Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
The Genius Mishmash -- January 25th Game Thread The Genius Mishmash -- January 25th Game Thread

01-25-2016 , 09:14 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by mucksandgravs
He had some villagery posts, but I'm not sold on calling him a villager at this point

I feel like this lynch is a crapshoot
qb has very good toan as a wolf imo but its his lack of wim.game solveyness that makes me wanna lean wolf more than anything
The Genius Mishmash -- January 25th Game Thread Quote
01-25-2016 , 09:14 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thingyman
Well, for me it's that he has made about 20 posts and none of them are villagery. That's basically it. Plus the fact that I don't like voting for some of the other wagons - namely, I am no longer sure about voting baudib or bopolis. I still think Moocher is super duper wolfy on tone, but people are telling me he's a villager because of the Main Match, so I'll just defer to those people's judgment for today on that.
(insert appropriate emoticon/gif here)
The Genius Mishmash -- January 25th Game Thread Quote
01-25-2016 , 09:15 PM
Do I actually need to quote JJB's posts? you lazies can't do it yourself?
The Genius Mishmash -- January 25th Game Thread Quote
01-25-2016 , 09:15 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jcohen
i wouldn't have to read any of the thread to be able to look at a d1 tally consisting of AoS and Freddy in the lead to be able to tell you its bad
but me getting lynched is preferable?

there is no possible way you believe this and your posting has been garbage all day wrt me, you have to be a wolf
The Genius Mishmash -- January 25th Game Thread Quote
01-25-2016 , 09:15 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kaze13
Haven't read many of his posts, but I thought him transferring his garnets away when he was lead wagon was villagery. Thingy confirmed having received one.
Two. He sent me two.

And I agree that that is slightly villagery, especially when coupled with him then suddenly reversing his read on me and having me as one of his top wolves after having sent me garnets. Seems bizarre from a wolf.

He can't go on THE LIST, but I am still very much against a QB lynch.
The Genius Mishmash -- January 25th Game Thread Quote
01-25-2016 , 09:15 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jcohen
i legit almost fell out of my chair at this
really? he wrecked like 6 wolves in a row in the cartoon mash. was impressive af.
The Genius Mishmash -- January 25th Game Thread Quote
01-25-2016 , 09:15 PM
Apoc you say that, but thats different than Ace?
The Genius Mishmash -- January 25th Game Thread Quote
01-25-2016 , 09:15 PM
Freddy is not villagery.

Ace is wolfy.


Yes, the distinction is important
The Genius Mishmash -- January 25th Game Thread Quote
01-25-2016 , 09:15 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by dLGN
just saw zyde pointed out this post. stork - did you ever explain it?

this kind of pings me because apoc, who I haven't really liked, was very sensitive to the fact that I accidentally deleted stork from my townlist in one of the updates I did. idk if he's been suspecting him or is just trying to link the two of us but yeah. tinfoil had me think that is something he'd want to use against me should stork be a wolf.
i read ~4 of his posts and thought he was a villager.
there isn't much more to explain than that (hence: soul).
The Genius Mishmash -- January 25th Game Thread Quote
01-25-2016 , 09:15 PM
Who are we ghana CFD, mooch?
The Genius Mishmash -- January 25th Game Thread Quote
01-25-2016 , 09:15 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Stork..
i hope more people (including monte) read this post.
I am astonished.
The Genius Mishmash -- January 25th Game Thread Quote
01-25-2016 , 09:15 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by StuckinARutt
Do I actually need to quote JJB's posts? you lazies can't do it yourself?
this isn't helping a case against JJB
The Genius Mishmash -- January 25th Game Thread Quote
01-25-2016 , 09:16 PM
I actually did some work

quick review of JJB's posts reveal a whole lot of nothing.

arguably role neutral.

carry on.
The Genius Mishmash -- January 25th Game Thread Quote
01-25-2016 , 09:16 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kaze13
Haven't read many of his posts, but I thought him transferring his garnets away when he was lead wagon was villagery. Thingy confirmed having received one.
hmm interesting this makes me wanna tinfoil bad but too tired to think about this atm def noted tho
The Genius Mishmash -- January 25th Game Thread Quote
01-25-2016 , 09:16 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mor_Tilt4mePls
why has qb lost steam? has he gotten better?
he made a few decent posts
The Genius Mishmash -- January 25th Game Thread Quote
01-25-2016 , 09:17 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thingyman
Two. He sent me two.

And I agree that that is slightly villagery, especially when coupled with him then suddenly reversing his read on me and having me as one of his top wolves after having sent me garnets. Seems bizarre from a wolf.

He can't go on THE LIST, but I am still very much against a QB lynch.
Ah I didn't realize he sent you two.

Yeah I don't wanna lynch him today due to that.
The Genius Mishmash -- January 25th Game Thread Quote
01-25-2016 , 09:17 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by dLGN
just saw zyde pointed out this post. stork - did you ever explain it?

this kind of pings me because apoc, who I haven't really liked, was very sensitive to the fact that I accidentally deleted stork from my townlist in one of the updates I did. idk if he's been suspecting him or is just trying to link the two of us but yeah. tinfoil had me think that is something he'd want to use against me should stork be a wolf.
I accused you of making up your reads.

You randomly lost a townread between your lists


Good recap
The Genius Mishmash -- January 25th Game Thread Quote
01-25-2016 , 09:17 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Moocher
but me getting lynched is preferable?

there is no possible way you believe this and your posting has been garbage all day wrt me, you have to be a wolf
I will say one thing

At this point, I don't think there is any way that not one of you and jcohen are a wolf

So if you're the villager, then jcohen is indeed very likely a wolf

I don't think he should be able to defend both AOS AND Freddy here. It seems wild.
The Genius Mishmash -- January 25th Game Thread Quote
01-25-2016 , 09:17 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by mucksandgravs
Why?
its funny that you're asking me to elaborate considering when i asked why he's lead wagon, you simply said "Because he's been one of the least villagery people in the thread"
The Genius Mishmash -- January 25th Game Thread Quote
01-25-2016 , 09:17 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by mucksandgravs
Who are we ghana CFD, mooch?
JJB atm and see what shakes out, then we'll swoop around a bit hopefully but it's taking me ages to refresh the page so i may have to go early
The Genius Mishmash -- January 25th Game Thread Quote
01-25-2016 , 09:18 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thingyman
Two. He sent me two.

And I agree that that is slightly villagery, especially when coupled with him then suddenly reversing his read on me and having me as one of his top wolves after having sent me garnets. Seems bizarre from a wolf.

He can't go on THE LIST, but I am still very much against a QB lynch.
I did not know this. I like this.

unvote
The Genius Mishmash -- January 25th Game Thread Quote
01-25-2016 , 09:18 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thingyman
Why do you think this? Any particular posts? Please quote them or refer clearly to their contents.
gosh it doesn't seem like anyone is capable of doing this to show he's a wolf. you would think the burden would be on them, and not on me for thinking he's a villager
The Genius Mishmash -- January 25th Game Thread Quote
01-25-2016 , 09:18 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thingyman
I will say one thing

At this point, I don't think there is any way that not one of you and jcohen are a wolf

So if you're the villager, then jcohen is indeed very likely a wolf


I don't think he should be able to defend both AOS AND Freddy here. It seems wild.
I don't get it
The Genius Mishmash -- January 25th Game Thread Quote
01-25-2016 , 09:18 PM
YG, I need 3 garnets.
The Genius Mishmash -- January 25th Game Thread Quote
01-25-2016 , 09:18 PM
vc?
The Genius Mishmash -- January 25th Game Thread Quote

      
m