Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Choose Your Own Adventure Vol IV: GAME THREAD Choose Your Own Adventure Vol IV: GAME THREAD

09-24-2020 , 07:18 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Uglydelicious
They look awful in Tapatalk
I don't see any reason to use that though

chrome or opera
Choose Your Own Adventure Vol IV: GAME THREAD Quote
09-24-2020 , 07:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sun Tzu
I don't see any reason to use that though

chrome or opera
i use safari
Choose Your Own Adventure Vol IV: GAME THREAD Quote
09-24-2020 , 07:20 PM
All criminal and healer vanilla players who submitted individual event choices last night should now have their results. Please PM this account immediately if you do not know your result or your new power.
Choose Your Own Adventure Vol IV: GAME THREAD Quote
09-24-2020 , 07:24 PM
Good lord I'm an idiot

Third try is a charm:

Trying again since it was two separate threads and MQ is hard

D1 (overnight)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gadarene
not gonna do any kind of EOD analysis but want to organize my thoughts in case i feel like iso-ing people in my pile or who aren't on here

reads and junk, etc. etc.

vv
Birdman10687
fanmail
iraisetoomuch
LKJ
Luckbox Inc

v
HerbieGRD
ladd (super-thin)
Montecore
shortline99
Sun Tzu (still only slightly)
Uglydelicious

will get resolved before i have to worry about it i imagine
bsball8806 (leaning v)
filthyvermin (leaning v)
Treep (isoed her and now leaning v maybe)
KingWiggles (isoed and fine with him dying)


A missread issue
aao
carolinacoder (i understand what people were saying near EOD)
crackedquads
fnord_too
wahoopride

w
AriesRam
Eric (why not!)
master3004 (!!!) (just isoed) (drudgesiren) (i'm pretty good at reading him and i think he's a wolf)
traz
Zurvan (he confuses me because his posts were way more dense as a villa in games without post restrictions than they are here, but that seems like such a facile read)

the rest
aaronk56
biggerboat
Chocolatte
EADGBE
iaafr (def iso)
Nicholasp27
SGT RJ (0 posts)
tedxtr
Tokyo!! (maybe trending up)

that was productive if for no other reason than I now think master is a wolf
Quote:
Originally Posted by Birdman10687
you know when i troll you it’s all in good fun right?

if it honestly bothers you i will stop
D2 (in the 13er thread)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gadarene
updated reads and junk, etc. etc.

vv
Birdman10687
fanmail
iraisetoomuch
LKJ
Luckbox Inc
Montecore

v
biggerboat
HerbieGRD
ladd
shortline99
Sun Tzu
Uglydelicious

very slightly v
aao (liked his posting this morning)
Eric (he also had a post this morning that i liked, but thinner)
filthyvermin
Treep
KingWiggles

idk really
aaronk56
Nicholasp27
SGT RJ
tedxtr (should iso at some point)
Tokyo!! (ditto)


bsball8806 (everything seems sort of effortless and glide-y on his part)
carolinacoder
crackedquads
EADGBE (but this is mostly volume?)
fnord_too

w
A missread issue (get the same sense as when he was a wolf in ST)
AriesRam
Chocolatte
master3004
traz
Zurvan

I think that looks pretty good
Choose Your Own Adventure Vol IV: GAME THREAD Quote
09-24-2020 , 07:25 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Zurvan
Eric coming in hot with the "pro-village" reaction post.
Trying to involve other classes in a Healer event was clearly a bad idea. Why did people go for option one?
Choose Your Own Adventure Vol IV: GAME THREAD Quote
09-24-2020 , 07:25 PM
One more time with all of the cases noted and blue for strong villa, orange for strong wolf and the cases for these. I am done with this for a while, but now at least I have a better idea of the landscape.

Player
Role
Deathpost
Notes
A missread issueW Minion 1LinkN2 Kill
aao   
aaronk56  Claimed seargent with no heat, no CC
AriesRamV Master HealerLinkLynched D2, early night called by Master
biggerboatWolf mechanically peekedTBDWolf due to iaafr dying when vig shot bigger
Birdman10687  Poisonned N2, healed, likely peeked by gad
bsball8806   
carolinacoder   
ChocolatteWolf Minion 5LinkSuicided bombed by king wiggles
crackedquads   
EADGBE  Clear due to being tied for lynch lead when wolf called early night
Eric   
fanmail  Near lead when wolves called night early lynching w master, if fv is tripple voter revisit
filthyvermin  fanmail vote right before night
fnord_too  CQ case fv voting analysis EOD d2
GadareneV FieldmarshallLinkKilled by V assassin IRTM
HerbieGRD   
iaafrWolf, Minion 2LinkVig shot bigger n1, iiafr took bullet
iraisetoomuchV Assassin See gad death post for conf
KingWigglesV Master MageLinkSuicided bombed chocolate
laddV PickpocketLinkN2 Kill
LKJ   
Luckbox Inc   
Mark_KVillagerLinkN1 Lynch
master3004Wolf Dark SorcererLinkLynched D2, early night called by Master
Montecore   
Nicholasp27   
SGT RJ  voting master during early night call
shortline99   
Sun Tzu   
tedxtrV BardLinkN2 kill
TheBrokenATM!VillagerLinkModkilled
Tokyo!!  Likely Gad peek
traz   
Treep   
Uglydelicious   
wahooprideVillagerLinkN1 Kill
Zurvan   
Choose Your Own Adventure Vol IV: GAME THREAD Quote
09-24-2020 , 07:25 PM
Knew you’d get it eventually
Choose Your Own Adventure Vol IV: GAME THREAD Quote
09-24-2020 , 07:26 PM
Bsball very silent tonight, huh?
Choose Your Own Adventure Vol IV: GAME THREAD Quote
09-24-2020 , 07:26 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Birdman10687
ok but as stupid as the wolf team clearly is, we have to assume that going into EOD that did not expect master to get lunched. we need to explain why they would have thought that

i guess if they just lucked into villager-filthy jumping on to fanmail when he did, got excited and called it and failed to notice that Zurvan had moved to treep?

like yeah i guess it could just be a total coincidence
I’m home - got off work early, trying to catch up.

Some quick thoughts:

Moving CQ to villa lean pile.

The more I mulled it over while flinging cards at random degens, the more I think this could actually be the most plausible scenario for yesterday’s lolgoodness that was master accidentally offing himself. That had to be an accident - they weren’t planning to rand one of the two wagons, and they would clearly want this opportunity to get two bad lunches for the price of one.

I think the wolves were just waiting for there to be two lead villa wagons, and to further complicate things (for them) I also think given how things played out that the triple voter was a) either not playing at all right then or b) was in the 13er.

If they missed the Z switch from fanmail to Treep, which honestly seems pretty likely at this point unless the wolf team is legitimately brain dead, then they just waiting for one more person to vote fanmail to unleash chaos. Which filthy did, but I honestly would not be surprised if he is just a villa that durped into it, and honestly who better to durp into something than filthy? No offense filthy.

It might be worth doing a vote by vote reconstruction of both threads to see why it wasn’t called sooner. I know it’s partially because chocolate was a top wagon until she was nuked.

Finally, I just want to say I’m sorta mad I wasn’t wolf killed in a seer hunt last night. I nailed master with my first post after I came back that afternoon. Given that I accidentally missed d1 I could have been the seer with a master wolf peek and play it that way. I mean I wouldn’t peek master but I kinda wish I had died. I dread late game mashes.
Choose Your Own Adventure Vol IV: GAME THREAD Quote
09-24-2020 , 07:26 PM
Does that suggest AMI was a wolf peek?
Choose Your Own Adventure Vol IV: GAME THREAD Quote
09-24-2020 , 07:26 PM
so did gad peek AMI wolf?
Choose Your Own Adventure Vol IV: GAME THREAD Quote
09-24-2020 , 07:28 PM
SGT - the wolf triple voter may have also just been AFK or deliberately non-voting. I had a post earlier today breaking down who those people are
Choose Your Own Adventure Vol IV: GAME THREAD Quote
09-24-2020 , 07:28 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Birdman10687
so did gad peek AMI wolf?
Is that how you would expect someone to leave a peek? "seems the same as previous game" ?
Choose Your Own Adventure Vol IV: GAME THREAD Quote
09-24-2020 , 07:29 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by crackedquads
Does that suggest AMI was a wolf peek?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Birdman10687
so did gad peek AMI wolf?
Yeah it makes sense given he should have been peeking from that part of his d1 list
Choose Your Own Adventure Vol IV: GAME THREAD Quote
09-24-2020 , 07:31 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Uglydelicious
Is that how you would expect someone to leave a peek? "seems the same as previous game" ?
Look how he moved AMI from the skeptical face pile on day one to the TOP of the wolf pile on day two

If he peeks him he knows he needs some sort of justification for that move, and his description is some sort of an attempt at a non-peek justification
Choose Your Own Adventure Vol IV: GAME THREAD Quote
09-24-2020 , 07:31 PM
Or are you suggesting that is who he peeked last night but AMI died?
Choose Your Own Adventure Vol IV: GAME THREAD Quote
09-24-2020 , 07:32 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Uglydelicious
Is that how you would expect someone to leave a peek? "seems the same as previous game" ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Montecore
Yeah it makes sense given he should have been peeking from that part of his d1 list
yeah his parenthetical seemed half assed, and usually when you make peeks you just leave them at the top of the relevant section. either way the other option is fanmail villager who is lock clear so no additionally info either way.
Choose Your Own Adventure Vol IV: GAME THREAD Quote
09-24-2020 , 07:32 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Montecore
Yeah it makes sense given he should have been peeking from that part of his d1 list
Would also make sense why he claimed to shoot AMI with his 1 time vig
Choose Your Own Adventure Vol IV: GAME THREAD Quote
09-24-2020 , 07:32 PM
Or maybe did shoot AMI with his 1 time vig, but I doubt it
Choose Your Own Adventure Vol IV: GAME THREAD Quote
09-24-2020 , 07:32 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by crackedquads
Look how he moved AMI from the skeptical face pile on day one to the TOP of the wolf pile on day two

If he peeks him he knows he needs some sort of justification for that move, and his description is some sort of an attempt at a non-peek justification
hmm ok
Choose Your Own Adventure Vol IV: GAME THREAD Quote
09-24-2020 , 07:32 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Uglydelicious
Or are you suggesting that is who he peeked last night but AMI died?
n0 birdman - v
n1 ami - w or n1 - fanmail - v
n2 tokyo - w

is how i read it
Choose Your Own Adventure Vol IV: GAME THREAD Quote
09-24-2020 , 07:33 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by HerbieGRD
Would also make sense why he claimed to shoot AMI with his 1 time vig
Quote:
Originally Posted by HerbieGRD
Or maybe did shoot AMI with his 1 time vig, but I doubt it
Quote:
Originally Posted by Uglydelicious
hmm ok
hey definitely didn't

it was a 25% shot n1

he claimed it to protect himself but irtm blew that plan up
Choose Your Own Adventure Vol IV: GAME THREAD Quote
09-24-2020 , 07:33 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Birdman10687
n0 birdman - v
n1 ami - w or n1 - fanmail - v
n2 tokyo - w

is how i read it
Probably correct
Choose Your Own Adventure Vol IV: GAME THREAD Quote
09-24-2020 , 07:34 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Birdman10687
yeah his parenthetical seemed half assed, and usually when you make peeks you just leave them at the top of the relevant section. either way the other option is fanmail villager who is lock clear so no additionally info either way.
yeah his lists are always alphabetical though
Choose Your Own Adventure Vol IV: GAME THREAD Quote
09-24-2020 , 07:34 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Birdman10687
hey definitely didn't

it was a 25% shot n1

he claimed it to protect himself but irtm blew that plan up
Fine, semantics at this point
Choose Your Own Adventure Vol IV: GAME THREAD Quote

      
m