Gunfight at the POG Corral
03-13-2011
, 01:55 AM
i totally forgot about that [at the time it looked like jonnyd could have powered kwami's armor]
def. loooks bad for kwami.
03-13-2011
, 01:59 AM
im not even rereading birdpoker bc i know afterwards (when i got to the thread) he didn't push me at all. he even at one point said his shot on me was based on bad logic.
soooooo.....
if CDL really didn't have the villa gun yesterday, it's likely one of Jonny/Vuroth/Birdpoker had it
and based on their reactions post "peek"...it's likeliest that kwami=wolf (or alice=villa)
soooooo.....
if CDL really didn't have the villa gun yesterday, it's likely one of Jonny/Vuroth/Birdpoker had it
and based on their reactions post "peek"...it's likeliest that kwami=wolf (or alice=villa)
03-13-2011
, 01:59 AM
And now I see what you were saying about seers, alice. Of the people who shot, gotcha.
03-13-2011
, 02:06 AM
03-13-2011
, 02:42 AM
i kinda like the TL = wolf seer theory.
ps: chips wasn't hugely against my theory. i was mistaken.
but check out the HUGE ****ING REACTION i get from Esse/JD/TL:
this is from last night, in order:
ps: chips wasn't hugely against my theory. i was mistaken.
but check out the HUGE ****ING REACTION i get from Esse/JD/TL:
this is from last night, in order:
Quote:
just got in and have a lot ot catch up on, but:
i dont know if it's been mentioned, but when i left at 2pm, we were already at numbers where it's providing wolf cover if we keep shooting.
there should be cease fire from now on. i hope you understand what i'm getting at (and how the more ppl that shoot, the harder it is to find wolves)
i dont know if it's been mentioned, but when i left at 2pm, we were already at numbers where it's providing wolf cover if we keep shooting.
there should be cease fire from now on. i hope you understand what i'm getting at (and how the more ppl that shoot, the harder it is to find wolves)
Quote:
but you know what im saying right?
everytime someone shoots and it results in "no effect" in the thread, that person goes into an auto wolf suspect pool.
keep the pool small/manageable imo.
also, saying this now can put pressure on the wolf seer and wolf IllQ holders. they need to take a shot today to have any benefit of their guns.
if they haven't taken their shot already, tough ****.
don't give them anymore cover to take it!
everytime someone shoots and it results in "no effect" in the thread, that person goes into an auto wolf suspect pool.
keep the pool small/manageable imo.
also, saying this now can put pressure on the wolf seer and wolf IllQ holders. they need to take a shot today to have any benefit of their guns.
if they haven't taken their shot already, tough ****.
don't give them anymore cover to take it!
Quote:
no no no. There are 11 wolves. Villagers dropped like flies. We need to even the score. Someone needs to shoot rebonk.
@ hifi. It was his placing on TheDean's lists. He looks like he was grouping people together.
Also im going to go look at the wagons yesterday when Rebonk had the lead.
@ hifi. It was his placing on TheDean's lists. He looks like he was grouping people together.
Also im going to go look at the wagons yesterday when Rebonk had the lead.
Quote:
Alice and HiFi, call me stupid but I dont get it.
Lets say the village has seer guns/vig guns and can only post in the evening, you want to deprive them of a chance of helping the village?
FWIW, I havent shot yet, but the reason is because I wanted more info at my disposal before I did, since I hadnt read much of D1.
I do plan on shooting. its why I signed up for this monster game. And its why all I can do is laugh and shake myhead at CDL, who wants to turn every mish-mash with guns into a vanilla game.
Cliffs:I am shooting. dont like it, tough patootie.
Lets say the village has seer guns/vig guns and can only post in the evening, you want to deprive them of a chance of helping the village?
FWIW, I havent shot yet, but the reason is because I wanted more info at my disposal before I did, since I hadnt read much of D1.
I do plan on shooting. its why I signed up for this monster game. And its why all I can do is laugh and shake myhead at CDL, who wants to turn every mish-mash with guns into a vanilla game.
Cliffs:I am shooting. dont like it, tough patootie.
Quote:
lol esse and TL
those are not "villa vig and seer" those are "ppl with guns"
the villa vig and seer should not feel like it's THEIR gun. it's expected to be taken from them at night.
the villagers are EXPECTED to steal those guns tonight. otherwise, are you just going to let the wolves steal from the "no effect" villas???
wat
those are not "villa vig and seer" those are "ppl with guns"
the villa vig and seer should not feel like it's THEIR gun. it's expected to be taken from them at night.
the villagers are EXPECTED to steal those guns tonight. otherwise, are you just going to let the wolves steal from the "no effect" villas???
wat
Quote:
Ok, say in your example, you have 10 players and 2 are wolves. 2 are the villa vig and seer.
That night, the wolves will steal from THE EIGHT REMAINING PLAYERS.
Do you really think it's worth giving the wolves AN EXTRA VIG AND PEEK and denying the village it's VIG AND PEEK just so you can find TWO WOLVES?
That night, the wolves will steal from THE EIGHT REMAINING PLAYERS.
Do you really think it's worth giving the wolves AN EXTRA VIG AND PEEK and denying the village it's VIG AND PEEK just so you can find TWO WOLVES?
Spoiler:
Quote:
jd - im not saying everyday ldo.
im saying TODAY.
we have a chance today to forfeit a potential peek and vig and in exchange gain a seriously reduced wolf suspect pool
all villagers should be trying to steal for the guns of the "no effect" anyway - because that's what wolves are doing
im saying TODAY.
we have a chance today to forfeit a potential peek and vig and in exchange gain a seriously reduced wolf suspect pool
all villagers should be trying to steal for the guns of the "no effect" anyway - because that's what wolves are doing
Quote:
isnt it just as likely that the wolves have or have not shot as the villagers with the same weapons?
your case if pretty much exactly =rand if you assume the weapons are equally dispersed villa/wolves.
and the wolves know who they are which puts us way behind in that regard.
your case if pretty much exactly =rand if you assume the weapons are equally dispersed villa/wolves.
and the wolves know who they are which puts us way behind in that regard.
Quote:
lol monumental theory.
i didn't realize it till i was at work. i exported teh posts from about 11am-2pm so i could look over the shooting stats at work.
and try to deduce things (like hifi/mets can't have the same gun; any pair shooters could be govida+wolf; all no effects can be w/w doubling up)
i didn't realize it till i was at work. i exported teh posts from about 11am-2pm so i could look over the shooting stats at work.
and try to deduce things (like hifi/mets can't have the same gun; any pair shooters could be govida+wolf; all no effects can be w/w doubling up)
Quote:
Ok, from a wolf POV, I absolutely think that the wolf seer/vig would have taken their shot very early today, perhaps as soon as they got itt. Esecpailly the wolf seer (since if their killed they still have the info they needed). Villagers are going to be more inclined to wait until the end of the day when more info has arisen.
So I think that atm you're just hindering any village PRs that haven't shot yet with very little tradeoff in terms of actually finding wolves
So I think that atm you're just hindering any village PRs that haven't shot yet with very little tradeoff in terms of actually finding wolves
03-13-2011
, 02:42 AM
ok
03-13-2011
, 02:47 AM
So you got a discombobulation pm?
