bigger kaze was pushing iver yesterday?

So, with all of that here is where I am.

We have at least 2 wolves left and 4 candidates. So they can't all be villagers.

Plusses and minuses

The thoughts and opinions of this post are solely those of biggerboat and should not etc. etc.

JD

+ killed a wolf and shot at another
+ has a claim
+ in his villager range
- claim is shady
- in his wolf range

iamnaww

+ solid work late game
+ good claim backed up by comments
- 2 village watchers?

kruze
+ I have no clue
- didn't bring wim
- hasn't really made cases on anyone

kaze
+ very active
+ game solvy
+ shot wolf
- shot villager
- weird iversonion stuff

i don tthink kaze has been game solvey at all. nor has he been very active

Also keep in mind Gamer was a lost stark. However, looking back at the progression of JD with gamer (AKA no progression), it would very well make sense that JD is the dragon Big Bad whose team peeked Gamer(the odd stark vig) and took out the killpower under the guise of killing a wolf

.

and furthermore, this is very congruent with his intermittent bursts of posting. Though he's sounded pure I'm willing to look passed that. The fact that he hadn't even mentioned gamer at all to that point, then suddenly he mentions gamer as a top 3 shot, then shoots him, doesn't feel like the deliberate villager JD at all. Reeks of agenda AKA the dragon big bad who had peeked gamer

what do you think about my posts about JD bigger? Do you not find his sudden infatuation and subsequent shot at gamer (no progression) odd?

his point against being a targ was he voted for mucks. let's see if mucks was already outed

I won't argue the early slank but the posting before EOD is completely out of my control. 2p2 is blocked at work.

I just got the phone app today but sheesh, it is painful to use.

i just want to nail a wolf at lunch and reeval tomorrow. too much to ask for or what

I just realized that the wolf factions are about equal sized. Derp

sorry for asking but who is the "another wolf"?

Also, what part of his game is in his wolf range? I'm very keen on hearing this given you have a lot of experience with him and you said his tone was pure too

good iver, can you read 10879 and 10881 for me? Then look at the lead up to J.D.'s shot on gamer. I think he's been given far too much credit for that result only

I can't argue against this.

I have a confession. I shouldn't really judge JD. What's that term? conflict of interest?

We go way back and are good friends. I pushed him hard late in one game (long time ago - he probably doesn't remember) and got him mislynched and we lost the game. Felt bad about it ever since. But it also means (to me) that although he can look really wolfy at endgame it doesn't necessarily make him a wolf.

reading jd's early game and he's making singular posts and absolute reads way too lightly

he shot at disko

Votes from post 10604 to post 10891
Night in 1:59:56
---

Votes	Lynch	Voters
3	J.D.	iamnotawerewolf (38), mexineil (24), KruZe (25)
3	iamnotawerewolf	J.D. (3), iversonian (29), Kaze13 (54)
1	KruZe	Outed Wolf (91)
1	not voting	biggerboat (18)

do you remember how he plays as a villager in mishmashes bigger? I've always thought he was deliberate and healthily suspicious. i dont see it here

I am definitely feeling it in my bones. J.D. is the last targ

the question is did he actually 'rep' the ben peek 'hard'?

I've seen him play like this. He's a family guy and a lot of times he just doesn't read a lot.

I really think I could go either way with him. Shooting 2 wolves, though....

kruze

I might let if flip if it stays like this

hopefully jd gets in thread

jd, if you show up, link us to your last wolf game

so could it be that the targs peeked quick ben? Quick ben was a PR stealer. Relatively strong wolf. I'm not sure if it's worth repping that peek to get him killed though. i guess it wouldn't hurt his village cred

don't think of it in that term. Remember this is a multi faction game. Here's what I believe to be the correct narrative.

1. Gadarene pushes QuickBen, the baratheon PR. Gad gets got but JD piggybacks a bit and makes it his peek
2. JD barely mentions gamer but then blasts gamer, the lost stark odd vig. a very powerful PR. My theory was that they had peeked him somehow. But bloobird the targ wolf has been dead since day 1. My hunch is still that they'd peeked gamer somehow regardless, saw that he was an odd vig, and rather than RB+NK him they just took the opportunity to blast him in broad daylight and get some villa credit in the mean time
3. JD's "Botched" claim
4. JD shot at disko

seems like JD may be the targ big bad, and one that has seer power himself. I don't think i'm forcing anything too much here - i think it is plausible

I really shouldn't theorize like this. gotta finish rereading JD in full first