Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
[Game Thread] 9/5 Top Tier Vanilla 17er (Short Night) [Game Thread] 9/5 Top Tier Vanilla 17er (Short Night)

09-10-2014 , 11:30 AM
Baudib, I didn't read 1/10th of that analysis. The format is so unappetizing.
[Game Thread] 9/5 Top Tier Vanilla 17er (Short Night) Quote
09-10-2014 , 11:33 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Silman
btw to my fellow uncleareds, I feel a good use of time is to try and clear each other
It's generally much easier to clear someone else than yourself and will also give the wolves fits because once one is lynched there's extra spew
Silman, tell me why you are not a wolf? Who do you wanna lynch today?
[Game Thread] 9/5 Top Tier Vanilla 17er (Short Night) Quote
09-10-2014 , 11:35 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by IAmRobik
There's basically nobody that baudib can be scum with. That's what started bothering me yesterday, and that's why I started questioning people for their top 2 scum. Everyone cleared him fairly lightly early on, and then everyone just buried the **** out of him at SOD yesterday. I still tried to snipe him based off of the logic I provided during the night phase, but I don't know if I was right or wrong in attempting to do that.
When exactly did it start bothering you? Before or after you jumped on me for a shot at random kill instead of Killer?
[Game Thread] 9/5 Top Tier Vanilla 17er (Short Night) Quote
09-10-2014 , 11:36 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by baudib1
Silman, tell me why you are not a wolf? Who do you wanna lynch today?
my role told me not to be a wolf this game is why I guess?
How to prove it, I'm not sure
Who I want to lynch today?
I'm also not sure
Probably killer
[Game Thread] 9/5 Top Tier Vanilla 17er (Short Night) Quote
09-10-2014 , 11:37 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thingyman
this is ****ing with me big time

is this for real?

@ any other person in this game

I don't know if it's just me, but given how this endgame is shaping up and given the fact that it seems like there could maybe be a hidden wolf (and this would only seem stronger from villa Silman's POV, given that he knows he can't be a wolf himself), how are you not IMMEDIATELY curious to know who the **** was killed during the night?
I'm trying to avoid the reflex reaction to lynch the most obvious wolf team of Killer-Silman but it's hard.
[Game Thread] 9/5 Top Tier Vanilla 17er (Short Night) Quote
09-10-2014 , 11:38 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by baudib1
When exactly did it start bothering you? Before or after you jumped on me for a shot at random kill instead of Killer?
At the beginning of the day when everyone was on you, but then not everyone would answer my question and not everybody had you as their #1, so it was basically null. Then the voting went down the way it did and I thought you could be scum, so I tried to snipe you. Reviewing the voting is what's leading my to believe that maybe I was wrong. Why didn't you vote for Killer to save yourself from a flip?
[Game Thread] 9/5 Top Tier Vanilla 17er (Short Night) Quote
09-10-2014 , 11:38 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by IAmRobik
Baudib, I didn't read 1/10th of that analysis. The format is so unappetizing.
Sorry, I was copying stuff down as I was going through it. I'll try to condense in the future.
[Game Thread] 9/5 Top Tier Vanilla 17er (Short Night) Quote
09-10-2014 , 11:39 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by IAmRobik
At the beginning of the day when everyone was on you, but then not everyone would answer my question and not everybody had you as their #1, so it was basically null. Then the voting went down the way it did and I thought you could be scum, so I tried to snipe you. Reviewing the voting is what's leading my to believe that maybe I was wrong. Why didn't you vote for Killer to save yourself from a flip?
I didn't know Pine was gonna change again and I thought you'd listen to Monkey.
[Game Thread] 9/5 Top Tier Vanilla 17er (Short Night) Quote
09-10-2014 , 11:41 AM
killer_kill

I don't see a scenario that would make me wanna change today.
[Game Thread] 9/5 Top Tier Vanilla 17er (Short Night) Quote
09-10-2014 , 11:42 AM
it might be hard to read but a unedited reads dump like that is *super* villagery
[Game Thread] 9/5 Top Tier Vanilla 17er (Short Night) Quote
09-10-2014 , 11:44 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by baudib1
I didn't know Pine was gonna change again and I thought you'd listen to Monkey.
What do you mean change again? He changed onto you and I was on killer. It was gamer-you-killer 3-3-3. If you switch to killer it makes it 2-3-4.

I have this feels. You know the feels I'm talking about. It's the feels that Baudib is trying to gain some cred for killer flipping maf today.
[Game Thread] 9/5 Top Tier Vanilla 17er (Short Night) Quote
09-10-2014 , 11:47 AM
Cliffs on my D2 notes:

Killer: LDFO wolf
Mets: Lazy ass villager who probably cost us a mislynch
Silman: Meh, I don't know. My thought as it was happening was "he feels like a villager" even as he was pushing me because it seemed to be coming from a probing way as opposed to a wolfy, just throw shade on me out of nowhere. But he was pretty early on the Lemon bandwagon without a whole lot of explanation.
Robik: Looks a lot better on D2 than I remember, led the lynch on Kruze.
Baudib: Confirmed LVP
Pine: His D2 was kinda ****/nowhere to be found.
[Game Thread] 9/5 Top Tier Vanilla 17er (Short Night) Quote
09-10-2014 , 11:49 AM
takes you 3 words to explain people and 3 sentences to explain silman?
[Game Thread] 9/5 Top Tier Vanilla 17er (Short Night) Quote
09-10-2014 , 11:50 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by IAmRobik
What do you mean change again? He changed onto you and I was on killer. It was gamer-you-killer 3-3-3. If you switch to killer it makes it 2-3-4.

I have this feels. You know the feels I'm talking about. It's the feels that Baudib is trying to gain some cred for killer flipping maf today.
WTF you're the one who said I can't be a wolf with Killer!

you're right on the vote count though, I thought Pine was on Gamer. And I just assumed it was going to be me or Gamer so I didn't even consider jumping to killer.
[Game Thread] 9/5 Top Tier Vanilla 17er (Short Night) Quote
09-10-2014 , 11:52 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by IAmRobik
takes you 3 words to explain people and 3 sentences to explain silman?
Sue me. Who are the 2 wolves?
[Game Thread] 9/5 Top Tier Vanilla 17er (Short Night) Quote
09-10-2014 , 11:52 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by baudib1
Sue me. Who are the 2 wolves?
that one guy and the guy that's with him.
[Game Thread] 9/5 Top Tier Vanilla 17er (Short Night) Quote
09-10-2014 , 11:53 AM
Probable NKs:
Thingyman
Chris Pine

baudib1
Monkey Banana
IAmRobik

Probable lynches:
Silman
killer_kill

This is how I think the game will go down
If I am in f3 it's very likely I will be lynched so I think it's better for me to be lynched at f5. I'll do my best to try and figure out who should be lynched in f3 and hopefully the villagers in f3 get there.
I would hard-clear baudib, and if he's wolf then hey, he deserves to win this game imo
If Chris Pine is in f3 then unclear him from SHC and just look at his posts. The wolves may leave him alive to try and make him look suspicious based on lack of being NK'd but it's pretty ballsy to do so.
If killer is villa I think we just lose

I'll re-evaluate whether I think I can fully clear myself tomorrow but if I can't and I do go down, I sincerely hope you will listen to what I have to say when it comes to f3.

FTR, I think there is a hidden wolf. I think it much more likely than baudib being wolf at this point. We need a team effort to find it.
If you think I'm a filthy wolf, lynch me. We have one mislynch. But please don't waste time and posts making a big song and dance about it.
We have work to do, men.
[Game Thread] 9/5 Top Tier Vanilla 17er (Short Night) Quote
09-10-2014 , 11:56 AM
I gotta jet. I'll try to be on later via phone. I think this day's lynch is pretty much settled but I want to hear more from a few people.

Actually, I'm probably only listening to Thingy, Monkey, and Silman (if he can come up with any decent theories on who else is a wolf besides himself).

Robik and Pine are just tilting me so ***** hard.
[Game Thread] 9/5 Top Tier Vanilla 17er (Short Night) Quote
09-10-2014 , 11:58 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by killer_kill
This almost has to be villa to have shrooped and not saw/know the NK imo. So that leaves thingy/MB/Baudib/CP.
interesting that after he clears me light, he makes a pool of potential wolves that is everyone but me and him and ... IamRobik?

Not even sure which way that spews, but I lean towards villa. Killa knows he's going down and will be trying to level.

Interesting that he puts thingy in his wolf pile. Has anyone even called thingy a wolf yet this game? (other than me ages ago for no real good reason)
[Game Thread] 9/5 Top Tier Vanilla 17er (Short Night) Quote
09-10-2014 , 12:00 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Silman
Probable NKs:
Thingyman
Chris Pine

baudib1
Monkey Banana
IAmRobik

Probable lynches:
Silman
killer_kill

This is how I think the game will go down
If I am in f3 it's very likely I will be lynched so I think it's better for me to be lynched at f5. I'll do my best to try and figure out who should be lynched in f3 and hopefully the villagers in f3 get there.
I would hard-clear baudib, and if he's wolf then hey, he deserves to win this game imo
If Chris Pine is in f3 then unclear him from SHC and just look at his posts. The wolves may leave him alive to try and make him look suspicious based on lack of being NK'd but it's pretty ballsy to do so.
If killer is villa I think we just lose

I'll re-evaluate whether I think I can fully clear myself tomorrow but if I can't and I do go down, I sincerely hope you will listen to what I have to say when it comes to f3.

FTR, I think there is a hidden wolf. I think it much more likely than baudib being wolf at this point. We need a team effort to find it.
If you think I'm a filthy wolf, lynch me. We have one mislynch. But please don't waste time and posts making a big song and dance about it.
We have work to do, men.
You think Chris will be nk'd before me? I highly doubt this.
[Game Thread] 9/5 Top Tier Vanilla 17er (Short Night) Quote
09-10-2014 , 12:01 PM
Votes from post 2596 to post 2670
Night in 7:59:58

---
VotesLynchVoters
3 killer_kill Thingyman (9), Chris Pine (3), baudib1 (11)
4 not voting IAmRobik (18), killer_kill (5), Monkey Banana (0), Silman (23)
[Game Thread] 9/5 Top Tier Vanilla 17er (Short Night) Quote
09-10-2014 , 12:01 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Silman
Probable NKs:
Thingyman
Chris Pine

baudib1
Monkey Banana
IAmRobik

Probable lynches:
Silman
killer_kill

This is how I think the game will go down
If I am in f3 it's very likely I will be lynched so I think it's better for me to be lynched at f5. I'll do my best to try and figure out who should be lynched in f3 and hopefully the villagers in f3 get there.
I would hard-clear baudib, and if he's wolf then hey, he deserves to win this game imo
If Chris Pine is in f3 then unclear him from SHC and just look at his posts. The wolves may leave him alive to try and make him look suspicious based on lack of being NK'd but it's pretty ballsy to do so.
If killer is villa I think we just lose

I'll re-evaluate whether I think I can fully clear myself tomorrow but if I can't and I do go down, I sincerely hope you will listen to what I have to say when it comes to f3.

FTR, I think there is a hidden wolf. I think it much more likely than baudib being wolf at this point. We need a team effort to find it.
If you think I'm a filthy wolf, lynch me. We have one mislynch. But please don't waste time and posts making a big song and dance about it.
We have work to do, men.
I wanna say this is a good post from you but mostly it's obvious stuff.

I'm a villager, and honestly not feeling optimistic atm.
[Game Thread] 9/5 Top Tier Vanilla 17er (Short Night) Quote
09-10-2014 , 12:04 PM
for catching the hidden wolf I think day 1 and 2 spew will probably be the most reliable tell.
I feel like after seer is dead wolves are much more careful about what they say about other wolves.

If we let the pool of potential hiddens be:
Thingy
Monkey
IamRobik
Chris Pine

since almost certainly myself and killer are getting lynched and I think baudib basically can't be a hidden wolf. (lolmeifwrong.jpg)
and if there is 2 hidden wolves we actual just lose

I'll do a bit of reading of telc first
then maybe killer since we are basically assuming he's wolf cause we lose othewise
then maybe kruze but he's a bit weirder so I'm not sure how well I will read him
[Game Thread] 9/5 Top Tier Vanilla 17er (Short Night) Quote
09-10-2014 , 12:04 PM
I was just looking at post count and I was about to ask where's mets
Rest In Pepperoni
[Game Thread] 9/5 Top Tier Vanilla 17er (Short Night) Quote
09-10-2014 , 12:05 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by IAmRobik
You think Chris will be nk'd before me? I highly doubt this.
well we will see tonight.
it certainly raises CP's wolf% a lot if he lives to f3
[Game Thread] 9/5 Top Tier Vanilla 17er (Short Night) Quote

      
m