Quote:
Originally Posted by Wyman
1. 3C, showing 18+ and 5+ diamonds and 4+ clubs.
2. I would bid 2H. You are a little light on points, but you have either a 9-card fit, a double fit, or both. It will be important to compete on this hand.
Thanks!
On 1: Hmmm, when you lay it out like that it seems obvious. I bid what now seems like an indefensible 2NT since we could be getting crushed in spades. If partner bid 1S instead of 1H is there any merit in 2NT, or is it too big a lie to tell about distribution? At the time, I justified the lie by reasoning that our most likely best contracts were either 2 or 3NT, and telling partner exactly how strong our hand is would give the most useful information for deciding which of the two was best.
Other bids I considered were 2C, 2D, and 3D. 2C and 2D now seem too weak, but what about 3D? With 6-4 hands, I often don't know whether to rebid the 6-card suit or show the 4-card one at my second call.
On 2: Okay, good, I bid 2H after similar reasoning (although I didn't realize at the time that the double-fit was a possibility). Auction then went (P)-3H-(P). What should partner's 3H bid mean there?