night action is strongly correlated with said person is a villager? I'm not sure I agree with that, at least from what I'm used to in large mishmashes. For example in HP (only other huge mishmash I played) a large number of villagers had night actions, such as peeks to find masonries, etc.

Maybe it would be true of this game in hindsight, but I'm not even sure that is true. Obv I could catch any roleblocker, but how many other evils had night actions that we've seen?

a kill counts as a visit
you seem to be aware of it because it is on that basis that you are saying ludo is sauron

anyway if you have any role that gains info at night, the standard way to play is to leave hints about what you learned to be found by the village when you are dead

why did you follow drontier night 2?

well obviously

but you think if i tracked the target of the nazgul NK i get all 9 names?
or if I track any of the 9 nazgul I would find out that they visited NK target?

that seems wayyyy overpowered if true

I figured they would choose a single person to carry out the NK, that seemed to be standard from other mishsmahes I've played where it mattered (ghostbusters comes to mind as a game where this was emphasized). This would be consistent with tracking mflip with his NK during n7, as he was the only nazgul left he had to be the one chosen to carry out the action.
I also figure sauron has his own NK, as indicated by the writeups where he is the person ordering the kill, and thats why I recieved the track result I did during the last night.

I assume dynamics are that the person he was peeking was role blocked. Did Aries say who this was? They should be considered nonwolf most likely however evils may roleblock one of their own to prevent them from being peeked (assuming roleblocks of the peeked results in no peek for the peeker). That is a slim chance as you'd have to have a candidate that is important enough to use your roleblock on but whose night power isn't worth much. Not usually a good play, so assume nonwolf if Aries left this info.

obviously all the discussion about him being shelob

i got no definitive answer regarding his role as shelob because nobody got poisoned that night

It looks like before OMW died, Saruman couldn't be peeked. lol if Aries peeked Saruman and just assumed he was roleblocked if it didn't go through

really?

I have class soon, but will be back after to answer more questions before EOD.

tabako post an explanation or lolcats. your choice.