I just quoted any posts that seem out of place to me upon reread. You are probably going to have to click through most of these posts to understand the context.
PLEASE READ THEM ALL. I KNOW ITS A LONG TL;DR but please read them/click through them.
Quote:
Originally Posted by timistere
kokiris body of work not that impressive either so far
Quote:
gtpitch not having a great start
Quote:
Originally Posted by timistere
the leo vote was basically random.org to get things started
and since these were all of kokiris posts up to that point i didn't think it needed any explanation
Xkf and timi both notice that Kokiri's posts are wolfy - but they never end up voting him on either D1 or D2.
Quote:
Originally Posted by bhuber2010
Has my partner outted us yet?
Do we have any votes?
If not, I am gonna go slank.
Quote:
Originally Posted by bhuber2010
Hey yo timi,
Add me to skype so we can strategize how to kill the village.
golfpro26ptp
Quote:
i think i have a unique perspective on reddboiler's lists post because i've seen him do it befoer and i think i was there for the origin when he thought it was a good idea. let me see if i can elaborate and hopefully you and others (particularly donk who was reading into it) can help me figure it out.
i think it first started in a game i was in with redd and SIU. SIU posted his notes that looked similar about 3/4 of the way through d1 and was all but insta cleared for it.
the next game i play with reddboiler he posts his notes just like that. i call him out for it saying he saw someone get cleared for it so he could easily be doing the same thing for credit. he was villaging.
lotr i dont recall him doing that and he was a wolf, but it was a mishmash so w/e
this game he does it again. but since it was so early and so inclusive (like every post is there somewhere)... it just feels insincere and way forced.
so im leaning towards reddboiler = w for that post
having said that, his tunneling timistere with some thin multiquotes is his typical villager tell
The bolded is freakign me out. He said I was tunneling Timi/Bhuber with "thin" multiquotes
Quote:
Originally Posted by bhuber2010
He's probably pissed he randed wolf.
His last few villager games were pretty on point (and he can be slanky as a wolf (disclaimer: I've read ~0 of his posts)).
Quote:
Originally Posted by Klairic
Would anyone be willing to post their motivation for voting bhuber2010/timistere, or gtpitch/kokiri? They're not standing out to me yet, so I'd love a little insight into it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by kokiri
Bhubers looks like an ok option, Iversonian still a good choice, thingy's working today, but i still would be happy to see him climbing the list.
Quote:
Originally Posted by LeonardoDicaprio
pitch has shown fairly little in the way of villagery posting. kokiri i thought was villagery yesterday but well named seems to think otherwise and i think the case that thingyman made on him earlier today may hold some water.
timi hasn't posted since very early on in the game and his posts were sketchy at best there. neither him nor bhuber bothered to be interested in who was lynched, and their vote stayed stagnant for the entire day. bhuber has had flashes of villagery tone but he's capable of it as a wolf.
basically the case is that everyone else(that has been posting) has done more villagery stuff than those people.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Klairic
So, to summarize, it's not that they seem wolfy, but rather that they don't seem villagery?
Ty, much appreciated. I'm going to make my strong pitch for Thingy soon...
Put these 3 quotes together because Klairic is asking about Bhuber and Kokiri when people are mentioning them as the wagons. He comes to the conslusion that Thingyman is a better vote than both of them.
Quote:
Originally Posted by gtpitch
I'm almost always way too easy on new players because I feel like they should be super easy to read and this post says "sup dudes, I'm a villager"
Pitch calling Klairic a villager.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Klairic
I'm ok with being a lock villager... as that's what I want to be perceived to be regardless of what side I'm on.
I think too many people make themselves difficult to read because they're afraid of getting voted out. I don't care if I go, it's a team game.
Quote:
Originally Posted by bhuber2010
Yeah, not saying its wolfy, just think they're really bad in general (nevermind that it draws conclusions that are actually wrong in this case).
If gpitch is a villager, this is a pretty poor effort in general.
His posting has actually been worse than iversonians IMO.
Klairic made about 6 posts and got like 3 villa leans/that would be impressive from a newer wolf; would like to see him post more/his partner post more though because it would be lolbad to clear them (like some people did with 'no lynches' in 3M and lol, he was a wolf).
This post - Bhuber basically calls GTPitch a wolf but ends up voting Iver > Gtpitch.
Quote:
bros i'm here
still cannot condone a gtpitch lynch, what is another option
Quote:
not lynching gtpitch
not lynching reddboiler
not lynching thingy
Self explanatory. 2nd quote looks like he jsut threw in me and thingy to look like he wasnt just protecting pitch even though Thingy and I were not even options at that point.
Quote:
klairic i've really only skimmed your posts but seriously
if you're a wolf do you spend an hour+ reading and quoting 2 other players games and come to the conclusion of "meh"?
Quote:
leo i agree
bhuber has been trending upwards though
Quote:
that's who i'm talking about
klairic tunneling on thingy at this point is a waste
Quote:
obviously i'm not the seer
but on the off chance gtpitch and reddboiler are both villagers
xkf was basically begging people not to lynch Pitch/Kokiri
Quote:
Originally Posted by DWetzel
PALPABLE RESISTANCE to lynching bhuber here
still time
Quote:
klairic you need to pick a wagon
Quote:
klairic nad kruze/leafs need to pick a wagon
Xkf telling Klairic to pick a wagon. This post strikes me as really bad because he could've been telling Klairic to go ahead and vote Ivers/Donk to save Kokiri/Pitch here. This was very near EOD2.
Still rereading.