Quote:
Originally Posted by Wyman
Playing strong NT, I open 1D, but I expect my partner's openings in 2nd seat to be solid, especially at these colors. In particular, 3rd seat couldn't say anything white v red, so I expect my partner to have a pretty decent hand opposite mine.
The question in my mind is why didn't third seat make a call.
Quote:
A 5
A 6 3
A 7 5 2
J T 6 3
There are three passes to me.
Am I being to nitty by passing out this hand?
My main reason is the lack of control of the major suits and lack of intermediates in the hand. Three aces (especially both major ones) is nice, and my partner's kings and queens are much better supported with them, but I feel (especially with our vulnerability) that the opponents can steal this contract away. It should also be noted that my partner tends to open fairly lightly from 2nd seat, so I'm pretty sure that he has 10 or fewer HCP and no long (5+) suit in his hand. Is this a bad play?
Three aces are just "too good"; maybe the only kind of
hands I would pass in fourth seat with exactly three aces
would look like:
Ax
Ax
xxxxx
Axxx
but here, you have an okay holding in clubs: JTxx. This is
easily an opening hand in fourth seat despite holding only
two spades.
The better question is this: will it be better in the long run
to open this or pass, i.e, do you expect to get a better
matchpoint score to do so? If you pass this, you will be
"going against the field" since almost everyone will open
this hand and I'd expect more than half of the time when
fourth seat opens this hand, they will go "plus". Even if
your opponents outbid you when you open in fourth seat,
some of the time you'll be +50 or even +100.