Ok so if Silman was strong in duels before he's probably literally unbeatable now.

Still hanging around and watching TV. I agree with both of these to some extent.

I had it around 75/25 for Silman originally, but I would up it to somewhere around 85/15 given the wolves want him dead.

I'm going to be mostly lurking keeping an eye out for ITAs, but I plan to spend real time around here at some point.

TL gimme your read of me.

I'm not 100%. Easy way to get village points, to kill an outted wolf. I did the same last game (killed a resurrected wolf digger with a bomb) and didn't get clear for it.

I'm not...1000% sure of Duck. I don't think it's lock, I think it's like Larry. Very veyr unlikely, but possible.

Also, if you think I'm a lock villager, then Quadstriker is a lock villager.

hotwings needs to die

not against a.ert dying or crossnerd either.

Those would be my top 3.

I am on board with crossnerd, hotwings, pfal and wahoo more than the others.

not peeks, just reads/feelings

what makes you say this?

I find one thing more convincing than this.

I'll let TL come up with it - or I'll find it myself.

wait what?

missed that antioch peverell died

prophet reporter should get arrested for libel imo

derwipok I believe has been villagery, but he is an exceptionally good wolf so hmmph.

Oh, that reminds me, I had a thought about Younguns earlier. It would take some research though and I'm not entirely sure it's pro-village to reveal what I think may be the case (plus I can't be certain it's correct). In fact, it almost certainly isn't correct. Nevermind, heh.

I'm good with most of this list, but if I were to put it in order I'd move wahoo to the back of the list solely because of bsball's fake-peek of him before he got killed.

also not sold on silman being villa
not trusting his claim of being peeked until we resolve jjhender

and just because he offers to shoot or duel anyone we want, not clearing him for that either. if he gets stronger with kills, he's not going to care WHO he kills.

def not on my top list aorn but still don't trust

**********NOT IN THE GAME*****************

Congrats TheNothing on getting a Sickle, I have been wondering if you would get one since you have the most posts. I enjoyed watching you miss every time

**********NOT IN THE GAME*****************

Hey, just caught up with the thread, so we have a 1 day weekend?.

I am a non wizard too, but now I see people can fire blank spells, I will fire a blank spell at whoever you guys decide during an ITA.

How many ITA's during the weekend, 3 or 6??.

An assumption that MB started with the elder wand, was never successfully disarmed and Silman killed him, which would mean Silman is now the rightful owner of the wand.

So I should have advocated for neutering the wolf dayvig?

Yeah I like FPS, but that's just plain stupidity..

Hiya Fnord. Did you see my post above (apologies if you've replied to it and I missed it?). I really liked the work you did last night.

Also I'm flattered you think my villa/wolf games are indistinguishable. I disagree with you there, but a lot of people who have played with me for the first time seem to have thought the same as you. I only have one long wolf game to go off here though, so it's difficult to have much evidence.

They're my top 3 too, the question marks are the ones I least want to die. Aksdal seemed convinced that CQ was a villager, and most of his reads have been spot on this game. In fact, I'm just about ready to take CQ off the list just for that reason.

Hmm, I felt like PFAL was spewed villa very early (in Hoya's video). Wahoo I'm unsure about.

I'm also unsure about Derwi, but I'm also not at all familiar with his game.

I agree with silman not being villa.

I remember everyone talking about how no one was supposed to ITA JimHalpert so we could have a lynch candidate for concensus. Then Silman comes in and is like Jim I like you wanna see you go out with a bang, lets duel. Wtf?. That's so anti village.

He's a neutral or a wolf still seriously (less likely obviously because of the paper), he's acting the same way necro did earlier. He also claimed to be just shotting villas, and loved duels.

I see we have a number of uncleareds in the thread.
Timelady, what do you think of the idea of me going back to my duelling pewpew ways?

1. - oh, ok. That makes sense because I would have hoped to catch Aksdal posting a peek, but mac cant go 10 posts without dropping a fake peek.

2. anyone have the details?

3. I was pretty out of it by the time I got that far down the list

4. This gives me a great idea!

Great Idea Time:

jjhender should put together the following table, which we will help him build.

For every character left, link in the main case on them. How we help is we just pull the case summary together (may just be quoting a post that already has it so he can get the link easily, or MQ a few good posts on the subject, or something like that) So I see his table like:

.
.
.
MJW - villa lean - Link <to summary post of MJW discussion/analysis
.
.
.


It seems like people really prefer in thread tables, and jj is pretty good at those.

I can certainly update the tables I did last night. I will make a basic spreadsheet to help me with nicer tables, because I was definitely doing some things the hard way last night.

But right now I need coffee.

I killed like 3 outed wolves in HP3 as a wolf.

hi wolf

Yeah, agreed. Somebody clear should fix the list and make it pretty. I think Wahoo and CQ at least should be taken off for now though.



Awesome

This is completely true. derwi scares the hell out of me. The only reason I wouldn't have him higher on the POE list is because of how spazzy Wizard-50 was during the practice ITAs. It didn't seem likely to me that he would be a wolf.