Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014)

11-10-2014 , 05:36 PM
Also, whoever killed Hoya is bad and should feel bad
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 05:36 PM
meh I think this Robik thing could be a huge distraction

I'm more interested in looking up Bloobird because a lot of us were calling him a wolf very early, off the top of my head:

me, Redd, CT, ChrisV

maybe others
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 05:36 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Stark Sandwich
Literally no reason that I can think of to claim that cphoya shot as a wolf imo
Quote:
Originally Posted by Stark Sandwich
and gad should know this
probably no reason to claim if he's familiar with the lore

if he doesn't know that the flavor has outed his character, i don't see why it would be impossible for a wolf to decide to claim in that spot
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 05:37 PM
The nothing. Obviously you didn't want to lose your night powers. Obviously you sent effen at me to either kill me or distract me.

Can anyone confirm the nothing denied my challenge and has lost his night powers?
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 05:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gadarene


we do know there's a Stark faction, though, so saying there shouldn't be one seems moot
Yeah but we don't know if its just the Bran faction or if it includes Arya/Sansa. In the show there is the Bran group of five. Arya is with the Hound and Sansa is at King's Landing and the Riverlands. Arya thinks Bran is dead Sansa thinks Arya and Bran is dead. Bran probably doesn't know anything about the whereabouts of Arya and Sansa. Arya and Sansa don't have to be part of the Stark faction. Sansa could be part of whatever faction includes, Littlefinger, Lysa and Robin and Arya could be a serial killer duo with the Hound. Leaf, the One Eyed Crow or a book only character could round out Bran's "Stark" faction.
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 05:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheNothing
UofU keeps saying i'm bad at this game

it's like he keeps saying it over and over again to make it true but it won't

idiot
I think you're bad enough to have slipped with the cripple thing given the hodor thing.

I also think you're bad at the game generally and overly emotional.

Hope that clears things up.

Looking forward to the white knights coming to defend your honor.
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 05:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Stark Sandwich
Literally no reason that I can think of to claim that cphoya shot as a wolf imo
why would he claim it ever?

like, no one knew who shot hoya. why did he claim it at all? no matter what his affiliation?
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 05:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Xaro Von Ducksauce
Robik: why did you yolo that Hoya shot?

skimmed your posts and i saw you talking about blasting UofU, but then you didn't

(also UofU is one of the few ppl who has seemed villagery to me so far, so )
UofU sounded villagery so I didn't shoot him. That's why I said "please don't challenge/threaten me " because I got the impression that we were both villagers.
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 05:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Krayz
Tyrells, Martell, Lannisters and Boltons are villagers to prevent any angleshooting. Obviously don't talk about the characters of yourself or someone else.
Let's maybe pay attention to this? esp the bolded
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 05:38 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Stark Sandwich
We know he's not a villager because the village groups/houses/whatever you want to call them were stated explicitly in the OP and he does not belong to any of them unless the game designers went completely off the reservation
lol

wat

if Jon Snow is never a villager, then Robik is never a villager

because Jon Snow is the person who shot Robik

but you just called me wolfy for thinking that a wolf would ever claim that shot

so what the **** are you talking about
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 05:38 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheNothing
seriously don't know why i stick around this place


okay let me ask my "accusers" who can search for if i have ever said the word cripple in a game before...

do you know me to be a signaler? have i ever tried to signal anyone about anything in a game before?

if you can find that happening ever, i'll self-vote and stop posting.
Someone already commented you said it 3 times in this game, and once before... ever.

Please to be self-voting now.
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 05:38 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Stark Sandwich
How does robik claiming the shot indicate his character?
because the flavor is character-determinative

are you saying that he's lying about taking the shot?
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 05:38 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Quick_Ben
The nothing. Obviously you didn't want to lose your night powers. Obviously you sent effen at me to either kill me or distract me.

Can anyone confirm the nothing denied my challenge and has lost his night powers?
or i have a power of 2 or something like that. i'm a wolf for not wanting to die day1.

your challenge was not accepted in the rand so you didn't actually get chosen to fight. i'd have refused it anyway.
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 05:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by IAmRobik
UofU sounded villagery so I didn't shoot him. That's why I said "please don't challenge/threaten me " because I got the impression that we were both villagers.
and the Hoya yolo?

are you a gimmick or newish?
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 05:39 PM
Targaryans will prolly be the two claimants to the throne Danaeyrs, the knight with him, prolly a slave fighter, her brother - maybe the blind targaryan in the black watch - prolly some mercenary fighters.

Stark will be - the mother, Nedd, all the boys, Hodor, maybe a direwolf, prolly jon snow, Lil John , arya, sansa

Wildlings will be the ygritte mance a giant , the redd headed dude

Dorne - dudes the guy who poisons and kills the mountain - the ones who come for the wedding

Baratheon: ghey brother, stern brother, dead king? Red woman, the ex-pirate, his sons, perhaps a weird vagmonster

Lannisters: tyrion, tywin, cersei, bronne, shae, mountain, knights
Martells : weird psycho woman, her kid,
Tyrells margery, her ghey brother, her mother


Unknowns: spider, deathcult shapeshifter, little finger
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 05:39 PM
jfc what an idiot
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 05:39 PM
Explanation:

IANAWW made a very strong case on Bloobird being a wolf. He was right. Now, normally, good job. This is IANAWW we talkin' bout though. I haven't played in a while, so if IANAWW is suddenly a lucid, analytic player then let me know. Otherwise, I am skeptical. And, yes, I do think he would bus early. I've seen him do it.
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 05:39 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by DiggertheDog
Jon snow will be a wolf always - he was a lost wolf in last game.

He is never a villager.
He was a lost wolf with the Wildlings because he was traveling with the Wildlings for the majority of the season. Who is he a wolf with here? Is he going to forsake his vows to head North and find Bran? Is he going to go back and apologize to Ygritte? Or is the Night's Watch a wolf faction?
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 05:39 PM
whatever, i'm going to assume at this point that people are just ****ing with me because they think it's funny and move on
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 05:40 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheNothing
why would he claim it ever?

like, no one knew who shot hoya. why did he claim it at all? no matter what his affiliation?
I see no reason to claim it at all, but i really see no reason to claim it as a wolf

Unless maybe he both knew that taking the shot and then claiming it would both out his role AND he knows that someone is looking for him or can maybe find him based on the flavor, which seems far fetched
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 05:41 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by DiggertheDog
Targaryans will prolly be the two claimants to the throne Danaeyrs, the knight with him, prolly a slave fighter, her brother - maybe the blind targaryan in the black watch - prolly some mercenary fighters.

Stark will be - the mother, Nedd, all the boys, Hodor, maybe a direwolf, prolly jon snow, Lil John , arya, sansa

Wildlings will be the ygritte mance a giant , the redd headed dude

Dorne - dudes the guy who poisons and kills the mountain - the ones who come for the wedding

Baratheon: ghey brother, stern brother, dead king? Red woman, the ex-pirate, his sons, perhaps a weird vagmonster

Lannisters: tyrion, tywin, cersei, bronne, shae, mountain, knights
Martells : weird psycho woman, her kid,
Tyrells margery, her ghey brother, her mother


Unknowns: spider, deathcult shapeshifter, little finger
Have you even seen the fourth season? Many of those characters are dead and you're leaving out other more prominent characters?
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 05:41 PM
Spent the last 30 mins reading the last few hundred posts, and I am just confused....but here are my thoughts.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gadarene
with no n0 actions, i don't understand anyone choosing Hoya to kill
Really Gad? Why would anyone want Hoya dead? Maybe cuz he is a great WW player who someone has meta of being read well by Hoya

Quote:
Originally Posted by UofU2010
Meh, TheNothing

I think there really is something to the cripple thing. Just like there was something to the "hodor" thing.
I agree with this but...

Quote:
Originally Posted by KruZe
even if TheNothing is a wolf she has value for the village by her chart making skills alone

she is someone that we can consider to kill 3-4 days into the game after the majority of charts are established
Yes!

With that, I am here to post in real time
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 05:41 PM
i want someone to tell me how Sando is not taking like four sides simultaneously here
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote
11-10-2014 , 05:41 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gadarene
makes sense

orrrrrr

1) Moocher says the flavor is always a wolf

2) I know that Moocher is familiar with the lore

3) I trust that Moocher wouldn't lie about something that is falsifiable/verifiable

4) Based on Moocher's representation, I believe you've outed yourself and vote you

you should def go with the interpretation where i decide to contradict myself for no reason itt and lie about having GoT knowledge, though
I'm not saying 'always' and if I did say 'iamrobik is always a wolf' or w/e then it was in the moment, I'm considering it now...it's just gross, I don't want to kill the guy based on mod flavour and a lore interpretation, I simply don't know how hardly any of the mechanics of this game work and lynching/vigging people over things like this is something I always think is really lazy and very often wrong.

Not sure what to do atm.

The fact he claimed the shot after Hoya flipped villa is ******ed if he's a wolf, I'd basically have to assume he misread Hoya's role reveal to carry on calling him a wolf here, I think he just got super unlucky and somehow he's either not the person I thought he was or he is and that person isn't a woofer.
Game of Thrones 4: A Storm of Swords pt 2 - A WW Mish-Mash Game Thread (November 10th, 2014) Quote

      
m