Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Cartoon Swim Game Thread Cartoon Swim Game Thread

11-19-2015 , 01:59 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by iamnotawerewolf
roman, do something homes
I will do stuff when I feel like it.
Cartoon Swim Game Thread Quote
11-19-2015 , 01:59 PM
i'm taking my own advice

eating, working, maybe i'll be back

maybe when i do i can focus on something other than lord
Cartoon Swim Game Thread Quote
11-19-2015 , 02:00 PM
Interesting fact: I have yet to tussle like this with Gad in a game where he hasn't flipped scum.
Cartoon Swim Game Thread Quote
11-19-2015 , 02:01 PM
Votes from post 2476 to post 3528
Night in 5:59:53

---
VotesLynchVoters
4 Lissa2 ihcjay (46), RAORoman (31), Viggorous (21), LordJvK (88)
4 Joker of Spades dLGN (51), descuffphoenix (95), TheBrokenATM! (57), Gadarene (49)
2 TehBankertin ApocPS (67), Xkf (45)
1 stormslyde BenjaminAO (93)
1 peskypenguin Telcontar (37)
1 Xkf Montecore (22)
1 Telcontar Ace of Spaids (12)
1 Viggorous iamnotawerewolf (32)
1 AllInBluff rtspurs (41)
1 ihcjay AllInBluff (126)
15 not voting bopolis (37), Copperheat (0), fraleyight (14), Gamer Dude (0), grant2 (15), Joker of Spades (3), Jon Paul (7), Lissa2 (36), Namath12 (0), peskypenguin (3), ReddBoiler (0), Stork.. (0), stormslyde (0), TehBankertin (0), xander biscuits (0)
Cartoon Swim Game Thread Quote
11-19-2015 , 02:01 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lissa2
"You're backing off the peek... oh we have to kill the guy you peeked anyway to resolve it"

How does that make sense as a villager thought
Because at the time I thought he was likely having his mind changed too easily.
Like he came out with the peek. I did a quick research and it seems quite believable.
If you look at my posts prior you'll see this progression.
Cartoon Swim Game Thread Quote
11-19-2015 , 02:02 PM
He was like this in Hearthstone and again in the recent Two Fold C9++.

If meta is a thing, Gad has it with me. He was not like this when he was a villa in the games where we were v-v.
Cartoon Swim Game Thread Quote
11-19-2015 , 02:02 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by descuffphoenix
Because at the time I thought he was likely having his mind changed too easily.
Like he came out with the peek. I did a quick research and it seems quite believable.
If you look at my posts prior you'll see this progression.
But if he was saying the peek wasn't real

You still wanting to kill the peeked person makes no sense
Cartoon Swim Game Thread Quote
11-19-2015 , 02:03 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by dLGN
because it is beyond implausible leaning towards constructed. we do not see this game similarly AT ALL, and in order for me to think you are town at this point I feel like I have to accept that more than one of your reads are absolutely wrong this game ON TOP of the fact that you "believe" this incredibly unlikely wolf-wolf situation with storm and nam. there's paranoid, there's JP, and then there is THIS...??
Why is it "incredibly unlikely", from what I've seen in a lot of forum games, this seems fairly plausible. You still don't want to view the game from my perspective, you are tunneled on this "I see this one way, and its the only plauisble world" sorry thats not how Wolf works. You need to think about Storm being wolf and namath being wolf/neutral. You have this perfect world where things go a certain way. I can see my world and yours, I'm not sitting there telling a player they're bad just because I see something differently. You are being an ass, and a bad villa if you are one. I would hope as villa you would work with my world and help me bridge over to you. Instead you insult my play and never change your thought process. I'm done talking to a player like this, and hope you change.
Cartoon Swim Game Thread Quote
11-19-2015 , 02:03 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ace of Spaids
Still not seeing anything that changes my reads from yesterday of stormslyde and Stork.

I don't think I will still be awake when ITAs happen. But to start Town Consensus:

TOWN CONSENSUS SHATS LIST
stormslyde
Stork
I have no objection to these two actually.
Cartoon Swim Game Thread Quote
11-19-2015 , 02:03 PM
Cartoon Swim Game Thread Quote
11-19-2015 , 02:04 PM
Lissa
Cartoon Swim Game Thread Quote
11-19-2015 , 02:04 PM
Cartoon Swim Game Thread Quote
11-19-2015 , 02:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by iamnotawerewolf
Obvious for [Reasons]
iamnotawerewolf

Mech and Stuff
Stormslyde
Namath
LordJvK
IhcJay

V Reads
DlGn
DescuffPhoenix
benjaminAO
Lissa2
Jon Paul
ApocPS
Xander Biscuits
frayleight
RtsPurs
Telcontar

Strongk, Love But Don't Trust
Gadarane
Xkf

ITA Long List
RAORoman
Bopolis
Stork..
TheBrokenATM!
Montecore
Grant2
Zorkman

ITA Short List
Viggorous
TehBankertin
Ace of Spaids
AllInBluff

In this game?
Reddboiler
Gamer Dude
Joker of Spades
PeskyPenguin
Ika
Copperheat

-------------

or something like that I guess
ben has 3 of your top 5 villagers as wolf, wolf, and leaning wolf. idk how he can't be lowered on that list atm.

why stork in ita long list? i liked a lot of his reactions this game, personally

same with monte - i'd certainly have him as villa this game. he has been forthcoming with what he believes this game and is very confident. his play reminds me of the town game of someone else where they almost have an untouchable arrogance about them.

zork was townread strongly by quite a few people iirc yesterday, though i never saw why. why do you have him as ita long list, too?

for the most part though we still seem to be about on the same page.
Cartoon Swim Game Thread Quote
11-19-2015 , 02:05 PM
dLGN
Cartoon Swim Game Thread Quote
11-19-2015 , 02:06 PM
Cartoon Swim Game Thread Quote
11-19-2015 , 02:06 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by RAORoman
Apoc, make a read on Lissa. Now.
Did Apoc ever answer this?
Cartoon Swim Game Thread Quote
11-19-2015 , 02:06 PM
Cartoon Swim Game Thread Quote
11-19-2015 , 02:07 PM
This is where I am currently at:

Village Core
Gad
DLGN
monte
IANAW
namath

Most likely villas:
roman
apoc
telc
lord

Villa leans:
grant
batm
storm
descuff
xkf

???
stork
vigg
pesky
ace
JP
jay

wolf leans:
banks*
lissa
fraley
joker
AiB
ben
spurs


There is an asterisk on banks because I'm not reading him wolfy but moreso i'm alarmed about how little he's given out about his thoughts on the game other than kill QB/dont kill JP. The fear is real with him because he was widely villa read in the last mash and he just styled all over the village.

I think lissa has been underwhelming yesterday but she is completely capable of making herself villagy. Failure to do so today should result in shats.

I think fraley has been a non entity in this game, and him popping in at the end of the day to vote was wolfy to me. Due to fraley's bussing if AiB flips wolf I think fraley is likely to be a wolf. In tvtropes he came in at the end of the day and did a similar thing to a wolfbro.

I like what gad had to say regarding joker's knowledge of the thread and I think he is fine target for shats.

I think we should lynch AiB. I think he's a wolf. I think he was wolfy yesterday and the way he is looking at the wagons doesnt make sense from his perspective. He's calling people jumping onto QB late wolves and it only makes sense to do that if you think they are saving a wolf. AiB would have to be the wolf the other wolves are saving so for him to continue with that line and say hes a villa is absolutely bananas.

I think ben has been inconsistent with his reads. DLGN pointed out that he's listing both Storm and namath as wolves when it never makes sense for wolves to peek each other there and lie about it. I think the lack of namath dying in the night is odd but i dont think its something we settle today.


Also, I think lord is always a villa here. I dont think it ever makes sense to do the jay peek thing as a wolf. I dont think wolf lord ever draws attention to himself like that. He aids'd up the thread but we arent lynching/vigging him for it.

I think BATM is a villa here. I think people are hanging on to the "he claimed wolf" too much. Wanting to lynch him because he does something that is not alignment indicative is bad.

I thought stork was villagy yesterday but he's trended downward

tl;dr

Lynch/ITA AIB,joker,fraley,ben,spurs and then re-evaluate; if banks/lissa dont come in and act villagy im down for changing up that order.
Cartoon Swim Game Thread Quote
11-19-2015 , 02:07 PM
Think the entire Joker wagon is scummy.
Cartoon Swim Game Thread Quote
11-19-2015 , 02:08 PM
Announcement:

There will be an upcoming event!

another Board Game Online event!

But this time, there's a different goal!

There will be 75 steps, and max 5 participants. all who enter will win!

What will they win exactly? Your odds get better depending how far you are in the game before it ends! Capped at 75!

from 0 to 75.

To make things harder, mod will be there race as well! He can use powers and skills on himself.

entering starts at 13:30.

I will post the link, there's no need to write IN.
Cartoon Swim Game Thread Quote
11-19-2015 , 02:08 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by LordJvK
I thought the Zork kill was pretty weird because I had him as 99.99% vanilla.

Maybe they didn't want a lock clear villa? Seems odd for a PR hunt kill.
jeez you're busting Xkf's balls because he's got "TMI" from figuring out you only do a weaksauce fake-peek as a villager.

And then you parade your belief that "Zork was 99.99% vanilla" as if *THAT* would not be TMI.

Xkf is making a lot more sense than you this game. Making sense isn't a prerequisite to being a villager but it sure helps.

Get over your ego here. Every single time you do one of these stupid Gotcha! plays you insist you have "caught" someone. Your shenanigans aren't really that clever.
Cartoon Swim Game Thread Quote
11-19-2015 , 02:10 PM
Why would a wolf peek another wolf hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm I wonder, maybe because they didn't know each other day one I hate how people forget some of the most important info villa has. My reads are inconsistent lol, how is this even true, I've stuck to my reads and only changed based on plays and interactions. Its been a bit over one day, and somehow I'm inconsistent. Okay
Cartoon Swim Game Thread Quote
11-19-2015 , 02:10 PM
in
Cartoon Swim Game Thread Quote
11-19-2015 , 02:10 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Reaperlicious
Announcement:

There will be an upcoming event!

another Board Game Online event!

But this time, there's a different goal!

There will be 75 steps, and max 5 participants. all who enter will win!

What will they win exactly? Your odds get better depending how far you are in the game before it ends! Capped at 75!

from 0 to 75.

To make things harder, mod will be there race as well! He can use powers and skills on himself.

entering starts at 13:30.

I will post the link, there's no need to write IN.
Your ITA-shot's Odds that is!

DescuffPhoenix and TheBrokenATM! can enter but won't be able to shoot.
Cartoon Swim Game Thread Quote
11-19-2015 , 02:11 PM
grant, if you were in the game yesterday and had seen the manner in which Zork stepped forward as a vanilla, I don't see how you can't see why I -- and many many other people -- thought Zork was vanilla.

And lo, he actually was.
Cartoon Swim Game Thread Quote

      
m