Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Harry Potter X: The Reunion - Game Thread Harry Potter X: The Reunion - Game Thread

07-31-2020 , 09:34 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Adam33
luckbox, are you interested in outing any adult wizard checks from the past 2 cycles? it's getting to the point where there are known to be a reasonable number of non-adult woofers left in the pack, given nagini + whoever the other role named in viggo's pm was, but i like having minor % things to help guide me, and it should still be adult wizard -> somewhat >rand w
Toedder is adult wizard.
If I peeked a non-adult I'm probably keeping those people close to vest at this point going forward. But the adults I keep peeking is seriously disheartening.
Harry Potter X: The Reunion - Game Thread Quote
07-31-2020 , 09:34 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NeedMoreManasi
Maybe spend a god damn minute posting about the current game / posts on the page relevant to solving it instead of just responding to random **** about flavor guesses hello??

I want to read you as a villager but you’re making it so close to impossible especially given you said you’d only be around this AM and the two things I feel like you’ve really said are “what’s the shot list for ita1” and luckbox role speculation

Give me something to work w pls
I don't know how to do that, but I'm also trying to enjoy the game and I was thinking last night how LB may be Aragog and it made me chuckle.

I really don't know how to prove to you I'm a villager, I've been saying the same things over and over. I shot Luco based on a Stork read. I voted for Lissa because she seemed wolfy. I voted DMK because of ****ing shortline and now I've been gunning against him the whole time. He's really the only strong read I have but nobody else wants to wagon that for some reason that completely eludes me. I shot JMurder because Chim seems villagery to me.
My reads mean nothing to anyone, so my actions make sense to no one. Every person who has defended me gets ignored and it's because Idk how to please y'all. I literally try to follow the most villagery person I can in each moment but I'm under a microscope.

I finished packing btw. Which I thought would take longer. I'll be around until I leave for the airport. then I'm probs out the rest of the day or phoneposting.
Harry Potter X: The Reunion - Game Thread Quote
07-31-2020 , 09:35 AM
btw i don't know if luckbox ever claimed his spam vig target, but we're not staying alive in this game without treating him as the hopefully unkillable village vigilante, and i hope the rest of you start thinking of the ideal end-game as being one where we try to win alongside him. if he wins solo by killing all the adult wizards, then we can lolmods and move on with our lives, knowing we fought the good fight and eliminated the wolf team against all odds. my 2c, and hopefully your future mindset also
Harry Potter X: The Reunion - Game Thread Quote
07-31-2020 , 09:35 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Uglydelicious
Luckbox, I'm an adult wizard. You have permission to kill me. I'm Ludo Bagman. Village deserves to lose at this point. I'm over it. gg
I'm not killing anyone.
All villages this size are going to deserve to lose. Ship up and get back out there.
Harry Potter X: The Reunion - Game Thread Quote
07-31-2020 , 09:35 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chim17
Zurvan,

Thoughts on Luckbox being responsible for Bigger?

Worst part here, is even if he outright claimed it, I don't even know wtf we can do.

The Luckbox saga should not have gone on this long.
If luckbox is responsible for bigger, it means he's been lying about his role a lot. If that's the case, what are we going to do about it? I don't think it changes our approach to the game, at all. We should have had him the backup vote to ladd, imo, but water under the bridge

There's been a curious lack of checking dead people for peeks; is everyone convinced we're out of seers? Have we even had a regular seer reveal yet?
Harry Potter X: The Reunion - Game Thread Quote
07-31-2020 , 09:35 AM
Maybe Gabe thought we'd get more kills out of ITAs but this is kind of brutal
Harry Potter X: The Reunion - Game Thread Quote
07-31-2020 , 09:35 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chim17
Up until this point this morning I was finally reading you as a villager!
lol you guys are so lost. Just kill me already then and stop talking about it.
Harry Potter X: The Reunion - Game Thread Quote
07-31-2020 , 09:36 AM
Wait so luckbox either started with the elder wand, or killed Ladd and got it from him probably lolz
Harry Potter X: The Reunion - Game Thread Quote
07-31-2020 , 09:36 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Luckbox Inc
I'm not killing anyone.
All villages this size are going to deserve to lose. Ship up and get back out there.
I'm disheartened by this game.
Harry Potter X: The Reunion - Game Thread Quote
07-31-2020 , 09:37 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Luckbox Inc
Toedder is adult wizard.
If I peeked a non-adult I'm probably keeping those people close to vest at this point going forward. But the adults I keep peeking is seriously disheartening.
fair enough. it's disheartening from the perspective of someone trying to believe you ~fully also, for what it's worth, but i've seen more than enough neutrals of dubious win % in my time to shrug anything off at this point in the game
Harry Potter X: The Reunion - Game Thread Quote
07-31-2020 , 09:37 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Uglydelicious
I don't know how to do that, but I'm also trying to enjoy the game and I was thinking last night how LB may be Aragog and it made me chuckle.

I really don't know how to prove to you I'm a villager, I've been saying the same things over and over. I shot Luco based on a Stork read. I voted for Lissa because she seemed wolfy. I voted DMK because of ****ing shortline and now I've been gunning against him the whole time. He's really the only strong read I have but nobody else wants to wagon that for some reason that completely eludes me. I shot JMurder because Chim seems villagery to me.
My reads mean nothing to anyone, so my actions make sense to no one. Every person who has defended me gets ignored and it's because Idk how to please y'all. I literally try to follow the most villagery person I can in each moment but I'm under a microscope.

I finished packing btw. Which I thought would take longer. I'll be around until I leave for the airport. then I'm probs out the rest of the day or phoneposting.
Maybe tell us why you think shortline is a wolf? That'd be a good start
Harry Potter X: The Reunion - Game Thread Quote
07-31-2020 , 09:37 AM
Guess I'm voting shortline99 for like the third straight day
Harry Potter X: The Reunion - Game Thread Quote
07-31-2020 , 09:38 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by wahoopride
Maybe Gabe thought we'd get more kills out of ITAs but this is kind of brutal
And giving out a vanillager role that is so insignificant to the books that nobody believes it could be real. God (Gabe) is laughing at us.
Harry Potter X: The Reunion - Game Thread Quote
07-31-2020 , 09:38 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by chim17
The Luckbox saga should not have gone on this long.
At this point in the game I've killed 3 villagers (Monstrman/Jdalla and Jumpluff who saved himself for CT) and 2.67 wolves-- Phail, I put 2 crucios into Lissa sort of against my own interests as shes non adult, and Ladd.

I'd say that's a fine ratio for the village.
Harry Potter X: The Reunion - Game Thread Quote
07-31-2020 , 09:38 AM
And I think I was right that aao was just running good as hell, unless there is another wolf angel out there in which case we're ****ed
Harry Potter X: The Reunion - Game Thread Quote
07-31-2020 , 09:39 AM
every item that has passed to other players has said so in the pm. if we're getting trolled by redacted flips on stuff like wolf items, then **** us, but the elder wand would be better off in luckbox's hands right now than anyone else's, so SPARKLESHRUG
Harry Potter X: The Reunion - Game Thread Quote
07-31-2020 , 09:39 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by wahoopride
Guess I'm voting shortline99 for like the third straight day
And someone explain to me how this gets ignored every day? Wahoo is on everyone's villager list and somehow his read of shortline means nothing to anybody. >.<
Harry Potter X: The Reunion - Game Thread Quote
07-31-2020 , 09:39 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Luckbox Inc
At this point in the game I've killed 3 villagers (Monstrman/Jdalla and Jumpluff who saved himself for CT) and 2.67 wolves-- Phail, I put 2 crucios into Lissa sort of against my own interests as shes non adult, and Ladd.

I'd say that's a fine ratio for the village.
I mean MrMendes/Jdalla/Jumpluff.
Harry Potter X: The Reunion - Game Thread Quote
07-31-2020 , 09:40 AM
Working on my theory that people who post primarily about themselves and ignore anything in the game that's not solely about them are more likely to be wolves, Wiggles.
Harry Potter X: The Reunion - Game Thread Quote
07-31-2020 , 09:40 AM
would be nice to kill a non outed wolf some day eh?

I'm assuming we still have a vig that just misfired?.. 3 more dead villa
Harry Potter X: The Reunion - Game Thread Quote
07-31-2020 , 09:41 AM
i get the sense that luckbox thinks this is much further from a wolf mech lock than i do, which is unfortunate
Harry Potter X: The Reunion - Game Thread Quote
07-31-2020 , 09:41 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Adam33
every item that has passed to other players has said so in the pm. if we're getting trolled by redacted flips on stuff like wolf items, then **** us, but the elder wand would be better off in luckbox's hands right now than anyone else's, so SPARKLESHRUG
What do you think I use to kill people with? Some wooden spoon from costco?
Harry Potter X: The Reunion - Game Thread Quote
07-31-2020 , 09:41 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Uglydelicious
And giving out a vanillager role that is so insignificant to the books that nobody believes it could be real. God (Gabe) is laughing at us.
That isn't that insignificant of a role and it was a fairly believable claims - Booker just started getting heat because he didn't do anything.
Harry Potter X: The Reunion - Game Thread Quote
07-31-2020 , 09:42 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Luckbox Inc
I mean MrMendes/Jdalla/Jumpluff.
I agree though I'm a little suspicious you've killed more villagers at night. Just too many villagers dying at night even after voldy died.
Harry Potter X: The Reunion - Game Thread Quote
07-31-2020 , 09:42 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Luckbox Inc
At this point in the game I've killed 3 villagers (Monstrman/Jdalla and Jumpluff who saved himself for CT) and 2.67 wolves-- Phail, I put 2 crucios into Lissa sort of against my own interests as shes non adult, and Ladd.

I'd say that's a fine ratio for the village.
I get it, it just becomes increasingly difficult to deal with you as the game goes on. It's probably why we just have to let you do your thing at this point.

-

I'll be firing in ITA1. In laws quarantine time ended and they are coming down to meet grandbaby this weekend, so super unlikely I'm around for ITA2 or EOD (but I will at least be sure to come vote).
Harry Potter X: The Reunion - Game Thread Quote

      
m